Official Heisman Watch

Discussion in 'Sports & Training' started by wildkycat, Oct 14, 2007.

  1. wildkycat

    wildkycat

    6,996
    127
    Joined
    Jun 11, 2004
    1a. Andre Woodson
    1b. Matt Ryan
    3. Mike Hart
    4. Darren McFadden
    5. Erik Ainge
    6. Sam Bradford
    7. Colt Brennan
    8. Dennis Dixon
    9. Chase Daniel
    10. Tim Tebow
    11. Brian Brohm
    12. DeSean Jackson
    13. Colt McCoy

    *disclaimer* it ain't easy ranking 13 dudes, and i know that's alot of QB's, but i like my top 6.

    agree? disagree? thoughts? discuss.
    BELIEVE​
     
  2. doublejs07

    doublejs07

    21,173
    24
    Joined
    Mar 14, 2004
    My list....

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]
     
  3. gunna get it

    gunna get it

    31,876
    934
    Joined
    Jul 24, 2007
    Woodson
    Hart
    Ryan
    Grothe

    thats all


    McFadden with them 50 yards rushing last nite, He gonna have to get his "Reggie Bush vs Fresno St" on against every opponent from here on out.
    [color=ff0000]P[/color][color=ff3333]H[/color][color=ff6666]I[/color][color=ff9a9a]L[/color]A 76[color=9a9aff]E[/color][color=6666ff]R[/color][color=3333ff]S[/color]
    [color=000066]S[/color][color=0000FF]T[/color][color=6699FF]L[/color] R[color=FFFF99]A[/color][color=FFFF33]M[/color][color=FFFF00]S[/color]

    Popcorn & Raisinettes, My Life's a Movie
     
  4. ak nako

    ak nako

    1,281
    110
    Joined
    Dec 30, 2002
    Woodson, Hart, Ryan right now. As of this week that IS the race.

    EDIT

    actually toss Grothe in there too I guess, he's playing well.

    Bradford is having a great season but I don't know if it's heisman caliber...
    Team DJ Bana Fan Club​

    ano, sumimasen. anata wa totemo kirei desu ne.​
     
  5. nowitness41dirk

    nowitness41dirk

    15,499
    345
    Joined
    May 31, 2006
    If you got Colt Brennan at 7, Graham Harrell HAS to be above him, period. I don't think either has to chance to win it, but Harrell has just been flat out better this year, no questions asked.

    3,151 Passing Yards (1)
    31 TDs (1)
    3 INTs
    74.4% Completion% (1)
    178.8 Passer Rating (2)

    System or not, the kid is having one hell of a year. And in a year where there's no clear-cut favorite, the stats monsters have to get a look, especially if that team stays competitive in the BigXii...

    Right now, Mike Hart, Matt Ryan, Dre Woodson, Matt Grothe are the Top 4, the fifth spot is TBD...
    TEAMCOWBOYS
    Winning is the only option...
     
  6. meb07

    meb07 Banned

    256
    10
    Joined
    Jun 1, 2007
    Woodson
    Ryan
    Dixon
    Hart
    Grothe
    McFadden
    TEAMYANKEES
     
  7. af writer

    af writer

    215
    10
    Joined
    Mar 13, 2005
    Hart and Woodson
    Team Wolverine
    Fire Lloyd
    DETROIT LIONS
    Fire Millen​
     
  8. vq35dett

    vq35dett

    79
    10
    Joined
    Jul 9, 2005
    Ray Rice put himself back in the wide open Heisman race with his game against Saracuse yesterday.
     
  9. kingkb34

    kingkb34

    2,343
    10
    Joined
    Oct 20, 2005
     
  10. meb07

    meb07 Banned

    256
    10
    Joined
    Jun 1, 2007
     
  11. jules winnfield 1994

    jules winnfield 1994 Banned

    9
    10
    Joined
    Oct 8, 2006
    Wow I cant believe my boy Hart getting some respect now.
    TEAM BUFFALO BILLS​
    Team Lost Power City ruined my life​
     
  12. wildkycat

    wildkycat

    6,996
    127
    Joined
    Jun 11, 2004
     
  13. lb510

    lb510

    13,443
    219
    Joined
    May 9, 2006
    The real list

    Woodson Very acurate passer will be a good pro but doesn't seem to throw more than a 20 yard pass, this will hurt his NFL stock, but if he plays like he's been playing and the win out he's your winner.
    Hart A ture Warrior who will be the best Pro out of anyone on this list has all the skills and could make a run for it with a huge game against OSU.
    Dixion I think the los to Cal is really going to hurt his chances, isn't as acurate as a passer as the rest of the other heisman hopefulll QB's
    Harrell If you go from pure stats he's your winner 31 tds 3 ints in a very strong Big 12 this year but since he goes to texas tech he won't)
    Grothe won't win because well he goes to South Flordia and they play no one.

