2016 MLB thread. THE CUBS HAVE BROKEN THE CURSE! Chicago Cubs are your 2016 World Series champions

Status
Not open for further replies.
Are the A's playoff-caliber?

There weren't many expectations for the Oakland Athletics entering this season. They made a splash for Yoenis Cespedes, but no one really knew what to make of the Cuban outfielder entering the season. The Josh Reddick trade seemed promising, as did the acquisition of Seth Smith, but they were tempered by the loss of Josh Willingham, to say nothing of the rebuilding tenor of the Trevor Cahill and Gio Gonzalez trades. Oakland started the season 29th in the ESPN Power Rankings, and when it came out of the gate slowly, the club seemed easy to dismiss.



But since the end of May, the A's have heated up. They posted their first winning record of the season in June, and they have been a house afire in July. They are 14-2 for the month, including a just-completed four-game sweep of the New York Yankees. As a result, they have moved up to a season-best 12th in the rankings this week.



The knock on Oakland, as we discussed two weeks ago, is always its offense. That is still the case, but will it become a crippling factor in Oakland's playoff hopes?




Where the A's stand
How American League teams have done in June-July in runs per game, runs allowed per game and run differential. (Sorted by the latter.)

Team RS/G RA/G Diff.
NYY 5.04 3.69 1.36
OAK 4.50 3.25 1.25
LAA 5.32 4.45 0.86
DET 4.82 4.22 0.60
BOS 4.69 4.13 0.56
TOR 5.16 5.09 0.07
CHW 4.52 4.48 0.05
TEX 4.23 4.21 0.02
TB 4.00 4.18 -0.18
SEA 3.77 4.11 -0.34
MIN 4.64 5.00 -0.36
CLE 4.38 4.89 -0.51
KC 4.24 4.96 -0.71
BAL 3.75 4.93 -1.18


Since the start of June, Oakland ranks just eighth in the American League in runs per game. Still, the A's have hit better than the Texas Rangers, whom they are chasing (see chart).



Texas has slipped while Oakland has gained a foothold in the standings, preventing the Rangers from running away with the division. And while they aren't the Rangers' only competition for the AL West crown, the A's are arguably playing better than the Los Angeles Angels right now as well. The Angels' rotation, and particularly Ervin Santana, has seen better days: Entering Sunday, their pitching staff was the only one in baseball that had been worth negative WAR this month.



Oakland's pitching staff, meanwhile, is running on all cylinders. We can see in the chart that the only team with a better run differential since the start of June is the Yankees, whom Oakland just finished browbeating. Tommy Milone and Jarrod Parker have stepped up in Brandon McCarthy's absence. Milone has had the tendency to go boom during road starts -- he has allowed six or more runs in three different road starts this season -- but he has shown that he can hang tough on the road against some offenses.



Parker simply has been good against everyone. After allowing two runs or fewer in 11 of his first 13 starts this season, the 23-year-old righty took a left and right cross, allowing six and four runs to the Seattle Mariners and Minnesota Twins, respectively, in consecutive starts. But before a panic could settle in, he held the Yankees to one run in eight innings Saturday, generating the best single-game WPA of his young career in the process.



A lot of the staff's success has to do with clamping down on walks. At the end of June, their BB/9 was 3.35, but in July it is 1.65 -- easily the best in the majors. The A's strike out fewer batters than most pitching staffs and don't generate as many ground balls as most teams, either. That formula is perfect at their spacious home park, which limits home runs.



Now, to be sure, there has been a little bit of good fortune involved in this run. It's pretty rare to have six walk-off wins so closely bunched together. But Oakland's 16-12 record in one-run games doesn't scream out as a regression candidate. It is the fifth-best winning percentage for such games in the majors this year, but it is grouped more with the teams that rank in the 10 spots behind them than it is with the top four spots (for instance, the Baltimore Orioles are No. 1 with a 19-6 record in one-run games). The A's also have played a tough schedule -- 58 of their 95 games have been against teams better than .500. The A's are 33-25 in those contests.



What's more, the lineup is no longer filled with easy outs. The outfield, in particular, has done a fantastic job. As David Schoenfield noted last night, Cespedes and Reddick have stood tall, but they have been joined by Jonny Gomes and Smith to give them four above-average hitting outfielders. All together, the outfield as a unit has a 121 wRC+, good for fifth in the game.



The team still could use some help, of course. Brandon Inge and Cliff Pennington are replaceable veterans, especially because Pennington is now on the disabled list. Oakland probably isn't excited at the possibility of taking on additional salary, but if it was, acquiring old friend Marco Scutaro and/or Chase Headley or Aramis Ramirez would help the offense.



The A's have played fantastic baseball the past two months, and in doing so have put themselves in the hunt for the playoffs. They are now tied for the lead in the wild-card race with the Angels and Orioles and don't appear to be a fluke. Both the starting pitching and the work from the bullpen has been tremendous, and if they get anything down the stretch from either McCarthy or Brett Anderson, they will become even more formidable.



It took the A's two months to get going, but continuing to overlook them would be unwise.



Paul Swydan covers baseball for ESPN Insider. He has been writing about baseball for various publications since 2005, and can most frequently be found writing for FanGraphs. You can find his ESPN archives here, and follow him on Twitter here.

Five best trade fits for Cole Hamels.

Philadelphia Phillies general manager Ruben Amaro Jr. and the agent for Cole Hamels continue to work toward a six-year deal that could get consummated early this week, and it's a contract that could wind up in the $140 million range and make Hamels one of the highest paid pitchers in baseball history.

However, it's always possible that those negotiations could stall, and Hamels could decide he wants to test the free agent market this winter. Amaro has always done his due diligence as GM of the Phillies, and he's prepared for such a scenario. While contract talks continue, Amaro is monitoring the trade market in advance of the July 31 trade deadline, and there are several clubs that would be willing to trade significant talent for Hamels, even for a two-month rental and even with the new collective bargaining agreement which says that you can't reap draft-pick compensation for a player who didn't spend the entire season with your club.

Before Sunday night's game between the Texas Rangers and Los Angeles Angels, I asked Rangers manager Ron Washington if his club would be willing to trade significant prospects for a rental. He said they would (although not top prospect Jurickson Profar) because you have to take advantage of their window to win a World Series. I also briefly spoke with Angels GM Jerry Dipoto who conveyed the trade market was extremely difficult this year with so many teams in the race, but was holding out hope they’d find a way to make a deal between now and the deadline.

If you're looking for the ideal trade fits for the Phillies and Hamels, if the two parties can't come to terms this week, you have to start with those two clubs mentioned above, but they're not the only possibilities. Here's a look at the five best trade fits for Cole Hamels.


1. Texas Rangers

Two years ago, the Rangers included Justin Smoak and Blake Beavan (two recent first-round picks) in a midseason deal for Cliff Lee, so we know GM Jon Daniels is not afraid to give up a lot to get a lot, not to mention the fact that Texas has one of the deepest systems in baseball. The Rangers will not trade Jurickson Profar -- arguably the top prospect in all of baseball -- but they would probably include third baseman Mike Olt, their second-best position prospect, or Martin Perez, their top pitching prospect, to get Hamels. They might have to include right-hander Tanner Scheppers or lefty Robbie Ross in the deal to get it done, but it’s package that is probably the most tempting of any of the clubs that would have interest in a rental. There are also some whispers that they might be willing to substitute Neftali Feliz if the Phillies wanted to take the health risk on him.




2. Los Angeles Angels

The Angels would have to include Garrett Richards or John Hellweg, who are their two top young starting pitching prospects, along with top infield prospect Jean Segura. The Phillies would like to get Peter Bourjos in the deal to solve their center field position for life after Shane Victorino, but the Angels want to hold on to him with Torii Hunter an impending free agent and questions where Mark Trumbo’s best long-term position will be.



3. Washington Nationals

Nats GM Mike Rizzo appears to be set on shutting down Stephen Strasburg at some point this season, a move that will take away the team's No. 1 starter before the postseason. The one way the Nationals could overcome that baseball decision would be to trade for Hamels. It's somewhat unlikely that the Phillies would trade Hamels within their division, but the Nationals have a good farm system, and if they dangled either third basemen Anthony Rendon (who's incredibly talented but seems to be injury prone) or right-hander Alex Meyer along with one of their mid-level bullpen prospects, the Phillies would have to listen. Rendon could solve third base for the next decade, or Meyer would give them a No. 3 starter who has potential for more. But as we've seen from the Nats with their handling of Strasburg, they are focused on the long term, so don't bet on them trading top prospects for a rental. Still, the pieces are there if they want to make a move.



4. Los Angeles Dodgers

The Dodgers could offer an impressive package of pitching prospects including right-hander Zach Lee and either righty Garrett Gould or southpaw Chris Reed. If the Phillies aren’t able to sign Hamels, a package of Lee and either Gould or Reed would be a nice return and more valuable than the draft-pick compensation they would get if Hamels leaves this winter. However, the Dodgers have an eye toward the future, and to give up that much of package, they would want a window to try and sign Hamels to a long-term contract, not to mention the fact that the Dodgers are considered the favorite to land Hamels if the SoCal native hits the market this winter.



5. St. Louis Cardinals

Like the Rangers, the Cardinals have one of the deeper systems in baseball and could easily build a package around top outfield prospect Oscar Taveras if they so choose. However, with Jaime Garcia progressing nicely in his rehab, it's hard to see the Cards paying such a premium for Hamels since they almost certainly would not re-sign him this winter. The New York Yankees, Chicago White Sox and Boston Red Sox would all love to have Hamels, but they just don’t match up as well as these other five teams in terms of need and prospect depth.

When it’s all said and done, I truly believe that Hamels will re-sign with the Phillies before July 31. But if negotiations quickly turn sour, I see the Rangers as the most likely destination, as they not only have the top prospects to deal, but also have the willingness to roll the dice even if it’s just for a rental.

Second Look: Fernandez, Taillon.

Jose Fernandez
Position: RHP
Level: High Class A Jupiter
Age: 20
Law's midseason ranking: 42




Fernandez was a first-round pick (14th overall) in the 2011 draft as a power arm from a Tampa high school with a powerful personal story as a Cuban defector. This has been a breakout season for him, and he has announced himself as one of the top pitching prospects in the game by carving up Sally League (low Class A) hitters. He earned a promotion to the Florida State League (high Class A) and had a dazzling showing at the Futures Game. I recently scouted Fernandez in his third FSL start in front of a boisterous cheering section in Tampa versus the Yankees affiliate (a team we'll cover later this week).

Fernandez came as advertised, with power stuff and big upside but clear areas for improvement. He isn't a typical lanky pitching prospect; instead, he has a thick lower half on an already mature 6-foot-2 frame. Fernandez was 96-98 mph in the first inning and worked 93-97, touching 98 mph for the duration of the start with a four-seam fastball that had only a little life on it, but plenty of velocity and solid command to both sides of the plate. He would only temporarily lose his release point, and he elevated with purpose for strikeouts. Fernandez didn't really miss up but also didn't live in the bottom of the zone; I counted five fly balls to one ground ball in this outing and his numbers show a persistent fly ball tendency. He also has a tendency to overthrow when he gets in a jam and to rely on his power arm.

Second Look
Here's a glimpse at the players we have covered -- and will be covering -- in our Second Look series in order of their spot on Keith Law's midseason top 50.

FEATURED PLAYERS


6. Taijuan Walker, Mariners
11. Jameson Taillon, Pirates
12. Christian Yelich, Marlins
18. Byron Buxton, Twins
19. Julio Teheran, Braves
20. Carlos Correa, Astros
21. Mason Williams, Yankees
24. Danny Hultzen, Mariners
27. Billy Hamilton, Reds
28. Gary Sanchez, Yankees
33. Hak Ju Lee, Rays
34. Matt Davidson, Diamondbacks
42. Jose Fernandez, Marlins
45. Tyler Austin, Yankees
49. Zach Lee, Dodgers
Fernandez uses his curveball liberally as an out pitch, and it's a true hammer. It has inconsistent shape and a wide 79-85 mph velocity range with depth, sweep, late bite and three-quarter tilt. Normally this inconsistency would mean he didn't have great feel for the pitch, but Fernandez had an uncanny ability to spot this pitch to both sides of the plate in order to freeze hitters; he also used it as a chase pitch and in the dirt. During warm-ups, he threw a changeup at 85-87 that flashed above-average potential, but in the game he was getting under it and couldn't throw it for a strike.



The reason Fernandez's curveball has shape and speed inconsistencies -- and that he can't spot his changeup -- is his delivery. His arm action is short and clean, and he hides the ball behind his body well, but he sets up on the first-base side of the rubber and strides past the midline of the mound. This crossfire angle causes him to throw across his body and makes it very difficult to stay on top of the ball and to finish his arm stroke consistently and completely.



Fernandez shows feel for his delivery, and this extreme angle may keep his front hip from flying open but it kills his chances to throw an effective changeup. Right now, Fernandez is a power arm that explodes at the plate, showing little finesse but flashing some feel. To reach his potential as a No. 2 starter, he'll need to learn to downshift at times but already has a floor of late-inning reliever.



Jameson Taillon
Position: RHP
Level: High Class A Bradenton
Age: 20
Law's midseason ranking: 10 | Preaseason ranking: 16




Taillon is another heralded prep arm. He was the second overall pick in the 2010 draft, from a Texas high school, and there are big expectations in his second pro season. Because of the Pirates' relatively strict approach to pitcher development, this is Taillon's first year with a chance to use his full arsenal in games; pitchers are told to throw an overwhelming amount of heaters in their first year to develop command of their fastball.



I've seen Taillon four times this year -- as recently as last Friday -- and he's shown the advertised power stuff. He'll sit at 94-96 and touch 98 mph with occasional hard, two-seam life and solid-average command at times. Taillon complements it with a true plus-plus hammer curve at 83-86 that he can spot in the zone or use as a chase pitch with 11-to-5 tilt and devastating late bite and depth. His curve was inconsistent early in the season, but Taillon has had more consistent feel recently as the shape, consistency and command of his hook have improved. Although he is a true power arm, Taillon has shown some aptitude for a changeup that flashes above-average potential -- but he'll throw it as hard as 90 mph, which is too hard relative to his fastball. There's still some work to do with this offering, and it will always be a clear third pitch for him.



Taillon's performance has been below expectations this year (4.27 ERA, 78 K's in 97 IP) and I'm a little concerned he may have trouble reaching his potential as a No. 1 starter. He has a slightly awkward arm action that goes far behind his body. This makes it easy for hitters to follow the ball and creates length that makes his arm late to catch up with his body. When he is even slightly out of sync, it's clear, because his arm gets even later and he starts spinning hard off the mound. Bottom-of-the-order hitters in A-ball still square him up more than you'd expect, a knock that came up in high school as he was too hittable for a pitcher with his stuff.



I still think Taillon has a chance to be a No. 1 starter, but his odds of reaching that upside have lowered this year. It's hard to give up on a pitcher who will regularly show two 70 pitches on the 20-80 scouting scale, and flash solid-average command and an above-average changeup out of a strong 6-6, 225-pound frame.



Kiley McDaniel has worked in the scouting departments of the New York Yankees, Baltimore Orioles and Pittsburgh Pirates, and has previously written for Baseball Prospectus.

How Mark Trumbo has improved.

After making arguably the biggest splash in free agency this past winter -- signing both the premier positional (Albert Pujols) and pitching (C.J. Wilson) free agents -- the Los Angeles Angels suffered through a dismal first month, posting a 9-15 record and a run differential of minus-10. It was thought that by adding Wilson to an already dominant pitching staff (and above-average defense), the Angels would benefit from arguably the best run prevention in the majors.



But while the Angels have the 11th-best ERA in the league (ninth-best park-adjusted ERA), their run prevention to this point has actually been worse than last year (sixth-best ERA, fourth-best park-adjusted ERA in 2011).



Still, fast-forward 2½ months, and the Angels currently find themselves seven games above .500 with a run differential of plus-43, sitting atop the American League wild-card standings. The biggest improvement for the Angels has been the offense, which is the fourth-best park-adjusted offense in baseball (106 wRC+) behind the division rival Texas Rangers (108 wRC+). That's a 10 percent improvement from last year's Angels team.



Pujols has been good, but he hasn't been otherworldly. That descriptor has generally been reserved for super rookie Mike Trout, who accounts for roughly 16 percent of the team's run creation. And while Trout has indeed shown that he is a once-in-a-generation player, he's not the only Angel having a breakout year. Mark Trumbo has quietly elevated his game significantly and has been a driving force in pulling the Angels out of their early-season struggles and back into postseason contention.




In his rookie campaign in 2011, Trumbo displayed the power that many observers and scouts had dreamed of, belting 29 home runs and 31 doubles. But despite posting the 24th-highest isolated power in history for a rookie with at least 550 plate appearances (.223), Trumbo was only 5 percent better offensively than league average. The reason? His inability to avoid outs.



Only 11 players posted an on-base percentage lower than Trumbo's .291 in 2011. For all of his power, Trumbo headed back to the dugout more than 70 percent of the time. Sluggers can typically make up for their lack of batting average with superior plate discipline, but Trumbo simply didn't walk enough to balance out his .254 batting average. In his 573 plate appearances last year, Trumbo posted a walk rate of only 4.4 percent. That was easily one of the worst rates in history for a rookie with more than 550 plate appearances (ranking 391st out of 433 such seasons).



But this season, Trumbo has improved his OBP nearly 70 points. His walk rate has increased to 7 percent. Although that's still not a high number, it represents almost a 60 percent improvement from last year. Trumbo has significantly reduced the number of balls he swings at outside the strike zone (36.6 percent in 2012 versus 41 percent in '11). He isn't seeing more pitches per plate appearance this year, but he is not helping pitchers out as much by chasing balls outside the strike zone.



Trumbo's increased discipline is also reflected in his ability to avoid outs when putting the ball in play. Trumbo has seen his batting average jump to .303 through Saturday's games, an improvement of nearly 50 points. Given that his strikeout rate is unchanged (roughly 21 percent this season and last), this boost is entirely the result of a better batting average on balls in play. This, of course, raises a question as to whether Trumbo has seen his average jump thanks to randomness or good fortune, or whether it's the result of an actual change.



By decreasing his number of swings outside the strike zone, Trumbo is increasing the odds that he'll square pitches up better when he puts the ball in play. This is reflected in the 10 percent decrease in Trumbo's infield fly-ball rate (17.3 percent last year versus 7 percent this year). Trumbo is simply swinging at more pitches located in zones that align with his natural power. As a result, Trumbo's isolated power has jumped to .317.



Trumbo's altered approach also can be seen in terms of where he's hitting the ball. According to Baseball Heat Maps, Trumbo is pulling fly balls and home runs significantly more in 2012. For right-handed hitters with at least 50 fly balls and home runs in 2012 and 2011, Trumbo has the third-highest increase in pull angle. This increase in pull angle has been accompanied by an increase in the average distance of these batted balls (11 feet).



Another hitter in the American League has seen a similar change in approach translate into increased power and production. Toronto Blue Jays infielder Edwin Encarnacion's 100 point jump in isolated power is partially the result of the seventh-highest increase in pull angle and hitting the ball 12.5 feet farther on average.



When the season ends, Trumbo is unlikely to finish with a batting average higher than .300. However, the young slugger has clearly made adjustments to his hitting approach that are fueling his remarkable season. These changes suggest that an above-average OBP and elite ISO are both outcomes that Trumbo can replicate over time and not simply the result of randomness.



If so, the Angels will have an unexpected offensive cornerstone under their control through at least 2016.



Bill Petti writes for FanGraphs.com.

Rumors.

Market impact of Dempster trade
11:26
AM ETMarket for starting pitchers Recommend7Comments2EmailIt's being reported Monday that the Chicago Cubs and Atlanta Braves are close to completing a trade that will send right-hander Ryan Dempster to the National League East contenders, likely in exchange for prospects or young big league pitching. ESPN.com's Jayson Stark tweets that the deal is far enough along that it could be completed sometime Monday afternoon.

CBSSports.com reports that Randall Delgado may be the return package for Dempster.

If the deal gets done it will leave the Los Angeles Dodgers, among others, without one of their main targets and sets the market for rental pitchers. The Dodgers are said to be in on Matt Garza.

Whatever the Cubs get for Dempster will likely be significantly less than the trade hauls for right-hander Zack Greinke, in whom the Braves have expressed interest, and left-hander Cole Hamels, if the Phillies cannot get him signed to a long-term extension.

The Dempster trade could serve as the first domino in a flurry of deals involving starting pitchers over the next 7-8 days. Greinke's teammate Shaun Marcum could also be moved, as could Houston's Wandy Rodriguez, Seattle's Jason Vargas and Kevin Millwood and Tampa's James Shields.

The Angels, Rangers, Red Sox, Reds, Tigers and Nationals are among the clubs being linked to starters this month.

- Jason A. Churchill
Tags:Ryan Dempster, Atlanta Braves, Chicago Cubs, Los Angeles Dodgers, Detroit Tigers
Giants seek relief help
9:40
AM ETSan Francisco Giants Recommend1Comments0EmailThe San Francisco Giants, who are not entirely comfortable with Santiago Casilla as the replacement for Brian Wilson, are keeping their eye on Indians closer Chris Perez, reports FoxSports.com.

The report says the Indians could consider moving Perez since they are deep in relievers and because Perez likely will earn about $7 million next season in his second year of arbitration.

Another closer who could be on the market is Heath Bell now that the Marlins are in sell-off mode, says Ken Rosenthal. The Giants couldn't be blamed for trying to acquire Bell at a very deep discount and hope that a change of scenery does wonders for a pitcher who had three 40-save seasons before a disastrous 2012.

- Doug Mittler
Tags:Josh Bell, Chris Perez, Cleveland Indians, San Francisco Giants
Rangers step up pitching search
9:18
AM ETTexas Rangers Recommend2Comments0EmailPerhaps lost in the shuffle of Mondays trades around baseball is the pitching issues bereft the Texas Rangers. Not only are there questions surrounding the reliability of Derek Holland and the role of Neftali Feliz when he returns from the disabled list, but Roy Oswalt is struggling and has an ailing back that required treatment, and now the club has learned that Colby Lewis is out of the rest of the season.

The Rangers have been linked, mostly by common sense, to every potentially-available arm in baseball, including Matt Garza, James Shields and Wandy Rodriguez. The club's top pitching prospect, Martin Perez, may be among the best options for the time being and Feliz's timetable could impact the team's pursuit of pitching.

Ryan Dempster is mulling over a trade to the Atlanta Braves, but if he turns it down could be an option for the Rangers. Dempster had full no-trade rights and is slated for free agency following the season. The Rangers may be most keen on impact starters such as Zack Greinke and Cole Hamels, but may have to part with third base prospect Mike Olt in a package to get either one. ESPN The Magazine's Buster Olney writes in Tuesday's blog that the Rangers are looking for "elite talent" such as Hamels or Greinke.

There was speculation last week that the Rangers also could be looking to bring back lefthander Cliff Lee.

As for possible trade bait, Rangers manager Ron Washington tells ESPN Insider's Jim Bowden that any deal will not include top shortstop prospect Jurickson Profar.

- Doug Mittler and Jason A. Churchill
Tags:Colby Lewis, Texas Rangers, Miami Marlins, Milwaukee Brewers, Houston Astros, Tampa Bay Rays, Matt Garza, James Shields
Nats interested in Greinke
9:13
AM ETZack Greinke | Brewers Recommend2Comments2EmailThe Washington Nationals are among the teams interested in Brewers right-hander Zack Greinke, but they might not have the resources to pull off a deal, reports Ken Rosenthal.

The Nationals traded four prospects to the Athletics to land Gio Gonzalez and they may not be willing or able to provide the young talent the Brewers would demand in any Greinke deal. The Brewers should be more willing to shop Greinke after their losing streak reached four games Monday.

Washington is believed to be looking for a veteran arm given the expected shutdown of Stephen Strasburg later this summer.

- Doug Mittler
Tags:Milwaukee Brewers, Zack Greinke, Washington Nationals
Suitors for Headley
8:58
AM ETChase Headley | Padres Recommend4Comments2EmailLast Monday, ESPN Insider's Jim Bowden tweeted that six teams had expressed interest in San Diego Padres third baseman Chase Headley, and added that the switch hitter would be traded before the deadline "in all likelihood."

The Los Angeles Dodgers have been linked to Headley in recent weeks and other clubs needing third base help include the Philadelphia Phillies, Seattle Mariners, Los Angeles Angels, Baltimore Orioles and Atlanta Braves. Sunday, ESPN The Magazine's Buster Olney tweeted that the A's are among those interested in Headley.

Olney reported Monday via Twitter that the Padres have asked the Pirates significant package of prospects in return for Headley, which flies with previous reports that the Friars would ask for the moon.

Headley, 28, will be arbitration eligible for the second time after this season and will not be free-agent eligible until after the 2014 season, making him a long-term fix for whichever club lands him.

Dan Connolly writes in Tuesday's Baltimore Sun that Headley is among the players on the Orioles' radar.

Tags:

Chase Headley, San Diego Padres
Ichiro's role in the Bronx
8:29
AM ETIchiro Suzuki | Yankees Recommend3Comments1EmailThe Seattle Mariners have done the unthinkable -- something I have been calling the Fight Club on the Emerald City. Ichiro Suzuki has been traded to the New York Yankees for two minor league pitchers. The Mariners will cover all but $2.25 million of the right fielder's remaining salary for 2012.

Ichiro, who has experience in center field, is likely to help fill the gaps in the Yankees' outfield left by the injuries to Brett Gardner, who may be out for the year, and Nick Swisher, who is nursing a minor injury and will be back. Joe Girardi said during the press conference Monday afternoon that Ichiro will mainly play left field for the Yankees.

After nearly 12 seasons with the Mariners, Ichiro is set to hit free agency after the season and a big question in Seattle of late has been centered on whether or not he would be brought back next year. Ichiro will suit up against his former team this week as the Yankees visit Seattle starting Monday night.

The Mariners will continue to use Casper Wells and Michael Saunders in center, but one of them could now begin playing right field -- most likely Wells -- with Ichiro now out of the mix. Carlos Peguero could gain more playing time.

- Jason A. Churchill



Buster Olney
Will the Ichiro experiment work?

"There are other hitters who get on base more, who hit for more power, who are better suited to take advantage of the dimensions in Yankee Stadium. Ichiro is still a good outfielder, and he can run. There are many other outfielders who have those two particular skills. If it doesn't go well, manager Joe Girardi is going to have to immediately feel comfortable with the idea of pinch-hitting for an all-time great. He will have to fight empathy, in making his choices. He may feel compelled to play him purely out of a sense of deference to Ichiro's extraordinary history."
Tags:New York Yankees, Seattle Mariners, Ichiro Suzuki
O's interested in Polanco
8:23
AM ETPlacido Polanco | Phillies Recommend2Comments1EmailThe Baltimore Orioles are in the market to add a corner infield bat and one of the targets is Phillies third baseman Placido Polanco, reports Dan Connolly of the Baltimore Sun.

The Orioles' interest, may be tempered after Phils manager Charlie Manuel revealed Polanco has been battling a sore back for at least a week. Polanco was not in the lineup Monday against Milwaukee and was scheduled to be examined by a team doctor.

Any deal, of course, will depend on Polanco getting a clean bill of health. Polanco, who is making $6.25 million this year and has a $5.5 million option next season, would be an upgrade at third base over Wilson Betemit.

Connolly adds the Orioles also are interested in San Diego's Chase Headley and the Cubs' Bryan LaHair.

- Doug Mittler
Tags:tongue:lacido Polanco, Baltimore Orioles, Philadelphia Phillies
Rays eye Ryan Roberts
8:04
AM ETRyan Roberts | Diamondbacks Recommend2Comments0EmailThe Tampa Bay Rays, looking for some depth at third base, are interested in Diamondbacks infielder Ryan Roberts, tweets Tim Brown of Yahoo Sports.

Roberts could provide another bat at third base while Evan Longoria continues to recovers from a hamstring injury. The Rays, however, may not be willing to overpay since Jeff Keppinger has filled in admirably at third base with seven hits in his last 14 at-bats.

- Doug Mittler
Tags:Ryan Roberts, Arizona Diamondbacks, Tampa Bay Rays
Duda could be demoted
7:47
AM ETLucas Duda | Mets Recommend1Comments0EmailLucas Duda, who has had the lion's share of starts in right field for the New York Mets this season, is in danger of being demoted to the minor leagues on Tuesday, reports Adam Rubin of ESPNNewYork.com.

Duda appeared to be out of danger when the Mets demoted Pedro Beato after Monday's game, apparently to clear a roster spot for Matt Harvey, who will start Thursday in Arizona. But the Mets announced Manny Acosta would return from Triple-A Buffalo, again leaving Duda in trouble.

Duda is hitting .140 with one homer in July, dropping his average to .241.

- Doug Mittler
Tags:Lucas Duda, New York Mets
The market for Josh Johnson
7:29
AM ETJosh Johnson | Marlins Recommend1Comments0EmailThe Miami Marlins traded Anibal Sanchez to the Detroit Tigers on Monday as part of a multi-player deal, fueling speculation the Fish is inclined to deal a more prominent pitcher.

Josh Johnson's start against Atlanta on Monday night was heavily scouted, although Scott Miller hears the Marlins are inclined to keep the righthander since he is under club control through 2013. In addition, Johnson left Monday's 2-1 win after six innings with a blister on his right middle finger, which could be an issue for acquiring clubs.

MLB.com's Alden Gonzalez says Johnson is an arm the Angels would consider, adding that any deal would probably have to include center fielder Peter Bourjos, who the Marlins have coveted.

Prior to Monday's deal with Detroit, a report by Chris Cwik of CBSSports.com said the Red Sox were interested in Sanchez and Johnson.

- Doug Mittler
Tags:Josh Johnson, Miami Marlins
Marlins could keep selling
7:09
AM ETMiami Marlins Recommend2Comments1EmailThe Miami Marlins appear to be in full sell mode after making a deal with the Detroit Tigers Monday that sent right-hander Anibal Sanchez to Motown Omar Infante and perhaps other pieces for package including right-hander Jacob Turner.

If the Fish continue to shop veterans, right-hander Ricky Nolasco could be next, and it may not be out of the question that they consider moving Hanley Ramirez.

Ramirez was rumored to be the subject of talks between the Marlins and the Red Sox earlier this month, but that was shot down as a concept only, at least for now. Scott Miller of CBSSports.com hears the Marlins "have never been more open" to the idea of dealing Ramirez.


Josh Johnson's name has always been mentioned as a possibility but the club might be selling low if they traded their ace this season, as the right-hander hasn't performed as he up to his own standards.

- Jason A. Churchill
Tags:Jacob Turner, Anibal Sanchez, Miami Marlins, Detroit Tigers
Chapman could start in 2013
6:57
AM ETAroldis Chapman | Reds Recommend0Comments1EmailAroldis Chapman has settled in nicely as the Cincinnati Reds' closer, a role he will have for the rest of the year. But Reds manager Dusty Baker hinted that Chapman could return to the rotation in 2013, reports John Fay of the Cincinnati Enquirer.

Chapman has a 1.58 ERA and 17 saves.

Baker's comments are not a complete surprise since Chapman prepared in spring training to start and only moved to the bullpen due to injuries to Ryan Madson, Nick Masset and Bill Bray.

- Doug Mittler
Tags:Aroldis Chapman, Cincinnati Reds
Phils optimistic on Hamels deal?
6:45
AM ETCole Hamels | Phillies Recommend6Comments14EmailWe are exactly one week from the trade deadline, and the Philadelphia Phillies have one eye on the calendar as they try to hammer out a long-term extension with Cole Hamels.

ESPN.com's Jerry Crasnick says the contract talks are expected to heat up in the next few days and are approaching a "sensitive" stage. The Phillies need to save themselves a window to renew talks with potential trade partners if they can't reach a deal with Hamels.

Jim Salisbury of CSNPhilly.com reports there is "a feeling of optimism" around the Phillies camp that Hamels will eventually agree to an extension.

Ken Rosenthal reports Monday that the extension talks will accelerate this week and hears that Hamel is "conflicted" as to how to proceed.

The discussion between the Phillies and Boggs likely started with the five-year, $112.5 million extension signed by San Francisco right-hander Matt Cain in April, a deal that actually guarantees him six years and $127.5 million when his salary for 2012 is considered.

In Friday's New York Post, Joel Sherman cites two executives they believed the Phillies would go at least six years at $130 million to keep Hamels. One of those executives says the only reason Hamels would turn that down would be a desire to return home (Hamels is a Southern California native) and pitch for the Dodgers.

- Doug Mittler



Jim Bowden
Best fit for Hamels

"When it's all said and done, I truly believe that Hamels will re-sign with the Phillies before July 31. But if negotiations quickly turn sour, I see the Rangers as the most likely destination, as they not only have the top prospects to deal, but also have the willingness to roll the dice even if it's just for a rental."
Tags:Cole Hamels, Texas Rangers, Los Angeles Angels, Los Angeles Dodgers, Detroit Tigers
Pirates pursue Maholm
6:19
AM ETPaul Maholm | Cubs Recommend6Comments0EmailRyan Dempster and Matt Garza are not be the only Chicago Cubs' starters drawing interest. Don't forget veteran lefthander Paul Maholm, whose trade value has risen thanks to a 4-0 record and a 0.89 ERA in his last five starts.

Maholm has emerged as a lower-priced alternative for teams such as the Pirates who are unlikely to add a Zack Greinke or a Cole Hamels. Maholm would be owed about $1.75 million on the remainder of a one-year, $4.75 million deal he signed in the offseason.

Maholm will make his next two starts against the Pirates, including Tuesday night at PNC Park. The southpaw has heard all the rumors, telling the Tribune Review it would be ?ironic? to re-join the team that let him walk as a free agent.

- Doug Mittler
 
Colby Lewis done for the year with forearm issues...

Rangers trade countdown for Hamels or Greinke in 3... 2... 1... :smh:
 
Finding Fits For Hanley Ramirez.

Yesterday, the Marlins officially declared themselves sellers, as they shipped Anibal Sanchez and Omar Infante off to Detroit for a group of prospects headlined by pitcher Jacob Turner. Within hours of completing that deal, rumors began to swirl that teams were also scouting Josh Johnson and that the Marlins were definitely open to moving Hanley Ramirez. Johnson makes sense for contenders shopping for a non-rental starting pitcher, and I expect he’ll be in heavy demand over the next week, with the Marlins able to command a strong return for their ace if they do decide to move him. However, when it comes to their mercurial third baseman, finding the right fit for a deal isn’t going to be quite as easy.

The primary issue with trading Ramirez is that he simply hasn’t been very good for a couple of years now. Since the start of last season, he’s hit just .245/.328/.405 in 776 plate appearances, good for a .323 wOBA that puts him in the same class of hitter as guys like Jeff Francoeur, Bobby Abreu, and Johnny Damon. That’s a far cry from the .393 wOBA he posted from 2006 to 2010, when he was on the same level as Mark Teixeira, Jim Thome, and Ryan Braun.

Ramirez’s regression at the plate last year was mostly written off as a function of injuries, as he spent time on the DL with back and shoulder problems, and ended up playing in just 92 games last season. However, he’s been healthy enough to play regularly this year, and his performance is nearly identical to what he posted a year ago. While he’s gotten a bit of his power back, it’s come at the expense of fewer walks and more strikeouts, so the overall package has still just added up to an average hitter.

Some players can be extremely valuable while producing league average offense — Elvis Andrus and Matt Wieters, for instance — but Hanley Ramirez is not a good defensive player, and the move to third base hasn’t seemed to help him much. In addition, his previous exploits running the bases have slowed way down, and he’s only been successful on 34 of 48 stolen base attempts the last two years. A 70% base stealer isn’t adding much in the way of value, so right now, Ramirez’s entire value is tied up in how well he hits. And for that kind of player, a league average wOBA just won’t cut it.

So, any team acquiring Ramirez has to be willing to accept that present day Ramirez is not the Ramirez of several years ago. He’s just 28, so there’s reason to believe that he could rebound, but that’s more hope than substance at this point. Today’s version of Hanley Ramirez is an average player without a defined position, and one that is due $31.5 million over the next two years. At that kind of price, you can’t just hope that there’s some rebound potential — you need it to be likely in order to justify the salary, especially if the Marlins are going to ask for legitimate talent in return.

Given what’s left on his contract, there are probably two kinds of deals that make sense for Ramirez — a large revenue team just taking his contract off Miami’s hands for little or no talent in return, or a smaller revenue club surrendering a real prospect in exchange for the Marlins paying some of the freight to ship him out of town. Given that the Marlins just opened their new stadium and don’t want to bring back memories of previous cost-cutting fire sales, the latter probably makes more sense, as it’s easier to convince your fan base that you aren’t going cheap if you’re kicking in cash in order to give the fans a shiny new young player with which to identify.

So, that’s the criteria – small-to-mid revenue team in need of an upside play on offense that is willing to sacrifice future talent in an effort to upgrade in the short term. Ken Rosenthal suggested the Oakland A’s, but they might be too small in terms of revenues to make it fit. They opened the year with a $53 million payroll, and so even if the Marlins picked up $5 million each of the next two years, Ramirez would represent 20% of their total Major League budget. You can make that kind of bet on a superstar, but probably not a guy with the risks associated with Ramirez. The Marlins would probably have to eat something closer to $8-$10 million per year to make it work for the A’s financially, and at that kind of cost, the Marlins asking price in terms of talent might be too high to have it make sense for a team that might just be in the wild card trap.

The Orioles also have been mentioned as a possibility, but Wilson Betemit offers a very similar average-offense-and-bad-defense combination at the hot corner, and the Orioles have more pressing issues elsewhere (read: pitching) if they’re looking to upgrade. They have the payroll necessary to take on most of Hanley’s contract, but they’re probably better served focusing on other parts of their roster and continuing with the youth movement, given that sustainable success in the AL East requires a commitment to developing from within. I wouldn’t count them out, but I think there’s a better fit for Hanley within their same division, just across the northern border.

The Toronto Blue Jays have been perpetually stuck in the middle of the AL East, and while Alex Anthopolous has done a remarkable job of undoing some of the damage done to the organization before he took over, the team has yet to make the leap from solid team to legitimate contender. Their firm stance on long term contract avoidance means that their upcoming payroll flexibility might be better used to acquire a player already under contract rather than trying to negotiate for a coveted player in free agency. And, as we’ve seen with Jose Bautista and Edwin Encarnacion, Toronto is a terrific place for a talented right-handed power hitter to get his career back on track.

Whatever They’re Calling The Skydome Now inflates home runs by right-handers by 5%, triples by 21%, and doubles by 2%, so the Jays would offer a nice landing spot for Ramirez to start tapping into his previous power once again. And, as we’ve seen from their willingness to take Colby Rasmus and Yunel Escobar, the Jays aren’t afraid of taking players that have worn out their welcome with their previous organization. In terms of environment, Toronto is probably one of the best possible places for Ramirez to get his career back on track.

The question would be positional fit. With Brett Lawrie catching everything hit towards third base, Ramirez would probably have to change positions again in order to fit in Toronto. That would leave the team with two options: give him his old job at shortstop back or convert him into the outfielder he was meant to be from the start.

Yunel Escobar hasn’t hit much this year and it’s rumored that the Jays wouldn’t mind getting rid of him, so the team could make a pair of moves that swaps out defense for offense at short and hope that Lawrie has enough range to compensate for the fact that Ramirez isn’t much of a shortstop. The defensive downgrade might outweigh most of the offensive gains, though, and they’d be selling low on Escobar, so instead, the Jays should push for Ramirez to accept a new role as an outfielder.

As a strong armed athletic guy with speed who struggles making basic plays on ground balls hit right at him, the outfield is almost certainly where Ramirez would have his most defensive value. In fact, with a bit of work, it’s not hard to see Ramirez becoming a quality defensive outfielder, as he has the physical tools to run down balls in the gap that most corner outfielders can’t get to. While the Jays are currently experimenting with Anthony Gose and Travis Snider in the corners while Jose Bautista is on the shelf, neither have Ramirez’s present offensive abilities and they probably don’t have his upside either.

Gose, in particular, might be an intriguing trade chip for the Marlins, where he could take over as their center fielder of the future, a position that is currently blocked in Toronto by the presence of Colby Rasmus. He’s the kind of talent that they’d likely eat a substantial portion of Ramirez’s contract in order to acquire, and a Gose-for-Ramirez-and-lots-of-cash swap could end up being beneficial to both franchises.

With Bautista, Encarnacion, and Ramirez, the Jays would have three right-handed bats who can take advantage of the ballpark, and a career resurgence from Hanley could propel the team into legitimate contender status. They probably won’t run down the Yankees this year, but a move like this could make their September games a bit more interesting and set them up to make a run at the division title for the next several years.

Ramirez has his warts, but that’s the main reasons he’s available to begin with. The Blue Jays have overlooked downside in a chase for talent before, and if they’re willing to do it again, they could end up buying low on a talented player who could push them into relevance once again.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Ichiro Suzuki, Hideki Matsui and BABIP Aging.

Two players I have always rather enjoyed — Ichiro Suzuki and Hideki Matsui — are in the twilights of their careers. And not only that, they are both having relatively miserable seasons at the plate.

At present, Suzuki is at a career-low 77 wRC+ and .281 wOBA. Matsui — playing in a reserve/pinch-hitting role for the first time in his career — has a disastrous 18 wRC+ and .195 wOBA. But both of these players have unusually low BABIPs and it is hard to know for certain if there has been a change in true talent levels or if this is random variation coupled with only mild aging.

In his reaction piece to the Ichiro trade, Eric Seidman rightly observed that Ichiro’s numbers should improve as he transitions from what has become an offensive deadzone in Safeco Park to the lefty-friendly grounds of Yankee Stadium, but how much can we expect his BABIP to improve? And what can the Rays expect from a 38-year-old Matsui, who may be needed more than ever with Luke Scott back on the DL?

Recent history suggests that both players are having abnormally bad BABIP, and they should improve if given consistent playing time through the rest of the season. But whether teams want to — or should — take that risk is another matter.

Biases Confessed
It is important to that readers understand my bias: I am a fan of both Ichiro and Matsui. I have a soft spot for aging veterans as well. It is important these biases are made plain because I hope to convince the reader of the legitimacy of my findings without the suspicion of self-serving motives.

When I began this study, I did so under the honest desire to find truth, not to trick myself, not to trick readers, and not to manipulate data in any way. My findings have flaws, my buckets have holes, and my data has problems, but none of these are extraordinary, none of these problems — in my understanding (which is apt to change) — is beyond what any other normal study has. Moreover, I think the findings are simple and loose and intuitive, so I hope few people will bristle at my suggestions.

Data Selection and Survivor/Confirmation Bias
First of all, let’s look at aging. From 2000 through 2011, there were 59 players aged 36 or older who put together a full season at the plate (a “qualified” amount of PA, which in this case has a minimum of 507 PA). This will be our Old Guys Bucket.

One of the great difficulties of any aging study is picking the right group. Especially in the MLB, there is the rampant problem of survivor bias and confirmation bias. The survivor bias comes via the players available — only good players make it to old age, and only players who are good in their old age get to keep playing. Very few players get to Chipper Jones their way to retirement — most of them Vladimir Guerrero their way into oblivion. And so my buckets will invariably include players who have done well — but hopefully it will also include a share of bad last seasons. For instance, Edgar Martinez had a -0.2 WAR season in 2004, and at age 41, he’s thankfully in the bucket. This helps balance things out because we don’t want to look at just the tails of the data, the extraordinary players that no one could have predicted — but for the purposes of this research, survivor should hopefully not be an issue. We are looking within careers, not really comparing across careers.

Confirmation bias makes an appearance in the playing time issue. Let’s say Ichiro has just been crazy unlucky and his skills haven’t eroded at all. Well, too bad. The Yankees have enough depth to play Ichiro according to his strengths, which likely means reduced playing time. And because we know all players eventually decline in their ability, we fully expect at least part of Ichiro’s drop off to be aging related — if not all of it. So, when he struggles, it confirms our expectations.

When Giambi struggled in 2009, and his BABIP dropped to .228, it was easy to believe that the veteran slugger has simply lost his hitting skill. He was 38 and had a 97 wRC+. Since then, however, he has not posted a BABIP below .284 (he has a career .297 BABIP) and he has been a useful hitter from the bench for the Rockies. Similar glowing things could have said about 34-year-old Jim Thome in 2005, who’s BABIP dropped to .256 with a, 89 wRC+. (Thome has not had a BABIP, by the way, under .300 for the last four seasons. Wow.)

So both of these issues — survivor bias and confirmation bias — are swirling around and playing with the available data. In the ideal aging study, every single MLB player gets 1500 PA per year until their 50th birthday, but alas, we do not have such luxuries.

What we do have are these 59 players — guys who have played with modern medical science, who have played in roughly the same run environments (these players are 2000 to 2008 heavy) and who did not suffer the penalties due pinch-hitters and bench players.

Of theses 59 hitters, they had a combined 112 split seasons aged 36 or older. We have 45 seasons of 36-year-olds, 31 seasons of 37-year-olds and the final four ages have groups of 15, 12, 6 and 3, respectively.

This, as if it needs emphasis, is not a big group. Remember that fact (I say this to myself as much as to the reader) when looking at the findings.

In the Old Guys Bucket, the average and median drop in BABIP (season BABIP minus career BABIP) was only 11 points. At the same time, it appears that most players, when looking at the distribution of those bad BABIP seasons, had their BABIP fall at least a little:



NOTE: Not all 112 season names can fit on the horizontal axis, but rest assured, they are all there. Click to enlarge the image.

We can see the majority of 36-or-older players cannot replicate their youthful BABIPs. It is worth noting here that the end of the aughties and beginning of the 2010s was the beginning of a reduced-BABIP era, and all these players are moving towards that world. Still, as I said before, this group is pre-2009 heavy. I think most of what we are seeing here is a decrease in true talent levels — guys making weaker contact and legging out fewer infield singles.

But if we break these differences down by age, we see the heaviest BABIP drops coming in the latter ages:



Click to enlarge.

From age 36 through 39, the group averaged BABIPs 8 to 16 points worse than their career numbers, with 8 and 9 points making the most appearances. This surprised me the most, considering we have 2003 Rafael Palmeiro, 2001 Cal Ripken, 2008 Kevin Millar and 2006 Frank Thomas included in this set.

These are old dudes — at the ends of their careers — with BABIPs barely shifted from their normal career numbers. Here we must interject the final confirmation bias warning. These hitters would not reach 500 PA if they looked lost in Spring Training, if scouts were seeing red flags in batting practice, if they were truly and undeniably kaput. I think few hitters really reach that level outside of catastrophic injury, but if and when they do reach it, they are unlikely to cobble together 250 PA, much less 500.

So these are hitters who, presumably, passed a modicum of the eye-test (at least among team officials) and who had success (to a degree) the preceding year. But nonetheless, we are seeing hitters aged 36 to 39 with BABIPs quite close to their career numbers, and that is worth remembering.

Ichiro and Matsui
This brings us full circle to Ichiro Suzuki and Hideki Matsui. Ichiro’s BABIP is 69 points below his career BABIP, and Matsui’s is 128 points down. Neither player is likely to get full playing time (or even 500 PA, for Matsui) through the end of the season — but, if they hypothetically did, and if their BABIPs remained constant, they would rank No. 2 and No. 1 among the worst BABIP drops in the whole Old Guys Bucket.

Maybe Matsui is really finished? It’s hard to say from a statistical standpoint as his 103 PA have come largely as a pinch hitter and in sporadic stints as the DH. Both roles come with considerable offensive penalties. Add in the fact his season started in late May, and we have to wonder if his extended off-season hasn’t resulted in a possibly temporary loss of bat speed.

Scouts might be able to offer insight into whether or not he has lost bat speed, but his contact rate (78.1%) is easily at a career low. Let us say he is not finished, that his skills have depreciated, but that he’s not an 18 wRC+ true-talent hitter.

