In their primes, Kidd or Nash?

[jehlers02]

Dont know if this has been discussed before, but like the title says who was better in their primes?

Nash is by far a better shooter, and is one of the most effective players ever using the pick and roll. He could throw up 20-30 points to go along with his assist count in the double digits.

Kidd was basically a walking triple-double. Better defender/rebounder.

 

[darthska]

back-to-back Finals

But yeah, no player a vs. player b threads.

*locked*

 

[Master Zik]

Kidd. Better passer in all facets; style/flare/flashy, efficiency, etc.

Nash will always be a better shooter but he can't see Kidd in the assist department.