Spanking Children? Right or Wrong?

Originally Posted by ColdCity

spare the rod spoil the child

thread/
basically. I spank/beat my daughter then explain to her what she did wrong and show her what she is/isn't supposed to do

  
 
Originally Posted by SonOfTony

i got spanked when i was a kid and so will my kids when i have em


This and even when I wasnt so little... Im better off b/c of it so my kids will b gettin whooped when they cut up too haha
 
Originally Posted by SonOfTony

i got spanked when i was a kid and so will my kids when i have em


This and even when I wasnt so little... Im better off b/c of it so my kids will b gettin whooped when they cut up too haha
 
i got +$% whoopins when i was a kid & so did everybody i know & i will be whoopin my kids. but i know for me it just made me mad & most days i got multiple beatins in a day so maybe i aint learn nuthin from it
 
i got +$% whoopins when i was a kid & so did everybody i know & i will be whoopin my kids. but i know for me it just made me mad & most days i got multiple beatins in a day so maybe i aint learn nuthin from it
 
CincoSeisDos wrote:
Originally Posted by Joe Billionaire

some kids need a spanking...

Absolutely.

Spank only if necessary I would talk to them like a few time just until I got tired of it then comes the beating because talking obviously doesn't work so I would try something else but at least when they get hit they know they deserved it
  
 
IMO it all depends on the kid. Some kids are easygoing and will listen and behave well without the punishment of spanking. Some kids are terrible and will act like demons unless they are physically punished.

When I was little my mom never hit me, but I still listened to her and treated her with respect.
 
IMO it all depends on the kid. Some kids are easygoing and will listen and behave well without the punishment of spanking. Some kids are terrible and will act like demons unless they are physically punished.

When I was little my mom never hit me, but I still listened to her and treated her with respect.
 
CincoSeisDos wrote:
Originally Posted by Joe Billionaire

some kids need a spanking...

Absolutely.

Spank only if necessary I would talk to them like a few time just until I got tired of it then comes the beating because talking obviously doesn't work so I would try something else but at least when they get hit they know they deserved it
  
 
If it reaches the point where you have to physically discipline your children, you have failed at parenting.
 
things used by my parents when I was young:


rambbowt0.jpg

belt-buckle-357-fancy-eagle.jpg

hanger_cropped_h6zr.jpg






Will a hit my kids?

F yeah.
 
Originally Posted by don23lucia

Spank em

Why? Is hurting a child better than logically explaining why what they are doing is wrong? Children are fast learners imo. They can later apply the knowledge they gain from that to things. Spanking imo will lead children to fear getting hit instead of actually realizing why what they are doing is wrong. Which imo is more important then spanking a kid to make them stop doing wrong. Also spanking will in turn teach children to do wrong but to not get caught. Just my opinion.
Example: Kid blatantly takes candy from store and eats it. Kid gets spanked. Kid learns how to steal candy without getting caught.
Kid takes candy. Parent explains why that is not okay. Kid learns that stealing is wrong. Later applies that to things later on in life.
 
If it reaches the point where you have to physically discipline your children, you have failed at parenting.
 
Originally Posted by don23lucia

Spank em

Why? Is hurting a child better than logically explaining why what they are doing is wrong? Children are fast learners imo. They can later apply the knowledge they gain from that to things. Spanking imo will lead children to fear getting hit instead of actually realizing why what they are doing is wrong. Which imo is more important then spanking a kid to make them stop doing wrong. Also spanking will in turn teach children to do wrong but to not get caught. Just my opinion.
Example: Kid blatantly takes candy from store and eats it. Kid gets spanked. Kid learns how to steal candy without getting caught.
Kid takes candy. Parent explains why that is not okay. Kid learns that stealing is wrong. Later applies that to things later on in life.
 
My daughter just turned one and I don't believe in spanking or yelling. I often get compliments at stores or kids birthday parties about how well behaved she is
 
My daughter just turned one and I don't believe in spanking or yelling. I often get compliments at stores or kids birthday parties about how well behaved she is
 
Originally Posted by BK201


Example: Kid blatantly takes candy from store and eats it. Kid gets spanked. Kid learns how to steal candy without getting caught.
Kid takes candy. Parent explains why that is not okay. Kid learns that stealing is wrong. Later applies that to things later on in life.


So the parent that spanks their child nonchalantly omits justifying the punishment received?

Ok.
 
Originally Posted by BK201


Example: Kid blatantly takes candy from store and eats it. Kid gets spanked. Kid learns how to steal candy without getting caught.
Kid takes candy. Parent explains why that is not okay. Kid learns that stealing is wrong. Later applies that to things later on in life.


So the parent that spanks their child nonchalantly omits justifying the punishment received?

Ok.
 
my 2 stepkids are bad ##%%% b/c their daddy was never around so momma went easy cuz she felt sorry for them. When we got together i went ham on them for they way they acted just outright disrespectful b/c they were told no, now they listen way better than before but still have fits as all kids will btu its a dramatic improvement. I do not have to beat them near like i used now its just for serious stuff like lying or being disrespectful to their mother. My baby is 2 and she gets spanked as well but she also knows when i am serious and for the most part acts right i think it just depends on how you raise them from the star but all kids need a spanking or beating whatever you want to call it form time to time.
 
my 2 stepkids are bad ##%%% b/c their daddy was never around so momma went easy cuz she felt sorry for them. When we got together i went ham on them for they way they acted just outright disrespectful b/c they were told no, now they listen way better than before but still have fits as all kids will btu its a dramatic improvement. I do not have to beat them near like i used now its just for serious stuff like lying or being disrespectful to their mother. My baby is 2 and she gets spanked as well but she also knows when i am serious and for the most part acts right i think it just depends on how you raise them from the star but all kids need a spanking or beating whatever you want to call it form time to time.
 
Back
Top Bottom