Let us then presume he can at least match the worst possible BABIP difference of -57 points. That would mean that Matsui, with a .240 BABIP, would have approximately a .260 wOBA (according to FI wOBA) — which is great for the best defensive shortstop in the history of the universe, but not so great for a DH.

If his BABIP managed to hit the average decline — minus 11 points — then he would still only muster a .289 wOBA. If he matched his career BABIP (not going to happen, in all likelihood), he’d be at .296 wOBA.

The core of this issue becomes clear, then: His plate discipline numbers are askew. Let’s say — with some regular playing time, as with before — he sorts out his approach and at least matched his 9.6% walk rate and 14.4% strikeout rate from 2011 (not great numbers, but not terrible either). Suddenly, his wOBA (with just a .286 BABIP) jumps to .316 — which would rank him the fourth-best hitter in an offense-starved Rays lineup.

So is Matsui’s usefulness expired? Perhaps — but if he can find his old plate discipline, even with a career-low home run rate, he could realistically provide the Rays with solid production. But there are a lot of if’s there.

Ichiro, on the other hand, needs to change little. One of the curiosities of his hitting profile over the last few years has been the rapid decline in infield singles. Though he continues to steal bases at a considerable pace and though his defense and range continue to rate well, he seems to be losing the skill for infield singles. Here is a look at his hit types per plate appearance:



However, from 2002 through 2009, Ichiro averaged only 5.8% infield hits. From 2010 through 2012, that number has decreased to 5.1% — that’s a pretty small change overall. Meanwhile, his non-infield hits have gone from 19.1% of his PAs to 17.1%. That’s a more troubling decline.

Still, his doubles and homers are in line with his career rates, and his triples have ticked up in recent years. And he has been successful (in 2009 — 113 wRC+) with a lower non-infield singles rate. Moreover, his stolen base rate over the past few years is almost unchanged from his career numbers.

Let us again play with the hypothetical and say Ichiro’s rest-of-season BABIP climbs to the -11 point difference we found prevalent in the Old Guys Bucket. Ichiro’s wOBA jumps from .281 to .329 as his BABIP goes from .279 to .337 — that’s a huge BABIP jump, but it’s also a testament to how far it has fallen this season.

One other difficulty with the preceding findings is that all those career BABIPs we were looking at already have incurred the low-BABIP final seasons — so they were downward biased, which means the player’s difference between career and seasonal BABIP looks less dramatic.

Since these guys have played into at least their late-30s, most of them have thousands of PA, so it shouldn’t make much of a difference, but, hey, let’s say the penalty should actually be 25 points of BABIP. That puts Ichiro at a .320 wOBA — and with his defense, which continues to be Gold Glovish — he makes a considerable outfield asset.

Conclusion
The biggest information we can draw from this is that players given ~500 PA from 2000-2011 did not see their BABIP drop more than 60 points (57 points to be precise) from the career numbers and averaged a drop of only 11 points. Whether this applies to any modern player probably depends on the situation, but it should make intuitive sense — players’ skills decline with age, but with steady playing time, they should be able to at least best pitchers, who sport BABIPs in the .220s. Give these veterans less than consistent playing time, and they may not best the pitcher BABIP.

For the specific players of Hideki Matsui and Ichiro Suzuki, the results are a little more divergent. Ichiro’s decline appears all too sudden, especially given his speed-rich skillset, and if the Yankees choose to give him steady playing time in New York — which would unfortunately come at the expense of some of their other talented outfielder hitters — it could be a worthwhile gamble (especially considering Ichiro’s change in home stadiums).

Matsui, meanwhile, has plate discipline numbers that suggest greater problems — including a low contact rate. If he continues to receive only partial playing time and cannot improve his plate discipline numbers while in that capacity (or any capacity, really), then the Rays will have little else to do but release him. If he gets steady playing time, we can expect his BABIP to increase, but it will do his output little good if he cannot also improve his walk rate, strikeout rate and/or home run rate.

Miami Reloads… Again with Decent Haul from Detroit.

The Miami Marlins organization was one of the big boys during this past off-season when the front office tossed money at shortstop Jose Reyes and starting pitcher Mark Buehrle. But the ‘new Marlins’ did not even last a full season before management pulled the plug once again and started flipping expensive veterans for cheap, young talent.

Monday’s deal saw the Marlins send starter Anibal Sanchez and infielder Omar Infante to the Detroit Tigers for pitchers Jacob Turner and Brian Flynn, as well as catcher Rob Brantly. Both Turner (1st overall) and Brantly (6th) appeared on the Tigers pre-season Top 15 prospects list.

Much like former Tigers No. 1 draft pick Cameron Maybin, who also went from Detroit to Miami in a trade, Turner was hurt by the organization’s over-aggressive development plan in an effort to compensate for a weak minor league system. Drafted ninth overall out of a St. Louis high school in 2009, the right-hander made his pro debut in 2010 and was in the majors in ’11. He entered 2012 as the club’s best prospect but he dealt with injuries and his stuff was not as crisp as in the past. A lack of fastball command doomed him at the big league level.

Turner, 21, still has youth on his side and has the potential to be a No. 2 pitcher if he can find his fastball command and sharpen his secondary pitches. He’ll likely see more time at the big league level with Miami but he could probably use about 100 more innings of minor league seasoning.

Brantly has the potential to be the steal of the trade. Former No. 1 draft pick and catcher Kyle Skipworth is following up his dismal 2011 (55 wRC+) with another limp performance in double-A (76 wRC+). The Detroit-turned-Miami prospect recently turned 23 and was a third round draft selection out of the University of California-Riverside in 2010. He reached triple-A in his third pro season in 2012 after posting a wRC+ of 122 in 46 double-A games. He’s been over-matched, though, during his 36 games in triple-A and his development needs to be slowed down.

The left-handed hitting catcher has the potential to be a first-string catcher if he can become more consistent but he’s probably more valuable as a platoon player. He lacks power and has an overly-aggressive approach at the plate that gets him into trouble. Defensively, he needs a lot of polish but shows potential with the throwing game. He’s probably about a year away from being a true contributor at the major league level.

Flynn is a C-level prospect and a former seventh round selection out of Wichita State University (2011). He stands 6’8” and is left-handed. He spent the majority of 2012 in high-A ball showing good control but giving up a ton of hits because he lacks command in the zone. He can hit the mid-90s with his heat but works down in the 89-91 mph range at other times. His secondary pitches are equally inconsistent and he has dabbled with both a curveball and a slider. At best, he could maintain the level of a No. 4 starter for a few years but is more of a long reliever and spot starter – unless he takes a big step forward with his fastball in terms of both command and consistency.

Miami gave up a very talented starter in Sanchez who has struggled with his health in the past but struck out more than 200 batters in 2011. In return, the Marlins received a decent – but unspectacular – return. Detroit was able to hold onto No. 1 prospect 3B/RF Nick Castellanos, who had leap-frogged over Turner this year to claim top spot in the Tigers system.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Yankees Hope They Acquired “Road” Ichiro.

The Yankees have acquired Ichiro Suzuki from the Mariners in exchange for pitching prospects D.J. Mitchell and Danny Farquhar. The Mariners are also paying approximately $4.5 million of the $6.7 million remaining on Ichiro’s contract, leaving the Yankees responsible for a fairly modest $2.25 million.

According to Mariners CEO Howard Lincoln, Ichiro had approached the club requesting a trade, reasoning that the Mariners are building for the future and it was best for the team if younger players were given more playing time.

Ichiro has also become a shell of his former self, posting a .289 wOBA last season and a .281 wOBA this year, both of which rank near the league’s bottom. Since the start of last season, only Cliff Pennington, Casey McGehee and Gordon Beckham have produced lower wOBAs. Trading him must have been very difficult, but it was much easier to justify, and downright responsible, from a production standpoint.

While Safeco Field clearly has a hand in his decline, he is simply nowhere near the same player fans are accustomed to seeing. He isn’t an everyday player anymore, but it would have been tough for the Mariners to play him sporadically given his importance to the team and the community. The Yankees don’t need him to be anything more than a part-time platoon player to make this deal work out, and for Ichiro, the realization that his days as a full-time starter are done is likely easier to stomach on a playoff contender.

While it’s somewhat shocking that the Mariners dealt their franchise player — especially since most signs pointed towards his retention next season — what he could potentially provide his new club is rather intriguing. In the appropriate role and under the right circumstances, he could really benefit the Yankees down the stretch.

Simply by not playing the majority of his games at Safeco Field, which has absolutely crushed BABIP and offense in general this season, Ichiro figures to improve his seasonal line. If his numbers at the plate with the Yankees resemble his current road numbers, and his terrific fielding persists, the Yankees won’t think twice about the money they’ll spend or the prospects they dealt. If they just acquired “Road” Ichiro, this is a darned good deal that bolsters depth in an important area.

Context is key in any analysis, and with Ichiro what’s important is how the Yankees will use him. If he splits time in a platoon — he has a .309 wOBA vs. righties compared to a .222 wOBA against lefties, he will provide more overall utility. If, on top of that, he produces close to his current road marks — a .311 road wOBA compared to a .243 home wOBA — the Yankees could end up with the version of Ichiro that hits close to the league average and fields very well. We obviously cannot take his road numbers and assume that he will match them now that he has left the unfriendly confines, but it’s more likely he produces near that level than it is that he completely falters.

But how Ichiro factors into the Yankees outfield is still a question mark. Curtis Granderson starts in center field. Nick Swisher mans right field. Raul Ibanez and Andruw Jones platoon in left field. Ichiro represents added depth given the injuries to Brett Gardner, but it’s unclear if he’s a better option than anyone, anywhere. Both Swisher and Jones sport .346 wOBAs, and Ibanez has an average-ish .318 wOBA.

The left field platoon of Jones and Ibanez has been productive to the tune of 2.1 WAR this season, and though Ichiro is a defensive upgrade over both, his role is likely limited to the third wheel of that platoon.

The Yankees could also use Ichiro in a catch-all outfield role, spelling any of their starters if injuries arise, or filling in when rest is required. That’s the key with a depth move like this — Ichiro isn’t counted on to be the tremendous hitter of yesteryear. The Yankees realistically don’t need him to do all that much, which means they are far more likely to use him in the proper roles. As a result, they stand to extract far more value out of him.

It feels very strange that Ichiro is no longer a member of the Seattle Mariners, but it’s ultimately for the best. The Mariners get to play younger players in a rebuilding phase while he gets to play in meaningful games without all the pressures of a fanbase on his shoulders. The Yankees part ways with two mediocre prospects and chump change to get a popular player who will get put in the perfect situation given his skill-set. The Yankees are betting on him producing closer to his more respectable road numbers from here on out. Given the cost of acquiring him, this was a bet well worth making.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Tigers Retool With Infante, Sanchez.

The Tigers are built to win now. From the owner to the position players to the pitchers, this team is built for short-term glory and some long-term pain. in that context, their latest trade — a package featuring top prospect Jacob Turner for Anibal Sanchez and Omar Infante — fills their greatest short-term needs and readies the team for postseason play.

Their 83-year-old pizza magnate owner, Mike Ilitch, bought the team from another pizza magnate, Tom Monaghan, in 1992, or eight years after the Tigers won their last world series championship. After some early success, the owner looked to put a long-term plan in place and hired Dave Dombrowski to captain the ship. 2003 saw the Tigers lose more than any other American League team in history, but then the pieces Dombrowski put together started to come to fruition. It’s still the stars from that accumulation of talent that power the team — Justin Verlander, Austin Jackson, Miguel Cabrera — but recent acquisitions have cemented the win-now feeling.

Spending $214 million on an iffy-bodied first baseman when the team had two or three first basemen already in the fold was probably the biggest sign that the team is focused on the short-term. That says “this team is a bat away,” and says it loudly. But this train might have been moving to a win-now mentality ever since the Cabrera trade sent their best prospects away for two players.

Of course, the early 2012 season didn’t turn out exactly as the Tigers had hoped. After roaring out to a 9-3 start, the team lost seven in a row and ended April at .500. They were still looking up at the Indians after May, too. The idea was maybe that the team’s fielding was hurting them, and that the pitching wasn’t as sure of a thing as it might at first have seemed. Well, the team is second-to-last in fielding runs in the league (-29.5), so that part might actually be a problem. But the Tigers rotation has the most WAR in the American League and even their ERA (4.13) is better than average.

Still, the Braves might be a one-team example for the “you can never have too much pitching” maxim, and past Justin Verlander, even the most ardent Tigers fan would have to admit to excreting a few beads of sweat when Max Scherzer, Doug Fister or Rick Porcello step on to the mound. That threesome has been great for stretches, but they’ve also had some terrible times.

So Anibal Sanchez and Omar Infante do fit their needs well.

With positive defensive numbers (and experience) at every position except pitcher and catcher, Infante can provide a better glove at any infield position than the Tigers currently boast, save for (perhaps) Jhonny Peralta. Even if his power regresses (.155 ISO this year, .121 career) and his BABIP (.307) stays below his career levels (.310), Infante’s recent .330 wOBA type of work would be a great improvement over the .243 wOBA (and league-worst -2.0 WAR) that the Tigers’ Ryan Raburn, Danny Worth and Ramon Santiago and put together at the position. It probably won’t be a four-win gain for the Tigers — Infante’s career high in WAR is 2.7 and it would be surprising for the 30-year-old to almost double that this year — but at least the team won’t have a below-replacement position on the field any more.

Sussing out Sanchez is harder. Well, it is if you get too caught up in his recent work. The 28-year-old starter spent June with an ERA over seven, and given the fact that he once had shoulder surgery, it might have made sense to worry about his durability some. On the other hand, Sanchez has been playing with the same (slightly lower) velocity all season, and even recently saw an uptick in fastball gas. And if you look at the season as a whole, he’s put up his third-stright season with an FIP under 3.5 by consistently improving his control while still seeing average ground-ball rates and above-average swinging strike stuff. He looks healthy and is a good pitcher. He could be worth a two-win swing himself.



A four-win addition is actually pretty important for a first-place team: with the new rules in place, getting into the second round of the playoffs by winning your division outright is invaluable, as Jesse Wolfersberger pointed out last week and Dave Cameron and Vince Gennaro expounded upon as well. This also gives the Tigers help at the front of their rotation, defensive help around the infield, and offensive help at second base.

At the cost of their top pitching prospect, yes, but that’s not a prospect without questions or a prospect who’s value was on the way up — Marc Hulet had him down at 25 in his mid-season update. The rest of the reported package — Triple-A (and probably depth) catcher Rob Brantly, iffy lefty Brian Flynn & 2013 Comp B pick — is about as lottery-ticket-esque as it comes. It is the first trade of a draft pick in modern baseball, though. [Update: Now it seems like the Tigers may be getting a pick back, so it was a pick upgrade for the Tigers. This part deserves its' own post.]

It’s a little surprising to see the Marlins selling so soon after making a push for their new stadium, but Sanchez will be a free agent at year’s end (Infante is signed for another year at $4 mill), and Turner can help them going forward. On the other hand, it’s not surprising to see the contending Tigers retool and fill in their only significant gaps. A quick, surgical strike while much of the baseball world was waiting on Ryan Dempster‘s decision, and the Tigers are ready for the postseason.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
What’s Wrong With Jon Lester?

From 2008 to 2010, there were only six pitchers in baseball better than Jon Lester, and you can probably identify them all by first name — Roy, Cliff, Tim, Zack, CC and Justin. Last year however, was a different story. Lester was still one of the top 30 pitchers in the game, but he was ensconced safely outside of the top 10. While many expected a rebound, or at least for Lester to plateau in 2012, he has continued his descent, with the exclamation point coming yesterday, when he allowed 11 runs in four innings to the Blue Jays.

As we noted last week with Jonathan Sanchez, part of Lester’s trouble may stem from the fact that while his fastball velocity is declining, his changeup velocity is increasing. The changeup hasn’t been a problem for Lester this season, but his fastball certainly has. Lester has not even lost a mile and a half on his four-seamer, and it is still the ninth-fastest four-seamer among left-handed starters. But that sentence is a bit of a tip off, isn’t it? Two seasons ago, that sentence would have read “tied for 11th-fastest in the game.” Now, it needs qualifiers. Also, it is getting hit hard — he is allowing a .397 wOBA on his fastball this season.

