Derrick Rose or Chris Paul? Who do you take?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted by Biggie62

Deron Williams > Chris Paul > Rondo > Westbrook > Derrick Rose

rajon rondo is nonexistent in 4th quarters and can't lead his team from behind. he can't knock down an 18 footer, and can't shoot free throws.

he's good, but he shouldn't be in this discussion.

that said, Paul/Williams > Westbrook > Rose > Rondo.

(that's assuming we're only talking new school of 1's.  Nash, Kidd, and TP didn't retire yet.)
 
Originally Posted by Biggie62

Deron Williams > Chris Paul > Rondo > Westbrook > Derrick Rose

rajon rondo is nonexistent in 4th quarters and can't lead his team from behind. he can't knock down an 18 footer, and can't shoot free throws.

he's good, but he shouldn't be in this discussion.

that said, Paul/Williams > Westbrook > Rose > Rondo.

(that's assuming we're only talking new school of 1's.  Nash, Kidd, and TP didn't retire yet.)
 
Williams>Paul>Rondo>Westbrook>Nash>Rose

28 shots and 3 FT's i the reason I can't put Pooh in that top 5. For a dude who is the most athletic PG I have ever seen and just a phenomenal athlete his lack of FT's is pretty confounding. He is so athletic he uses that ability too much to avoid contact instead of drawing it. Until he figures that out though which I think he will he'll be in that top group.
 
Williams>Paul>Rondo>Westbrook>Nash>Rose

28 shots and 3 FT's i the reason I can't put Pooh in that top 5. For a dude who is the most athletic PG I have ever seen and just a phenomenal athlete his lack of FT's is pretty confounding. He is so athletic he uses that ability too much to avoid contact instead of drawing it. Until he figures that out though which I think he will he'll be in that top group.
 
Originally Posted by airmaxpenny1

Williams>Paul>Rondo>Westbrook>Nash>Rose

28 shots and 3 FT's i the reason I can't put Pooh in that top 5. For a dude who is the most athletic PG I have ever seen and just a phenomenal athlete his lack of FT's is pretty confounding. He is so athletic he uses that ability too much to avoid contact instead of drawing it. Until he figures that out though which I think he will he'll be in that top group.

why beat up your body though? he attacks the basket, shoots a good percentage, and avoids injury.  look at what happens to guys like iverson and wade who look for contact.
 
Originally Posted by airmaxpenny1

Williams>Paul>Rondo>Westbrook>Nash>Rose

28 shots and 3 FT's i the reason I can't put Pooh in that top 5. For a dude who is the most athletic PG I have ever seen and just a phenomenal athlete his lack of FT's is pretty confounding. He is so athletic he uses that ability too much to avoid contact instead of drawing it. Until he figures that out though which I think he will he'll be in that top group.

why beat up your body though? he attacks the basket, shoots a good percentage, and avoids injury.  look at what happens to guys like iverson and wade who look for contact.
 
Originally Posted by Nako XL

Originally Posted by airmaxpenny1

Williams>Paul>Rondo>Westbrook>Nash>Rose

28 shots and 3 FT's i the reason I can't put Pooh in that top 5. For a dude who is the most athletic PG I have ever seen and just a phenomenal athlete his lack of FT's is pretty confounding. He is so athletic he uses that ability too much to avoid contact instead of drawing it. Until he figures that out though which I think he will he'll be in that top group.

why beat up your body though? he attacks the basket, shoots a good percentage, and avoids injury.  look at what happens to guys like iverson and wade who look for contact.
Yeah look at what happened to them.  They will go down as all time greats.
 
Originally Posted by Nako XL

Originally Posted by airmaxpenny1

Williams>Paul>Rondo>Westbrook>Nash>Rose

28 shots and 3 FT's i the reason I can't put Pooh in that top 5. For a dude who is the most athletic PG I have ever seen and just a phenomenal athlete his lack of FT's is pretty confounding. He is so athletic he uses that ability too much to avoid contact instead of drawing it. Until he figures that out though which I think he will he'll be in that top group.

why beat up your body though? he attacks the basket, shoots a good percentage, and avoids injury.  look at what happens to guys like iverson and wade who look for contact.
Yeah look at what happened to them.  They will go down as all time greats.
 
Wade won a championship by basically drawing contact going to the hoop, what are you talking bout dude?
 
Wade won a championship by basically drawing contact going to the hoop, what are you talking bout dude?
 
Originally Posted by and1play5

Im trying to tell this dude theres nothing d.rose can do that cp3 can't.
Not true at all.  Rose is quicker off the dribble and can finish in the paint better.  He is also stronger.
 
Originally Posted by and1play5

Im trying to tell this dude theres nothing d.rose can do that cp3 can't.
Not true at all.  Rose is quicker off the dribble and can finish in the paint better.  He is also stronger.
 
Originally Posted by jdizzle75

Originally Posted by and1play5

Im trying to tell this dude theres nothing d.rose can do that cp3 can't.
Not true at all.  Rose is quicker off the dribble and can finish in the paint better.  He is also stronger.

But there are quite a few things that Paul can do that Rose cant.  Which is why he is unquestionably the better player.
 
Originally Posted by jdizzle75

Originally Posted by and1play5

Im trying to tell this dude theres nothing d.rose can do that cp3 can't.
Not true at all.  Rose is quicker off the dribble and can finish in the paint better.  He is also stronger.

But there are quite a few things that Paul can do that Rose cant.  Which is why he is unquestionably the better player.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom