My point exactly. You can't put into words what your criteria is because you don't have one. It's all random, basically whatever formula that makes you right.
I'd really like you to explain to me since your the most vocal how you personally go about the process. How much weight do titles and stats hold for you? Please I'm curious to know.
What criteria do you have again? As far as I can tell, it's being a "vocal and emotional leader" and vague references to an "eye test" with no further explanation. Ha ha ha
At least Mister Friendly has his Starting Lineup figures and ESPY awards. I'm still confused about how you rate/evaluate players.