Still, that’s not what is most troubling. In 2010, when Lester posted a 3.13 FIP, he allowed a .396 wOBA on his fastball, so clearly he can be effective without a dominating fastball. But what Lester does need to be effective are the pitches that break — his cutter, curveball and sinker — and right now, they are not. His cutter, in particular, has been a mystery. For starters, he is either throwing it less frequently or he has been throwing it in a way that makes it harder to identify as a cutter. That can sometimes be attributable to a computer or user error or change in how pitches are identified, but if it isn’t, it’s a big issue for Lester moving forward. Over the last three seasons, the cutter had been Lester’s bread and butter, and had been one of the most effective cutters in the game. From ’09-’11, he threw it 20.5 percent of the time. This year, that has dipped to 11.5%. Hitters are still having trouble squaring up the pitch, but they’re not missing it with the frequency they have in the past — his SwStr% on his cutter is four percent lower than it has been the past three seasons.


His curveball and sinker have not been much better. First, let’s look at his curveball:



Year PA wOBA
2007 26 0.103
2008 123 0.238
2009 105 0.189
2010 135 0.18
2011 95 0.254
2012 53 0.371
Total 537 0.223

Now, what we’re looking at here needs to be taken with a grain of salt. Because only 53 of the batters he has faced this year have seen a curveball as the final pitch in said plate appearance, there is room for noise in these numbers. But it bears watching, since Lester’s wOBA allowed on curveballs is currently is almost 150 points above his career norm. In addition, perhaps it should tell us something that he is featuring it that much less frequently at the end of plate appearances the past two years.

His sinker has stabilized a bit better, but the results there aren’t promising either:



Year PA wOBA
2010 109 0.325
2011 126 0.353
2012 150 0.373
Total 385 0.353

Lester is throwing his sinker more than ever before even though it is getting harder than ever before. And unlike in 2010, when he had a respectable 8.7 SwStr% on the pitch, he is only getting swings and misses on 4.0% of his sinkers this season. Which would be fine if he was generating weak contact, as sinkers are not necessarily designed to be a swing and miss pitch, but he’s not. He’s getting hit hard, and what’s worse, he’s getting his sinker hit into the air — a career-worst 22.8% of the time.

Add it all up, and Lester is throwing four of his five pitches below the standards to which he is accustomed. When things like that happen, you end up with a second straight season of pronounced platoon splits. When things like that happen, you end up with a career-worst 23.3 LD%. When things like that happen, you post the worst HR/FB of your career. And yet, is Lester really doing that poorly? He’s still been worth close to two wins, and if you look at his minus numbers, he’s still been a better-than-league-average pitcher. His K% is down, but so is his BB%, and his K/BB numbers are in line with his last two seasons. His BABIP is up a lot this season, and that could be because his pitches have lost some of their mojo. It could also be just bad luck. Certainly, starts like yesterday’s don’t come around too often, and when they do, the opposing team doesn’t always cash in to the degree the Blue Jays did. On Wednesday, Justin Masterson had a very similar start in terms of baserunners allowed and innings pitched — 14 in 4 1/3 innings against Tampa — but the Rays only cashed in four of them.

It is clear that Jon Lester has slipped from ace status, but how far is still up for debate. His pitches have been far less effective, and his platoon split is troubling, especially since the overwhelming majority of the batters he faces are right-handed. Yet, as recently as last month, he had posted a season-best monthly FIP of 2.92. His E-F number is third-worst in the game at the moment and his 3.80 xFIP places 39th out of 100 qualified pitchers. Interest certainly hasn’t dampened on him either, as the Braves have recently inquired about his availability.

Lester’s struggles will continue to be magnified in Boston because, number one it’s Boston, and number two the Red Sox — thanks to the fluctuation of both health and effectiveness of every other member of its starting rotation — need him now more than ever. If he is able to turn things around, then his last three starts — in which he has allowed 22 runs in 12 1/3 innings — will become a blip on the radar screen, much like when he allowed 15 runs in 16 innings in his first three starts of 2010. If he isn’t, we will remember this past weekend as the time when we stopped referring to him in the same discussions with guys like CC, Justin, Cliff and Roy.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Braves Go Dempster Diving to Improve Rotation.

The starting rotation was supposed to be a strength for the Braves, but they instead opened today with just one qualified starter with a sub-4.40 ERA. Ben Sheets has provided a lift two starts into his comeback and Tim Hudson has been his typically reliable self, but Mike Minor, Randall Delgado, and Jair Jurrjens have struggled to varying degrees while Brandon Beachy blew out his elbow. Atlanta remains right in the thick of the playoff hunt despite ranking middle of the pack in rotation ERA and FIP (both 4.04).

In an effort to shore up the staff, the Braves acquired Ryan Dempster from the Cubs this afternoon. It’s unclear what they gave up as of this writing, though Delgado has been rumored. Dave O’Brien, Jon Heyman, and Mark Bowman all deserve some credit in breaking the news. The veteran right-hander has ten-and-five no-trade protected but waived it to join Atlanta. He reportedly did not demand any kind of extension or other compensation to approve the trade, so he gets brownie points for that.

Dempster, 35, recently missed some time with a lat strain but otherwise is in the middle of his best season as a full-time starter. His 2.11 ERA is backed by an sky-high 83.9% strand rate, something that may be more sustainable than you think. Dempster’s become more of a fly ball pitcher at this point of his career (42.2% grounders this year) and Atlanta has a big home ballpark with a dynamite defensive outfield led by Michael Bourn in center. Maybe 83.9% won’t last forever, but a regression to the 72.6% league average is not a foregone conclusion.

Those fly balls and outfield defense should also go a long way towards keeping Dempster’s BABIP down. He’s working on a career-low .245 mark right now (.301 career) and while that probably won’t last all season, regressing all the way back to the .293 league average is again no sure thing. It’s tough to overstate how favorable the switch is for Dempster — he’s going from a hitter friendly park where Alfonso Soriano and Bryan LaHair roam the corners to a pitcher’s park with three good-to-great defensive outfielders.

There are still some concerns of course. Dempster’s career-low strikeout rate (7.07 K/9 and 19.5 K%) has been trending in the wrong direction basically since April…



His swinging strike rate (9.3%) is identical to last year and in line with 2010, so he’s still missing bats. It’s worth noting that based on the PITCHf/x data, Dempster is throwing considerably more sliders and splitters this year than the last few seasons. Matt Garza showed a similar adjustment following the trade to Chicago last year, so maybe it’s a pitching coach thing. Either way, the drastic decline in strikeouts — he was over 8.5 K/9 and 21.5 K% in each of the last two seasons — is a red flag.

We don’t know what the Braves are sending the Cubs just yet, but acquiring Dempster drastically improves Atlanta’s chances of winning this season assuming prospects and not big league pieces went the other way. They got a reliable innings eater who, even if his performance down the stretch isn’t as impressive as the first half, will be an upgrade over three current starters. It could be as much as a three-win improvement, though two seems more likely. Dempster gets to join a contender and stay in the National League, the best case scenario for a veteran who (probably) wants to win and land a nice multi-year deal this winter.

Are the Wild Cards Now a Trap?

Over the weekend, Vince Gennaro — president of SABR, author of Diamond Dollars, and friend of FanGraphs — launched his own blog. For his first post, he talked about the second wild card and it’s effect on the upcoming trade deadline. In that post, he said some of the things that I’ve been thinking lately, so instead of just repeating those ideas, I’ll quote him instead:

What are the implications for trade deadline deals? Since we know the real financial payoff for a team’s performance results from a run through the postseason—the deeper the run, the richer the pot of gold—teams will need to shift their mindset to not treat all postseason qualifying positions as “equal”. In the new system, it may make more sense to fortify your ballclub when your playoff status is assured, but being anointed a division winner is still in question—think Texas or even the Angels. However, a team fighting for a wild card berth should think twice before they go all-in for the privilege of potentially extending their season for one more day. This is the exact opposite of the old mindset—do everything you can to qualify for the playoffs, but don’t worry too much about winning the division.

Vince is right about the incentives of the old system, as there was no real incentive to try and secure a different seed within the playoff structure. If you were in, you were in, and your goal should have been to just get in. But, now, the addition of the second wild card changes everything. In reality, it’s the play-in game that is really the differentiator here, as the new structure created a vast separation between winning your division and finishing as a strong runner up. As Jesse noted last week, the playoff probability curves have shifted, and the incentives on when to be a trade deadline buyer have to shift as well.

There are now twice as many wild cards, but they are less than half as valuable as they used to be, as they only guarantee a ~50-50 shot at a real playoff spot, and, in order to secure that playoff spot, the team will likely have to burn through their pitching staff in order to win the one game playoff. Rather than entering the division series on even footing, the wild card may now very well be without their best starting pitcher until Game 3 or Game 4. Not only does a wild card entry no longer get you any guaranteed home playoff dates, it increases the likelihood that the wild card will be losing in the first round.

These are good changes that I’m in favor of, but the devaluation of the wild card may have some unintended consequences at the trade deadline, as Vince noted in his post.

For instance, the recent surge by the Oakland Athletics has left them just a half game behind the Angels and tied with the Orioles in the wild card standings. Under the old system, the A’s and O’s should probably have both acted as buyers. While they’re not as good as the Angels in terms of true talent, they’re close enough to that first wild card spot that there’s a realistic chance that they could outplay Anaheim over the final two months of the season and steal a lucrative playoff spot that could re-energize their fan base and create significant revenue gains. However, under the new system, both teams should probably resist the urge to give up prospects for rentals, as the reward for running down the Angels (or even just maintaining their current spot in the standings) is likely a one game, winner-take-all affair against Jered Weaver in Anaheim.

Yeah, they could beat him, but how much of your farm system do you want to bet on coming out victorious against Weaver on the road, especially when you’re pretty sure that the Angels roster is still stronger than yours even without factoring in the pitching match-up? The outcome of any one game is unpredictable enough that they shouldn’t just fold up their tents and give up, but trading good prospects for the right to try and win one game as an underdog on the road against one of the best pitchers in baseball just seems like a poor use of value.

It was one thing to trade a prospect for a guy who gave you a 10% chance at getting to the World Series, where the potential return could dramatically alter the trajectory of a franchise. But, now, with the required play-in game, teams that are hanging out in the wild card race but probably aren’t contenders for the division title should probably hold instead of buy. The play-in game is enough of a carrot to keep teams from repeating the White Flag Trade, but it shouldn’t be enough of a carrot to get teams to give up real long term value to chase a wild card spot.

Of course, there’s a flip side to this coin as well. Since the division title is so much more valuable than a wild card berth, teams like Chicago, Detroit, Pittsburgh, Cincinnati, and St. Louis should be far more incentivized to win the central divisions than they were in prior years, when a second place finish could still get them into the playoffs as a wild card. Likewise, the Washington Nationals should probably be more aggressive buyers this year than they would have been last year, as they can’t afford to let the Braves pass them in the NL East race.

The changing marginal values of wins 87-97 have made it so that first place teams should be more active this week, while second place teams should probably be a bit less active unless they’re close to the top of their division.

It will be interesting to see which teams are aggressive in adding talent. It probably won’t be the same ones that would have been active in prior years.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Phillies Find Gem in Mitch Walding.

The scouting highlight of my time in upstate, New York was not 2011 first rounders Taylor Guerrieri (Rays) or Larry Greene (Phillies). Nor was it Red Sox 2012 first round pick Deven Merrero. How about 2011 second round picks Roman Quinn (Phillies) and Williams Jerez (Red Sox)? No. Without a doubt, the most impressive few minutes of my five games scouted in New York was the batting practice display put on by Phillies third base prospect Mitch Walding. So frequent were the balls leaving Falcon Park, home of the Auburn Doubledays, that I was compelled to find the distance down the right field line as I kept having flashbacks of Asheville and its sub-300 foot porch.

And while the power displayed in batting practice by Walding did not carry over into game action, his advanced approach allowed him to pepper line drives to all fields resulting in a multi-hit performance. Having seen the young third baseman at a time when his batting average sat in the .350′s, his current line of .280/.353/.374 is perplexing. However, Walding’s recent struggles are not enough to sway me from believing he is one of the best pure hitters I’ve scouted this season.

At 6-foot-3, 190 pounds, Walding has room to add an additional 20-30 pounds to his frame at full physical maturity. However, adding weight may not come easily considering his lack of natural size through the shoulders and hips.

In terms of athleticism, Walding’s long limbs cause him to look a bit awkward at times – especially when running and playing the infield. However, his swing is surprisingly short and quick considering his arm length leaving his bat more advanced than his glove at this point. Having already moved down the defensive spectrum from shortstop to third base, he is in no danger of having to move to a less valuable defensive position such as first base or a corner outfield spot.

In batting practice, Walding is able to stay inside the baseball better than just about every left-handed hitting prospect I’ve seen previously. Behind strong hands and a slight uppercut in his swing plane, Walding was able to let the ball travel deep into his hitting zone before tattooing baseball after baseball. And while his home runs were not tape measure shots, the natural backspin and loft he was able to generate was uncanny for a player his age.

However, that backspin did not carry over into game action although Walding consistently barreled the baseball with success. Instead of allowing the ball to travel and trusting his hands to do much of the work, Walding attacked pitches in front of the plate nullifying much of his impressive natural power. The contact skills are there for his strikeout rate to plummet, but Walding will likely struggle with identifying off-speed pitches until he makes an adjustment. Additionally, he was almost patient to a fault. It would benefit him to be a bit more aggressive – especially with two strikes – as about the only thing worse than short season pitching are short season umpires.

On defense, Walding’s throwing motion caused natural tail into the base runner. This led to an error early in the contest, as well another near mishap later on. His arm strength is at least average for the position, but he’ll need to develop a cleaner arm action to consistently make long throws across the diamond. With the glove, Walding picked everything in front of him and showed range to his left. As with many young prospects, his backhand side was a bit rough, but repetition and better technique should help. In time, there’s really no reason for Walding to become at least an average defender based on the skills he does have.

When totaling Mitch Walding’s signing bonus and future cost of a college education, the Phillies organization invested close to seven figures to sign the young third baseman. Based on other seven figure signings I’ve seen, Philadelphia made a wise investment as the potential is there for Walding to develop into a player with both an above average hit tool and power. In person, Walding presented far better than first round pick Larry Greene and is likely to be ranked as one of the better prospects in the organization this winter.

While much different in terms of build and being left-handed, my first impression of Mitch Walding is similar to that of Colorado Rockies third base prospect Nolan Arenado in terms of hitting ability. When I first saw Arenado in 2010, I was blown away by his feel for contact and focus on generating lift – down to the his bat flick when taking practice swings. Arenado hails from Newport Beach, a full six-plus hours from Walding’s stomping grounds in Lodi, California. But oddly enough, Walding had the same bat flick. The Phillies would surely be pleased if it yielded the same results.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Myers Traded To Windy City.

As the trade deadline approached this month, the Chicago White Sox desperately needed to upgrade their bullpen. Their cumulative 4.17 FIP ranks second worst in the American League, and their 3.99 ERA ranks only marginally better.

GM Kenny Williams looked to perhaps the only self-identified “seller” on the current market, the Houston Astros, for help. The White Sox acquired right-hander Brett Myers for minor-league pitchers Matthew Heidenreich and Blair Walters, as well as a player to be named later.

Despite saving 19 games for the Astros to this point, Myers will not immediately step in as the White Sox’s closer. That role will continue to belong to rookie Addison Reed, which only makes sense, as Reed has a better FIP, better stuff, and misses far more bats.

Reports suggest Myers will transition into the set-up role behind Reed and provide veteran stability in a bullpen that features rookies such as Reed, Nate Jones, and Hector Santiago. In terms of a talent upgrade, though, the White Sox may not have acquired as much as they previously thought.