    Those who in my eyes have no shot/ Didn'nt play well enough early

    McFadden (50 yards and sharing carries with Jones in the long run makes him better but short trem hurts his chances)

    Tebow (was better last year,too many other QB's a head of him, Forida is gonna finish with three losses)

    DeSean Jackson (Has the talent but he doesn't get the ball enough)

    McCoy(Texas is having a down year, and there are better QB's out there, was better last year)

    Erik Ainge(His team has fallen off the map, there are better QB's out there)

    Brohm (Plays well ever 3 games aginst low level talent)





    TEAM SF GIANTS

    The home of true champions
    If my aunt had balls she'd be my uncle​
     
  14. doublejs07

    doublejs07

    21,173
    24
    Joined
    Mar 14, 2004
    ^imma break down your post a lil later on cause you are WAAAAAY off on your "observations"....but real quick....

     
  15. gunna get it

    gunna get it

    31,876
    934
    Joined
    Jul 24, 2007
     
  16. marv machamp

    marv machamp

    1,485
    10
    Joined
    May 2, 2007
    DENNIS DIXON #10


    ...
     
  17. acidicality

    acidicality

    17,241
    61
    Joined
    May 20, 2004
     
  18. lb510

    lb510

    13,443
    219
    Joined
    May 9, 2006
    DoubleJs07- Lets talk stats

    Dixion is no where to be found in the list of top 40 in passing
    check for yourself (Woodson is 1 8) [​IMG]msn.foxsports.com/cfb/sor...descending

    70.2 yes there are a lot of bubble screens mixed in there.
    And if you really look at the game most of his passeses are deep ball in broken coverage if there receivers aren't open the balls not going to get there. Which leads to my third and final point the recivers aguably the best out of any of the Heisman QB's Oaklahoma fans mite debate that. If you have all that tallent why should Woodson,Ryan and Harell be a head of you. When they do WAY more with less?

    GUNNA GET IT- :evil: [​IMG] I'm and LSU fan so that might have been a little one sided :lol: [​IMG]
    TEAM SF GIANTS

    The home of true champions
    If my aunt had balls she'd be my uncle​
     
  19. doublejs07

    doublejs07

    21,173
    24
    Joined
    Mar 14, 2004
    You know that list is based off of passing yards right? If we were going solely off of PY, then Heisman's would have been won by Timmy Chang and Colt Brennan by now.

    Dennis Dixon..

    #5 in the nation in completion %

    #7 in yards per attempt

    #18 in TD passes

    only thrown 2 int's

    #3 in QB rating




    you do know that TTU runs a spread offense, and that is why they put up ridiculous numbers right? Harrell is the best QB to go through TTU in a while, but what argument do you have saying that he is more than a system QB? Look at the #'s Crabtree has put up....
     
  20. 5am6oody72

    5am6oody72

    7,356
    239
    Joined
    Sep 25, 2002
     
  21. downtown43

    downtown43

    8,534
    14
    Joined
    Mar 1, 2007
     
  22. juvedagreat

    juvedagreat

    123
    10
    Joined
    Jan 9, 2006
    Andre Woodson
    Mike Hart
    Jake Locker
    _______________

    the rest

    In that order :lol: [​IMG] :pimp: [​IMG]
    HUSKY FOOTBALL
    THIS IS LOCKER NATION​
     
  23. acidicality

    acidicality

    17,241
    61
    Joined
    May 20, 2004
    Jackson definitely is NOT a Heisman frontrunner anymore, not after the OSU game. But if people pay close attention, he draws so much attention that other receivers get opportunities, i.e. Lavelle Hawkins and Robert Jordan who both have had MONSTER games. It's almost a Barry Bonds thing, they're constantly double-triple teaming him out there that they're not letting him catch a pass. Plus, he's been hurt for most of the season (until Oregon) with a sprained thumb or somethin and that definitely affects the ability to catch the ball.

    He's no Heisman candidate now, but that doesn't take away he's one of the best receivers in college football right now, and the most explosive player in CF.
    Team49ers/CalBears/Warriors
    XVI . XIX . XXIII . XXIV . XXIX
    UCSD Football Win Total: 0​
     
  24. srvballer

    srvballer

    3,366
    61
    Joined
    Mar 25, 2005
    Woodson and Hart.
    TEAM WARRIORS
    SAN FRANCISCO 49ERS​
     
  25. downtown43

    downtown43

    8,534
    14
    Joined
    Mar 1, 2007