Here are the main cogs in Chicago’s bullpen, sorted by FIP:

Player FIP
Jesse Crain 2.93
Matt Thornton 3.02
Addison Reed 3.07
Nate Jones 3.44
Brett Myers 4.24
Hector Santiago 5.40

This is not to suggest that Myers is unequivocally the fifth-best reliever for the White Sox. After all, Myers has only six meltdowns this season, while Matt Thornton has eleven. Instead, the above chart is meant to illustrate that the White Sox did not acquire a shutdown reliever who will transform the entire bullpen. His inability to miss bats has limited his success all season, and that trend could become even more pronounced in the less pitcher-friendly American League.

Overall, the White Sox received marginal value. It’s difficult to see them even gaining a full win from this move.

For a non-elite bullpen arm with only a half-season of control remaining, it’s only natural that the Astros did not acquire anything earth-shattering. Neither right-hander Matt Heidenreich nor left-hander Blair Walters cracked Marc Hulet’s Top 15 White Sox Prospects list prior to the season, while ESPN’s Keith Law wrote over the weekend that both “barely qualify as prospects.”

The biggest win for the Astros in this transaction was avoiding the $10 million vesting option that was poised to enact had Myers finished 16 more games prior to the end of the season. The White Sox should also avoid the vesting option, as Myers is not slated to close games in Chicago.

This type of trade has precedent, as well.

Last season, the New York Mets traded right-hander Francisco Rodriguez to the Milwaukee Brewers in order to avoid his bulky $17.5 million vesting option that would have triggered if he had finished 55 games. That vesting option negated the Mets negotiating leverage and were forced to settle for two non-prospects, right-hander Adrian Rosario and left-hander Daniel Herrera.

Within that context, the Houston Astros crafted a quality deal. Not only did they trade away an inferior pitcher to Francisco Rodriguez, they also acquired far more in prospects. Heidenreich and Walters may not profile as more than back-end starters at the big league level, but Adrian Rosario has walked more batters than he has struck out in Double-A and Daniel Herrera is a journeyman, who underwent Tommy John surgery this year. The Astros certainly acquired more talent than the Mets last year for a less-attractive asset, especially when considering the fact that the Astros will also net a player to be named later in the deal, though that piece is not expected to be significant.

Ultimately, this is a win-win trade. The White Sox improved their below-average bullpen without sacrificing anything significant, while the Astros acquired pitching depth for their improving farm system and avoided a $10 million vesting option. Add in the K-Rod trade for context, and the Astros come out looking even better.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
2012 Trade Value: #50-#46.

Now that we’ve looked back at last year’s Trade Value list, we’re ready for the 2012 version. Before we get to the rankings, here’s a quick recap of the idea behind the list, and what we’re trying to measure:

If every player in baseball was made available for trade, who would generate the most in return for their current club? Since it only takes two clubs to start a bidding war, we’re not trying to measure who has the most value to all 30 clubs, but rather who which player has so much value that they’d command a larger return in trade from one team than any other player. Some of the players on this list will be guys that many franchises can’t afford, but they still have significant trade value to high revenue clubs. Others are not quite as strong of performers on the field, but they’ve signed contracts that are extremely team friendly and would be franchise building blocks for lower revenue clubs. I’ve tried to balance out the value of performance and cost over the number of years that a team would control a player’s rights in order to determine which players have the most value as we head towards the 2012 trade deadline.

As a reference, we’ll be listing the years and dollars that a team has a player under control for including all team option years, as the assumption is that those are all seen as positive net value years, and would be seen as such by an acquiring team. The amount remaining on the contract includes half of their 2012 salaries and all future guaranteed salaries plus base salaries covered by the team options, though many deals have complicated option structures, buyouts, and bonuses that make these more of a ballpark figure than an exact accounting of what they’ll make going forward. For players who have remaining arbitration years, it is obviously impossible to know exactly what they’ll make in those years, so we’ll just list how many more trips through arbitration they have coming.

So, without further ado, let’s get to the last five guys on the list.

50. Elvis Andrus, SS, Texas – Signed through 2014 for $12 million.

After coming up as a defensive specialist, Andrus has continued to make progress as a hitter, and is now one of the best all around shortstops in the game, and he doesn’t turn 24 until August 26th. The combination of youth and productivity at a premium position make him one of the game’s best young players, but the Rangers weren’t able to buy out any of his free agent years when they signed him to a three year, $14.4 million contract last offseason. While he’s young, he doesn’t have enough years of team control to rank as highly as his performance might otherwise suggest, and glove first players still don’t command the types of return that guys who can create runs at the plate can. While Andrus is one of the best young players in baseball, his skillset and short contract serve to keep him at the very end of this list.

49. Yovani Gallardo, SP, Milwaukee – Signed through 2015 for $35 million.

Still just 26, the idea of Gallardo developing into an ace seems to become less likely each year. He’s actually taken a bit of a step back with his command this season, and while he still misses bats, the combination of walks and home runs keep him from being a true front of the rotation hurler. He’s got two more years and a team option left on the deal he signed in 2010 at more than reasonable salaries, so he’d be a coveted asset, but he’s more good player at a good price than a young ace-in-the-making.

48. Matt Cain, SP, San Francisco – Signed through 2017 for $128 million.

So much for being overpaid. The best way to show you’re worth your shiny new contract is to dramatically up your strikeout rate while cutting your walks at the same time — well, as long as you’re a pitcher, anyway — and post career bests nearly across the board. Cain has transformed from durable innings eater into a legitimate ace, and even with salaries of $20 million per year kicking in, he’s the kind of guy that contenders would love to add to their rotation. He’s not cheap, but he’s good enough to still command a serious haul even with his new contract.

47. Alcides Escobar, SS, Kansas City – Signed through 2017 for $21 million.

Yes, this might be too aggressive of a ranking for a guy who was an abysmal Major League hitter before the 2012 season began. Any team paying a high price for Escobar would have to hope that the big step forward offensively is at least somewhat sustainable, and would be taking on a serious risk that the BABIP comes crashing down and he’s more of a decent starter than any kind of serious core building block. However, scouts still love his defensive abilities (even if UZR disagrees this year) and the Royals have him locked up for five more years at bargain basement prices, so there’s legitimate value there even if he doesn’t keep hitting like he has in the first few months of this season. While there’s a lot of regression risk here, he should at least be an average shortstop making peanuts through his prime, and there’s certainly upside beyond that.

46. Robinson Cano, 2B, New York – Signed through 2013 for $22 million.

Yes, there’s only a year and a half left before he’s eligible for free agency, and he’s going to command a monstrous contract pretty soon, but he’s performing at a level that makes him one of the very best players in baseball. He’s turned some of his doubles into home runs and is drawing more walks than ever, transforming himself from a good-hitter-for-his-position into just a great-hitter-period. Cano’s one of the few guys in the sport who can play a premium position and hit like a first baseman, and he doesn’t turn 30 until October. The short term team control and high expected cost to re-sign him drive down his trade value to some degree, but there are certainly a few big market clubs who would love to have the chance to sign Cano long term, and would have give up significant talent for the right to do it.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

2012 Trade Value: #45-#41.

45. (28) Ben Zobrist, 2B, Tampa Bay – Signed through 2015 for $22 million.

Since 2009, when he became a full-time player, Zobrist has posted the second-highest WAR in the major leagues, with only future Hall of Famer Albert Pujols ahead of him by that measure. Given the deal to which he’s currently signed — a four-year extension from 2010, with very afforadable option years ($7.0 and $7.5 million, respectively) in 2014 and 2015 — there’s every reason to believe that the Rays will extract considerable surplus value from Zobrist. As a trade commodity, however, Zobrist is slightly less valuable, owing to the fact that his production comes from areas that tend to have less value in the open market: defense, baserunning, and plate discipline.

44. (NR) Matt Holliday, OF, St. Louis – Signed through 2017 for $94 million.

When Holliday was producing crazy offensive numbers with the Rockies, there was always the question, “Yes, but would he hit like this outside of Coors?” Holliday has answered that question with an emphatic “Yes” over the last three-plus seasons. Since leaving Colorado early in the 2008-09 offseason, Holliday has posted the seventh-highest wRC+ of any qualified batter and produced over 20 wins above replacement. The contract — $17 million annually through 2016, with an option (also for $17 million) for 2017 — isn’t necessarily a bargain over the long term. Plus, at 32, Holliday is on the wrong side of his peak. For a contending team in search of an impact bat, however, there are few better options in the short term.

43. (NR) Adam Jones, OF, Baltimore – Signed through 2018 for $87 million.

Before 2012, there was always a disconnect between what Jones appeared to be capable of and what he actually did on the field. Kindly donated by Seattle to the Orioles (along with George Sherrill, Chris Tillman, and two others) in exchange for left-hander Erik Bedard before the 2008 season, Jones immediately became the team’s starting center fielder. Aside from a (probably questionable) Gold Glove in 2009, however, the sense was that there was potential being left unfulfilled. This season, of course, has been a breakout one for Jones, who has already matched his career-high WAR (2.9) with approximately half the season left. That performance earned him the largest contract in Orioles history — a six-year, $85.5 million deal this May. The bump in production for Jones has been almost entirely based on increased power numbers. If those gains are real, though, he’s a value for the money he’s owed.

42. (NR) Yu Darvish, SP, Texas – Signed through 2017 for $53 million.

That the Rangers have been linked both to Zack Greinke and Cole Hamels with the trade deadline approaching suggests, in part, that Darvish is not precisely what the team expected (or paid for) when they signed him — which is, a legitimate No. 1 starter. Darvish certainly has electric stuff and has shown flashes of dominance, but command is enough of an issue for him at the moment that the Rangers would want to slot someone ahead of him in a playoff series. The good news, sort of, is that roughly half the money invested in Darvish was used in the posting fee, which means that he’s only being paid like a two-win pitcher, a figure he’s already reached this season. That has value as a trade commodity — although, with the Rangers likely to be competitive for the duration of Darvish’s contract, a trade of Darvish would be surprising.

41. (46) Starlin Castro, SS, Chicago – Signed through 2016 (arbitration 2013-16)
There are a lot of discussions about what Starlin Castro isn’t — he isn’t a great fielder, he isn’t a patient hitter, he isn’t the most focused player — and there is some legitimacy to all of those complaints. What Castro is, however, is an athletic 22-year-old with a roughly league-average bat and four years of team control remaining. That has value as a trade piece. Owing to his Super Two status, Castro is eligible for arbitration this coming offseason, and is a candidate, as an offensively oriented shortstop, to do well there. As for his next four years, the possible outcomes are more diverse for Castro than other players. He could learn to play shortstop. He could develop power and move to third, in the Hanley Ramirez mold. He could not develop power and move to third — which is a less favorable mold.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

2012 Trade Value: #40-#36.

40. (NR) Johnny Cueto, SP, Cincinnati – Signed through 2015 for $30 million.

Johnny Cueto is one of two types of pitcher — either one who, year after year, produces peripherals that are likely to lead to a league-average ERA or one who, like Matt Cain, has cracked the secret code of batted-ball suppression. The numbers support either thesis at this point. Each of Cueto’s career component stats — his 18.3% strikeout rate, his 7.6% walk rate, his 44.1% ground-ball rate — is within percentage points of league average, respectively. Cueto’s home runs per fly ball and his strand rate, however, have both improved since his rookie season — and his ERAs relative to the league have followed suit. The good news for the Reds is that even the first type of pitcher is an asset at an approximate average annual value of $8 million.

39. (NR) Alex Gordon, OF, Kansas City – Signed through 2015 for $35 million.

It came about four or five years after it was originally expected, but Alex Gordon finally had a star-type season with the Royals in 2011, posting career-bests in basically every offensive category of note and playing an excellent left field, by all accounts. That is, of course, what did happen, while the concern here is with what will happen, or what could be reasonably expected to happen. In many respects, Gordon isn’t a much different player offensively in 2012 than he was in 2007-10. The biggest differences from those earlier years are the change in position (from third base), the level of the expectations placed on Gordon, and BABIP. It’s his improvements in that last category (plus the above-average left-field defense) that have him en route to a five-win season, even in the absence of a double-digit home-run pace.

38. (45) Matt Wieters, C, Baltimore – Signed through 2015 (arbitration 2013-15).

Perhaps it’s not a coincidence that Wieters follows Gordon on this list: both were high draft picks out of college who were subject to great expectations and both failed to live up to those expectations immediately (even while playing mostly like average major leaguers). Both also had 2012 seasons that confirmed those original expectations. The difference, from the point of view of trade value, is that Wieters is arb-eligible for just the first time this next offseason. On pace now for a four-plus-win season, the switch-hitting catcher will command quite a bit in arbitration — probably more than $15 million over three years. Given recent trends for teams locking up catchers, there’s a great possibility that he’ll reach an extension long before he hits free agency.

37. (NR) Wil Myers, OF, Kansas City – Six-plus years of team control.

If the Royals felt comfortable with Myers’ defense in center field, the clock on his team-controlled years would have started ticking already. They don’t, however, so, as it is now, he’s just your typical 21-year-old minor-league outfielder on pace for 40-plus home runs. Despite a down season by his standards in 2011, Myers still ranked pretty highly on most prospect lists entering 2012 — and that confidence in his abilities seems to have been justified. With the PCL now conquered, the only challenge remaining for Myers is major-league pitching. Well, major-league pitching and Jeff Francoeur‘s mysterious hold over the Royals coaching staff and front office.

36. (22) Jay Bruce, OF, Cincinnati – Signed through 2017 for $58 million.

Yes, the average is down this year, but Bruce’s is a legitimate power bat (he’s on pace for his second consecutive 30-homer season) in a league that currently has fewer of those than in quite some time. At his current age (25), there are reasons to believe that Bruce still has his best years ahead of him, too. More power, more contact, more walks: an improvement in any of those departments could bump Bruce from above-average piece to star — and that would be a star who’s making about $11 million per year. That’s a risk that a number of teams would be willing to make in a trade. And even if Bruce stays who he is, he’s still likely to provide surplus value year-by-year over what he’d get on the open market.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

2012 Trade Value: #35-#31.

35. (NR) Pablo Sandoval, 3B, San Francisco – Signed through 2014 for $15 million.

Every team in baseball is looking for young hitting, and many of them are wondering where all the third baseman with power went. Sandoval is one of the few good young offensive 3Bs in the game — his career line of .306/.356/.499 is good for a 125 wRC+ — as he doesn’t turn 26 for a few more weeks. He’s had problems staying healthy the last couple of years and the Giants only bought out his arbitration years when they signed him to a three year extension, which drive down his value a bit, but his power and contact skills are rare enough that he’d command a strong return if put on the open market.

34. (4) Dustin Pedroia, 2B, Boston – Signed Through 2015 for $36 million.

Pedroia is yet another example of a guy ranked very highly last year who has tumbled due to injury and performance issues. A couple of thumb injuries have landed Pedroia on the DL and contributed to a miserable performance in June, but his overall performance even before the injuries was down a bit from what we’ve come to expect. Still, signed for two more years plus a team option for a third year at $10 million per season, he’s a massive bargain and he was an elite player last year, so there’s no question that there’s still a lot of value to be had. However, the multiple thumb issues and disappearing power put a bit of a damper on his current value, and any team trading for Pedroia would have to be aware of the fact that they’d be taking him away from the Green Monster, where he’s done most of his damage throughout his career.

33. (NR) Austin Jackson, OF, Detroit Tigers – Under Team Control Through 2015.

Jackson has enjoyed a breakout 2012 season, already matching his career high in home runs and seeing his walk rate spike as well. The addition of power and patience to a player with good speed have made him an all around performer and one of the best center fielders in the game this season. His track record suggests that the power might be in for a decline, but he’s posted an ISO over .200 in each of the first four months with no discernable drop-off, so there’s a case to be made that the new Jackson is simply a large improvement over the old one. His surge is well-timed, as he’ll be heading to arbitration for the first time this winter, and is probably in line for a lucrative extension if the Tigers decide to buy out his arbitration years. Even with a payday coming, however, Jackson’s performance and athleticism make him a guy that teams would be lining up to bid for.

32. (NR) Mark Trumbo, 1B/OF, Anaheim – Under Team Control through 2016.

His lack of plate discipline received a lot of attention during his rookie year, but it may have overshadowed the fact that Trumbo is one of the strongest players in baseball, and he’s got the kind of power that allows him to be productive even while swinging at pitches he should probably let pass. Instead of regressing from his rookie season, Trumbo has been one of the most dynamic offensive players in baseball this year, hitting .311/.361/.634, good for a 165 wRC+. Just 26, Trumbo is one of the premier young power hitters in the sport, and he’s athletic enough to not embarrass himself in the outfield. He’s not a perfect player, but his strengths are notably hard to find in the sport these days, and with four more years of team control, he’s an asset that the Angels aren’t likely to part with.

31. (NR) Chris Sale, SP, Chicago White Sox – Under Team Control through 2016.

Sale’s conversion to the rotation couldn’t have gone any better — that is, unless you take away that whole two week blip where the White Sox were moving him back to the bullpen because his arm hurt before changing their minds. That incident has to raise some concern, but it’s still too hard to ignore what Sale has done as a dominant starting pitcher this year. A 77 xFIP- as a starting pitcher in the AL shows just how good he has been even if you regress his BABIP and HR/FB rates, and the White Sox still have another year where they can pay him peanuts before arbitration even kicks in. The drastic loss in velocity and the whole starter-reliever-starter thing would probably serve as red flags for some team, especially given his slender frame, but he’s pitching at a level where you accept some risk in order to get this kind of performance, especially from a 23-year-old making the league minimum.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

2012 Trade Value: #30-#26.

30. (NR) Jason Kipnis, 2B, Cleveland – Under Team Control through 2017

When the Indians drafted Kipnis out of Arizona State, he was seen as a tweener outfielder without the speed to play center or the power to play left. So, a few months after selecting him in the third round, the Indians moved him to second base, and are now being rewarded for their foresight. Kipnis has gotten a lot better at second in a hurry, and now profiles as an average to above average defender at an up-the-middle position, and provides the kind of offense (122 wRC+ over 541 MLB plate appearances) you don’t often get from a player at the keystone. Kinpis is a classic good-across-the-board guy, combining gap power with walks and improving contact rates while also being a highly efficient baserunner. In many ways, he profiles as the new Ian Kinsler, and as a 25-year-old with five more seasons of team control, the Indians will be able to get a lot of value from Kipnis without paying a high price to do so.

29. (NR) Matt Moore, SP, Tampa Bay – Signed through 2019 for $36 million

On the field, Moore has been a pretty big disappointment this year, struggling with command problems and showing that he wasn’t quite as polished as he looked down the stretch last year. However, he’s still a lefty with a mid-90s fastball who can miss bats, and teams haven’t forgotten how dominant he was in 2011, so a disappointing rookie season hasn’t shattered his value yet. And then, there’s the contract. In typical Rays fashion, they signed Moore extremely early in exchange for getting team options on his final arbitration year and his first two free agent years, so they’re only on the hook for about $15 million if he never develops. If he does, they’ve essentially got him locked up through age 30 at bargain rates (though there are a lot of incentives built into the deal, so knowing the precise amount ahead of time is impossible). He’s a higher risk guy without the performance track record of many others around him, but he also comes with extremely high reward due to the financial limitations he’s agreed to. If he does turn into an ace, he could end up near the very top of this list in a few years.

28. (5) Justin Upton, OF, Arizona – Signed through 2015 for $42 million.

This ranking is about to be put to the test, as everyone is aware that the Diamondbacks are currently shopping Upton around baseball and will likely trade him at some point in 2012. A year ago, it seemed hard to imagine the D’Backs giving up on their star right fielder, but another mediocre season has made Upton seem like an underachiever once again, so any team acquiring him would be making a bet on a big comeback after changing teams. The talent is certainly there, but he’s no longer all that cheap — the last three years of his contract total $39 million — and has a spotty record hitting away from Chase Field. There’s a lot of risk to be absorbed by any acquiring team, but potential franchise players aren’t moved in their mid-20s too often, especially when they’re not close to free agency. Whether Upton will command a star player’s return or will be shipped off for less than his talent would suggest remains to be seen, but we should have a better idea of how baseball views Upton later this year.

27. (NR) Mike Moustakas, 3B, Kansas City – Under Team Control through 2017

Moustakas was awful during the early part of his rookie season last year, but found his power stroke late in the season and hasn’t slowed down in 2012. He’s still not a finished product, but he’s flashing a combination of above average offense and terrific defense at age 23, and has shown very good contact skills in prior years as well. If he can get back to those lower strikeout rates while sustaining his power output, he may very well may be the new Adrian Beltre, or at least a player of similar value. Because of when he was called up last season, Moustakas may end up as a Super Two, qualifying for arbitration four times and accelerating his pay schedule, but the Royals still control his rights for five more years and have a young star in place at third. Even if he doesn’t remain overly cheap for more than a year or two, he’s still a highly valuable commodity.

26. (NR) Gio Gonzalez, SP, Washington – Signed through 2018 for $65 million

I wasn’t a big fan of the Gio Gonzalez trade for the Nationals, but kudos to Mike Rizzo and his staff for anticipating the breakout pitching star of 2012 and getting him while they still could. Gio’s velocity is up and he’s throwing first pitch strikes, which has led to a huge spike in strikeout rate and a reduction in walks, and the overall package has seen Gio pitch like a legitimate ace. His command is still not fantastic, and previous history suggests that he may not be able to keep this up forever, but Gonzalez looks like a better pitcher than I gave him credit for over the winter. To boot, the contract Washington signed him to now looks like a pretty big steal, as he would have been in for a hefty raise via arbitration, but is now looking at a salary of just $6 million in 2013 with manageable raises for the following three seasons, and then two team options at the end of that. There’s room for Gonzalez to regress and still be worth the contract, and if he keeps pitching like he is right now, he’ll be a huge steal for years to come.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
2012 Trade Value: #25-#21.

So, from the land of embarrassing mistakes comes this – I screwed up yesterday and copied the wrong part of the list in to the #30-#26 post and didn’t catch it until this morning. Kipnis, Moore, Upton, Moustakas, and Gio were actually 25-21, and for whatever reason, I simply grabbed those five when transposing the post into WordPress and didn’t notice that I had copied the wrong section. So, this post is actually presenting #30-#26 again. Feel free to call me an idiot in the comments. I certainly feel like one.

#50-#46
#45-#41
#40-#36
#35-#31
#30-#26

Note: salaries are rounded estimates and include all team-controlled years. Rankings from the 2011 Trade Value series in parentheses.

30. (30) Ian Kinsler, 2B, Texas – Signed through 2017 for $76 million.

The Rangers second baseman got a big contract extension over the winter and is having the worst offensive season of his career, but he remains in the same spot he occupied a year ago, as he was probably just a bit too low last year. At 30, he’s headed towards the downside of his career, but he’s still a highly productive middle infielder who can hit, field, and run the bases, and the extension he got pales in comparison to some of the recent big deals that similarly valuable players have received. While he might not still be a productive player by the end of the contract, he’s good enough now to make a big difference for many contenders, and the salary is low enough that he’s still producing surplus value for the next several seasons.

29. (NR) Dylan Bundy, SP, Baltimore – Under Team Control for 6+ Years

Yes, he’s a pitcher in A-ball. Yes, there are a ton of risks that go along with inexperienced teenage arms. Bundy is not your normal 19-year-old, however. The stuff is terrific, but he’s advanced beyond his years as a pitcher, and several team officials told me that they’d have him in their big league rotation right now. This is higher than I’m comfortable putting an A-ball pitching prospect, to be honest, but I was convinced to move him up by folks in the game who insist that he’s ready to get big league hitters out right now. Given the upside, there are a lot of teams that would love to take a risk on Dylan Bundy.

28. (NR) Jurickson Profar, SS, Texas – Under Team Control for 6+ Years

If you push a 19-year-old to Double-A, the hope is that they can just hold their own. Profar has gone beyond that and just dominated the league instead, posting a 140 wRC+ that makes him a top five hitter in the league, and the four guys ahead of him are legit power hitting prospects or minor league veterans. Profar makes contact, has power, draws walks, and might be a good enough shortstop to force Elvis Andrus out of the way, which is saying something indeed. He doesn’t have Mike Trout‘s speed, and you shouldn’t expect any prospect to flourish the way Trout has this season, but it’s not crazy to say that Profar is a similar type of hitter, with the added ability to play shortstop as well.

27. (40) Carlos Gonzalez, OF, Colorado – Signed through 2017 for $74 million

There’s no question that Gonzalez derives a large benefit from playing in Denver, and he wouldn’t hit as well if he was traded back to sea level. However, even after you adjust for his home park, he’s a 26-year-old running a 157 wRC+, showing that his 2010 season wasn’t a complete fluke. Gonzalez has developed into one of the game’s best offensive performers, and he’s one of the premier power/speed guys in the game today. His defense is still not fantastic, but for a team looking for a young hitter to build around, Gonzalez wouldn’t be a bad place to start. I will readily admit that I was wrong about the $80 million extension that the Rockies gave him last year, which looks like a pretty good deal in retrospect.

26. (7) Joey Votto, 1B, Cincinnati – Signed through 2023 for $246 million

With a 10 year, $225 million extension that doesn’t even kick in until 2014, Votto became one of the most expensive players in the sport. However, because he’s still just 28, the cost of the deal is deferred well into the future, and any team acquiring him would essentially be getting the best hitter in baseball at bargain rates for the next half decade or so. There’s a ton of value in the front of this contract, and so while the last few years are likely going to bring negative returns, large revenue franchises would love to have him even with his new sticker price. There might not be a large quantity of bidders, but several teams would pay a high price to add Votto to their line-up right now and deal with the financial consequences in 2020 and beyond when that gets here.

And, for those who missed the post yesterday afternoon, here is the real #25-#21, with their write-ups from the #26-#30 post.

25. (NR) Jason Kipnis, 2B, Cleveland – Under Team Control through 2017

When the Indians drafted Kipnis out of Arizona State, he was seen as a tweener outfielder without the speed to play center or the power to play left. So, a few months after selecting him in the third round, the Indians moved him to second base, and are now being rewarded for their foresight. Kipnis has gotten a lot better at second in a hurry, and now profiles as an average to above average defender at an up-the-middle position, and provides the kind of offense (122 wRC+ over 541 MLB plate appearances) you don’t often get from a player at the keystone. Kinpis is a classic good-across-the-board guy, combining gap power with walks and improving contact rates while also being a highly efficient baserunner. In many ways, he profiles as the new Ian Kinsler, and as a 25-year-old with five more seasons of team control, the Indians will be able to get a lot of value from Kipnis without paying a high price to do so.

24. (NR) Matt Moore, SP, Tampa Bay – Signed through 2019 for $36 million

On the field, Moore has been a pretty big disappointment this year, struggling with command problems and showing that he wasn’t quite as polished as he looked down the stretch last year. However, he’s still a lefty with a mid-90s fastball who can miss bats, and teams haven’t forgotten how dominant he was in 2011, so a disappointing rookie season hasn’t shattered his value yet. And then, there’s the contract. In typical Rays fashion, they signed Moore extremely early in exchange for getting team options on his final arbitration year and his first two free agent years, so they’re only on the hook for about $15 million if he never develops. If he does, they’ve essentially got him locked up through age 30 at bargain rates (though there are a lot of incentives built into the deal, so knowing the precise amount ahead of time is impossible). He’s a higher risk guy without the performance track record of many others around him, but he also comes with extremely high reward due to the financial limitations he’s agreed to. If he does turn into an ace, he could end up near the very top of this list in a few years.

23. (5) Justin Upton, OF, Arizona – Signed through 2015 for $42 million.

This ranking is about to be put to the test, as everyone is aware that the Diamondbacks are currently shopping Upton around baseball and will likely trade him at some point in 2012. A year ago, it seemed hard to imagine the D’Backs giving up on their star right fielder, but another mediocre season has made Upton seem like an underachiever once again, so any team acquiring him would be making a bet on a big comeback after changing teams. The talent is certainly there, but he’s no longer all that cheap — the last three years of his contract total $39 million — and has a spotty record hitting away from Chase Field. There’s a lot of risk to be absorbed by any acquiring team, but potential franchise players aren’t moved in their mid-20s too often, especially when they’re not close to free agency. Whether Upton will command a star player’s return or will be shipped off for less than his talent would suggest remains to be seen, but we should have a better idea of how baseball views Upton later this year.

22. (NR) Mike Moustakas, 3B, Kansas City – Under Team Control through 2017

Moustakas was awful during the early part of his rookie season last year, but found his power stroke late in the season and hasn’t slowed down in 2012. He’s still not a finished product, but he’s flashing a combination of above average offense and terrific defense at age 23, and has shown very good contact skills in prior years as well. If he can get back to those lower strikeout rates while sustaining his power output, he may very well may be the new Adrian Beltre, or at least a player of similar value. Because of when he was called up last season, Moustakas may end up as a Super Two, qualifying for arbitration four times and accelerating his pay schedule, but the Royals still control his rights for five more years and have a young star in place at third. Even if he doesn’t remain overly cheap for more than a year or two, he’s still a highly valuable commodity.

21. (NR) Gio Gonzalez, SP, Washington – Signed through 2018 for $65 million

I wasn’t a big fan of the Gio Gonzalez trade for the Nationals, but kudos to Mike Rizzo and his staff for anticipating the breakout pitching star of 2012 and getting him while they still could. Gio’s velocity is up and he’s throwing first pitch strikes, which has led to a huge spike in strikeout rate and a reduction in walks, and the overall package has seen Gio pitch like a legitimate ace. His command is still not fantastic, and previous history suggests that he may not be able to keep this up forever, but Gonzalez looks like a better pitcher than I gave him credit for over the winter. To boot, the contract Washington signed him to now looks like a pretty big steal, as he would have been in for a hefty raise via arbitration, but is now looking at a salary of just $6 million in 2013 with manageable raises for the following three seasons, and then two team options at the end of that. There’s room for Gonzalez to regress and still be worth the contract, and if he keeps pitching like he is right now, he’ll be a huge steal for years to come.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

2012 Trade Value: #20-#16.

20. (12) David Price, SP, Tampa Bay – Under Team Control through 2015

The Rays ace has continued his steady climb into elite territory, and is establishing himself as one of the dominant left-handed starters in the game. At age 26, he’s added nearly one MPH to his average fastball velocity and has become a groundball pitcher for the first time in his career while maintaining his usual blend of few walks and a lot of strikeouts. The only thing holding Price back from a higher ranking is the fact that he’s got three more trips through arbitration, and as a guy who qualified as a Super Two, he’s going to get expensive in a hurry. This is the one guy the Rays weren’t able to get locked up that they probably wish they could have, and because of his escalation paychecks, he may not be in Tampa Bay all that much longer. When the Rays do trade him, however, they’ll get a monstrous return.

19. (NR) Madison Bumgarner, SP, San Francisco – Signed through 2019 for $58 million

Okay Giants fans, you win. Bumgarner’s absence from last year’s list brought plenty of criticism, and it was simply a poor call on my end to exclude him. Now, with another year of quality pitching under his belt and a very friendly contract — the first five guaranteed years only call for $35 million in total — Bumgarner not only makes the list, but rates as one of the more valuable pitchers in the game. There aren’t many 22-year-olds who can throw strikes as regularly as Bumgarner can, and he gets enough strikeouts and groundballs to make the overall package work. He might not be a classic ace, but he’s a good pitcher with a very good contract, and every team in baseball would love to have him.

18. (NR) Miguel Cabrera, 3B/1B, Detroit – Signed through 2015 for $75 million.

Perhaps the biggest benefactor of the shift towards rewarding premium players with large contracts, Cabrera was also unranked a year ago due to the amount of money that he’s still owed over the next 3 1/2 years Given the rising costs of acquiring big time hitters, however, there are a number of teams that would gladly line up to pay Cabrera $22 million per year without a long term commitment. While he’s taken a bit of a step backwards this year (protection theory, where are you?), he’s still an offensive force, and he doesn’t even turn 30 until next spring. Even with the salary of a star player, the Tigers would get a strong return for him if they put him on the blocks.

17. (14) Felix Hernandez, SP, Seattle – Signed through 2014 for $49 million

While his fastball velocity is still MIA and he doesn’t get ground balls like he used to, he’s getting better at every other part of pitching. His change-up is one of the best single pitches in the game, and to compensate for the lack of ground balls, he’s just started using it to strike everyone out instead. Like Price, Felix is just 26 years old, so while he doesn’t come with a team friendly long term contract, any team acquiring him would have a couple of years to convince him to stick around, and in the meantime, they’d have one of the true legitimate #1 starters in the sport.

#16. (11) Clayton Kershaw, SP, Los Angeles Dodgers – Under Team Control through 2015

Trying not to sound repetitive with the above paragraph, but there are a lot of similarities between Kershaw and Felix at this point. Like Felix, Kershaw also has two years left before he hits free agency, though his already negotiated 2013 salary is significantly lower. Kershaw is also still just 24, so he’ll be up for his next contract well before his decline years become a big concern. He’s probably the most coveted left-handed pitcher in the game, and given his age and performance, he’d rank significantly higher if the Dodgers had been able to buy out any of his free agent years. Even with just 2+ years under control, however, Kershaw is so good that he’d command a king’s ransom in return if the Dodgers decided to put him up for sale.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

2012 Trade Value: #15-#11.

15. (NR) Brett Lawrie, 3B, Toronto – Under Team Control through 2017

For all that is made about how remarkable Starlin Castro‘s Major League success is, we shouldn’t ignore the fact that Lawrie is only two months older. While he hasn’t been able to match last year’s ridiculous debut, his career line is .283/.339/.459 in what amounts to one big league season. Any 22-year-old who has a 117 wRC+ is off to a pretty good start to their career, but Lawrie’s not just a bat-only guy. Whether or not he’s actually a +15 defender as UZR has given him credit for is still to be determined, but the scouting reports on his glovework have also been fantastic, and he’s athletic enough to be a plus glove at the position. If the timing of his performances were flipped and Lawrie was currently in the midst of what he did last summer, he might be a top 10 guy. Even still, this version is an above average player at an age when most of his peers are still in the minor leagues. Add in five more years of team control, and Lawrie is still a tremendously valuable asset.

14. (19) Justin Verlander, SP, Detroit – Signed through 2014 for $50 million

Remember how we told you that Verlander couldn’t sustain last year’s .236 BABIP? Well, we were right — he’s all the way up to .242 this year. As crazy as it sounds, he’s basically having the exact same year that he did last year, and is the pitcher most people would choose if they had to win a single game. The only thing keeping him this low is his contract, which expires at the same time as Kershaw and Felix, and the last couple years of his extension aren’t particularly cheap. But, if Verlander was a free agent this winter, he’d almost certainly command the largest contract ever given to a pitcher, so in reality, 2/40 is far less than market value for Detroit’s ace. It’s essentially impossible to see them moving him in any scenario, but if they did, the bidding would be outrageous.

13. (NR) Jered Weaver, SP, Anaheim – Signed through 2016 for $77 million

Like Verlander, Weaver is also duplicating his unsustainable 2011 performance, and is actually having his best year yet in terms of run prevention relative to league average. While Weaver might not be as classicly dominant as Verlander, his track record is impossible to argue with now, and he’s under contract for an additional two seasons. Weaver took less than he could have gotten otherwise to stay in Anaheim, and and he’s gotten better since he signed his contract. His home/road splits and not-acelike peripherals might keep a few teams at bay, but four years of a premium pitcher at a below market price would still generate a lot of interest. Like Verlander, though, it’s impossible to see Weaver going anywhere.

12. (27) Buster Posey, C, San Francisco – Under Team Control through 2016

Posey has come back from his broken leg and been better than ever, and probably doesn’t get enough credit for the Giants success in recent years. He’s already at +8.5 WAR in just under 1,000 career plate appearances, so he’s contributed at a near MVP level pretty much since the day he arrived in the big leagues. He’s even added walks to round out his offensive game, and based on the factors that we can judge with some degree of certainty, he appears to be one of the game’s best defensive catchers as well. The questions about how long he’ll remain at catcher and his Super Two status mean that he might be an expensive first baseman by the time he reaches free agency, but for the next several years, he’s one of baseball’s great bargains. While the pitchers (and more recently, Melky Cabrera) have gotten most of the attention, Posey is the straw that stirs the drink in San Francisco.

11. (3) Troy Tulowitzki, SS, Colorado – Signed through 2020 for $148 million

Another injury plagued season for Tulowitzki, who is looking more and more like a guy who just won’t be able to play 150 games in a season all that often. Durability is a skill, and with each season that goes by, it seems less likely that it’s one he possesses. But that might be the only baseball-related skill he doesn’t have, and even with the injuries, Tulowitzki is still a premium player capable of putting up hugely valuable seasons — he topped +6 WAR in each of the last two years despite just averaging 130 games per year. There’s eight guaranteed years left on his deal with a team option for a ninth season that could push the total money up over $160 million, but because he’s still just 27, the Rockies shouldn’t have too many large negative value years at the end of the deal, and he’s worth far more than the $18 million per year he’s being paid. If he could stay healthy, he’d still be in the top 10, but even with the health issues, Tulo is still a guy to build around.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

2012 Trade Value: #10-#6.

10. (2) Jose Bautista, OF, Toronto – Signed through 2015 for $63 million

An early season slump and another low BABIP has Bautista performing at a more human level than the past few years, though he’s still among the best hitters in the game. However, he does turn 32 in October, so whether he’s going to remain an elite player for much longer is an open question. The steal of a contract that the Blue Jays signed him to in 2010 has four years left at $14 million per year, and then there’s a team option for 2016 at the same price. For the next couple of years, it’s a significant discount, though I probably wouldn’t expect the option to be exercised. For a team in need of a short term offensive boost without taking a huge hit to their payroll, Bautista would be one of the most appealing players in the sport.

9. (8) Jason Heyward, OF, Atlanta – Under Team Control through 2015.

Heyward has bounced back nicely from his disappointing 2011 season, showing a different set of skills than what made him a heavily hyped rookie and flashing potential to be a premier all-around hitter. Still a few weeks shy of his 23rd birthday, Heyward already has 1,400 career plate appearances and has posted a 120 wRC+ during those three years. Guys who can do that over an extended period from 20-22 generally turn into superstars. There are downsides here, though — health has been an issue, for one, and he’s only three years from free agency. Any team trying to pry Heyward from the Braves would be hoping to land a franchise player, but would need to pony up a large contract in order to get his prime years locked up, and they probably wouldn’t come cheap given what Heyward has already accomplished. Still, he’s one of the best young hitters in the game, and a legitimate franchise cornerstone.

8. (24) Stephen Strasburg, SP, Washington – Under Team Control through 2016

If durability wasn’t a question mark, Strasburg would be in the mix for the #1 spot. So, yes, he’s a pitcher, and we acknowledge that pitchers get hurt more often and have a high risk of flameouts, but we can’t just ignore the fact that Strasburg is outpitching everyone in baseball on a per-innings basis. His 67 xFIP- is the best mark of any qualified starter this year, and puts him on par with most recent Cy Young winners. There’s no question about Strasburg’s abilities — if his arm stays together, he’s a Hall of Fame talent. Any pitcher is a gamble, but Strasburg offers enough potential to make that a gamble that GMs want to take, especially given that they’d control his rights for four more years without the downside of a guaranteed contract.

7. (NR) Matt Kemp, OF, Los Angeles Dodgers – Signed through 2019 for $153 million

It took about a month for Kemp’s 8 year/$160 million contract to look like a steal, as he spent April proving that last year was no fluke. He’s not the best defensive center fielder around and his lingering hamstring problems are a bit of a concern, but Kemp is still a 27-year-old five tool superstar who might just be baseball’s best overall player when he’s on the field. The Dodgers took a risk in paying him big money after what appeared to be a caree year, but Kemp is performing at an even higher level this season, and simply looks like he’s developed into one of the game’s true elite players. He probably can’t keep hitting as well as he has so far in 2012, but then again, we said that last year too.

6. (31) Ryan Braun, OF, Milwaukee Brewers – Signed through 2020 for $128 million

At age 28, Braun has essentially developed into a complete all around player. He’s always had power, but his game was rough around the edges before he made the leap last year. Now, with improved plate discipline, better defense, and more aggressive baserunning, Braun has no real weaknesses on the field. While I didn’t understand the Brewers desire to an extend his contract until 2020 when they already had him signed through 2015, the move now looks like it will save them tens of millions of dollars, and was one of the best decisions in franchise history. The Brewers have essentially locked up one of the game’s rare talents for well below market rates, and they didn’t have to guarantee years beyond age 36 in order to get a lower price. Braun’s a great player with a great contract, and is only this low because of the great wave of young talent that has pushed their way past him with their incredible production.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

2012 Trade Value: #5-#1.

5. (16) Giancarlo Stanton, OF, Miami – Under Team Control through 2016.

Stanton is a beast of a hitter, and he’s only getting better. He got to the Majors as a 20-year-old who struck out too much, but while he still swings and misses a lot, he’s got his strikeout rate down to acceptable levels, and he’s matured into the game’s best young power hitter. For comparison, Stanton has been better through age 22 than Miguel Cabrera, and on the same level as Ken Griffey Jr and Alex Rodriguez. He doesn’t offer the same kind of defensive value of those two, but young hitters don’t get much better than this. With four more years of team control, Stanton is one of the most valuable pieces in the game today, though his numbers are going to assure that he gets paid in arbitration. Given how quickly he’s become a great hitter, the Marlins may regret not locking him up sooner.

4. (1) Evan Longoria, 3B, Tampa Bay – Signed through 2016 for $38 million.

After a long stint at the top of this list, Longoria has finally been dethroned. Injuries have essentially wiped out his age 26 season, and he’s down to just four more years left on the seemingly never-ending contract the Rays signed him to as a rookie. However, this fall in the rankings is more about the three guys in front of him than about Longoria himself. Even with the durability questions, he’s still one of the game’s elite talents, and that contract is still paying him a tiny fraction of what he’s actually worth. In a normal year, Longoria would have still been in the mix for the top spot, but this isn’t a normal year. This is a year that has seen three young outfielders all perform at incredible levels, and that trio has emerged as the future of the sport. This is no knock on Longoria. He’s just been displaced by three guys who could each carry the sport on their back for the next decade.

3. (6) Andrew McCutchen, OF, Pittsburgh – Signed through 2018 for $63 million.

McCutchen entered the year as a consistently solid hitter after posting a wRC+ of 125, 125, and 129 during his first three years in the big leagues. This year, McCutchen has exploded, turning doubles into home runs and outhitting every other player in the National League. His 187 wRC+ is second in baseball, and at age 25, he’s turned into a true superstar. He probably won’t keep hitting for power at this level, but even if some of those home runs turn back into doubles, he’s still a premier all around talent. The Pirates were extremely smart to lock up McCutchen over the off-season, buying out all of his arbitration years and getting his first three years of free agency as well. He’s worth several magnitudes more than the contract is going to pay him, and he’s almost single-handedly restored Pittsburgh’s credibility as a franchise. The Pirates have a superstar who isn’t going anywhere any time soon, and that’s good for both the city and the sport as a whole.

2. (20) Bryce Harper, OF, Washington – Under Team Control through 2018

When I finished the initial version of this list a couple of weeks ago, Harper was #1. His placement at second on this list really has nothing to do with his July slump — where he’s finally looked human for the first time since arriving in the big leagues — he just got passed by an epic tornado of brilliance in Anaheim. Harper is still the premier young talent in the sport. Comparisons range from Josh Hamilton (with plate discipline) to Ken Griffey Jr, and outside of an injury or off the field issue, it’s hard to see any career trajectory for Harper that doesn’t end with him as the best player in baseball.

What he’s doing in the big leagues as a teenager is special, and I’d still take his future over any other player on the planet. But, right now, Harper is simply a good player who can be a solid piece on a winning team. By next year, he could be a superstar, but he’s not quite there yet, which is just fine, because he’s 19-years-old. His future is amazing. His present is very good. That was good enough for the top spot until last week, when the #1 spot on this list was finally just torn out of his hands through sheer force by…

1. (21) Mike Trout, OF, Anaheim Angels – Under Team Control through 2017

Since getting called up to the Majors, Trout has been the best player in baseball, and it hasn’t even been particularly close. At his current rate of performance, he’d average +10.3 WAR per 600 plate appearances. For his career, Babe Ruth averaged 10.0 WAR per 600 plate appearances. Yeah. There’s just not much left to say about what Trout is doing right now. He’s almost certainly not going to keep this up because no one can keep this up, but what we’re seeing is a 20-year-old with no real flaws in his game.

39 of his 107 hits have gone for extra bases. He’s 31 for 34 in base stealing. He’s an amazing defensive center fielder. Three times he’s tried to bunt his way on base, and three times he’s been successful. He makes contact, he hits for power, he doesn’t swing at pitches out of the zone, and he can run like the wind. The only way Trout could be better at baseball is if he was also a dynamite pitcher with a 99 mph fastball.

When I was polling baseball people for their opinions on Harper versus Trout, it came down mostly on Harper’s side. But then, over the last two weeks, I’ve had a half dozen people send me notes saying that they’ve changed their minds. What Mike Trout is doing right now is something we haven’t seen since Alex Rodriguez in 1996. 20-year-olds aren’t supposed to be the best player in baseball. Right now, Mike Trout probably is.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
Thanks Pro

I'm not worried about Ichiro, I honestly think he will hit around .300, he's probably been waiting years to leave Seattle.
 
I doubt it's true because it's ******g ******ed but I heard they are open to include Zach Lee for a Garza deal.
 
If Theo manages to flip Z, Garza, Dempster, Sori all in the same year, he should get a medal with the Olympians. :lol:

I've never had a stacked minor league system, so it will be interesting to see what it feels like. :wow:
 
Dodgers getting anybody?

Ryan Dempster is pushing the only weight he has to land in LA, Theo wants Zach Lee, but he won't be included for a rental. Lee in a deal for Garza would make more sense.

Also the Marlins are waiting for the us to jump in the Hanley Ramirez sweepstakes. Wouldn't mind taking a shot at Hanley, but his stock has taken a major hit the past two years and he has a lot of red flags.

It will be interesting to see what happens at the deadline.
 
Dempster wants to go to LA so he gets no run support?

And I'm not touching Hanley for his asking price.
 
Read someone today suggest an Elvis Andrus for Justin Upton swag in the offseason to make room for Profar... Not sure how I feel about it, but I think I like it.
 
IDK man including Lee for Garza, I'd rather include Lee for a bat if at all. That kid is gonna be special. Garza isn't worth that.

Just Elvis Dirk?
 
i don't want Dempster he can stay with the Cubs or go to LA

Delgado is struggling but he shouldn't be traded for a couple months of Dempster i'd do it for Greinke though.  
 
If Theo manages to flip Z, Garza, Dempster, Sori all in the same year, he should get a medal with the Olympians. :lol:
I've never had a stacked minor league system, so it will be interesting to see what it feels like. :wow:

I understand Z and Sori since their contracts were horrid. Theo is not getting much for Dempster, he has 10-5 rights, is in his last year of his deal so don't see the jumping for joy here. Dempster basically took all the leverage out of Theo's hands by nixing the trade to the Braves. They are now asking for Allen Webster, a pitcher with a back end of the rotation ceiling, new to pitching, converted SS.

Flip Garza? 28 year old pitcher under team control and you guys are happy to dump him?

Will never understand Cub fans.


Dempster wants to go to LA so he gets no run support?

And I'm not touching Hanley for his asking price.

When you're fielding a triple A lineup due to your best offensive players being out, Kemp and Ethier, of course runs are going to be hard to come by.


IDK man including Lee for Garza, I'd rather include Lee for a bat if at all. That kid is gonna be special. Garza isn't worth that.
Just Elvis Dirk?

I wouldn't include Lee for anything, just saying I could see him included in a deal for Garza since he is under team control. Wouldn't even include him in a deal for Hanley.
 
Cinco I'm with you. Thought it was weird that the Marlins were waiting for us to get involved even though the A's we're seen as a leader.

Just felt he was coming West since we are willing to take on money now. Interested to see how much money Miami will eat.

Hanley's stock is low, hopefully a change of scenery does him some good. This move can pay off immensely. If he continues his slide I can live with taking this risk.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom