The Poorest Households Spend 9% of Their Income on Lottery Tickets

Discussion in 'General' started by crcballer55, Apr 1, 2012.

  1. crcballer55

    crcballer55

    3,939
    1,179
    Joined
    Nov 17, 2001
    To put this into perspective, if the same person invested that $97/mo. into the market at an annual rate of 10%, that would be equivelant to $700,000 over a 40 year period with only $47K invested. Instead, that's $47K that 99% of people will be throwing away.

    http://www.theatlantic.com/business...-9-of-their-income-on-lottery-tickets/255304/

    Mar 31 2012, 11:52 AM ET56
    The Mega Millions jackpot makes this the week to talk about lottery economics, so here's a whopper: Households earning less than $13,000 a year spend a shocking 9% of their money on lottery tickets, Henry Blodget relays from a PBS report.* Are they clueless? Are they desperate? Are they economical? Maybe, probably, and possibly.

    For the desperately poor, lotteries perform a role not unlike the obverse of insurance. Rather than pay a small sum of money in exchange for the guarantee of protection that you'll need in the future, you pay a small sum of money in exchange for the small probability that you'll win money to help your lot right away. It is, for lack of a better term, a kind of aspirational insurance.

    As it turns out, the typical U.S. family spending spends nearly the same share of its money -- 10.8% -- on insurance and pensions, including mandatory insurance programs like Social Security. The poorest working families also pay Social Security. But approximately 10% of households, most of them in the bottom decline, pay net zero federal taxes (including Social Security) due to tax credits in federal income tax code that bring their total federal burden past zero.
    [​IMG]
     
  2. jordan supreme

    jordan supreme

    2,961
    15
    Joined
    Jul 29, 2008
    The lottery is merely a tax on the poor...
     
  3. Mark Antony

    Mark Antony

    35,081
    20,109
    Joined
    May 1, 2010
    I doubt that figure is correct.
     
  4. mcraptor

    mcraptor

    2,625
    47
    Joined
    Apr 1, 2009
    I'd like to know where I can get this 10% return rate from 
     
  5. thegr8blkhope

    thegr8blkhope

    1,472
    49
    Joined
    May 9, 2007
    10% return? [​IMG]
     
  6. docsback

    docsback

    436
    10
    Joined
    Aug 4, 2001
    Yeah, or close to it.
     
  7. utvol23

    utvol23

    5,947
    472
    Joined
    Apr 5, 2004
    Over the LONG term some good long track mutual funds average around 10% rate of return.


    Fundamental Investors (growth-and-income fund)
    Class A shares
    Fund Number       10
    Ticker/Quotron Symbol     ANCFX
    Newspaper Abbreviation     FdInvA
    CUSIP Number     360802 10 2 
    Fund Inception  August 1, 1978
    Fund Lifetime Rate of Return:  12.52%


    The Growth Fund of America® (growth fund)
    Class A shares
    Fund Number       05
    Ticker/Quotron Symbol     AGTHX
    Newspaper Abbreviation     GwthA
    CUSIP Number     399874 10 6 
    Fund Inception  December 1, 1973
    Fund Lifetime Rate of Return:  13.79%


    The Investment Company of America®  (growth-and-income fund)
    Class A shares
    Fund Number       04
    Ticker/Quotron Symbol     AIVSX
    Newspaper Abbreviation     ICAA
    CUSIP Number     461308 10 8 
    Fund Inception  January 1, 1934
    Fund Lifetime Rate of Return:  12.18%


    New Perspective Fund® (growth fund)
    Class A shares
    Fund Number       07
    Ticker/Quotron Symbol     ANWPX
    Newspaper Abbreviation     N PerA
    CUSIP Number     648018 10 9 
    Fund Inception  March 13, 1973
    Fund Lifetime Rate of Return:  12.65%
     
  8. crcballer55

    crcballer55

    3,939
    1,179
    Joined
    Nov 17, 2001
    How about the stock market? It's been at least that over its history. Even with historic crashes like 1929, 1987, 2000, & 2008 it's averaged that over the long run. Heck, we're only 1000 points from where we were in 2007 before the wall street crash.
     
  9. shatterkneesinc

    shatterkneesinc Banned

    22,535
    2,383
    Joined
    Nov 26, 2005
    for real where do i get that...
    and plus poor people dont have much access to financial markets
     
  10. jeenewed

    jeenewed

    2,983
    21
    Joined
    Jun 30, 2008
    You gotta be in it to win it.
     
  11. crcballer55

    crcballer55

    3,939
    1,179
    Joined
    Nov 17, 2001
    It's pretty simple to gain access to financial markets (especially if you're spending $1300/yr. on lottery tickets). There are many funds with a minimum buy in of only $1000. It's all a matter of priorities.
     
  12. taymane23

    taymane23

    3,313
    84
    Joined
    Oct 5, 2010
    I can say for all my neighbors and family to claim that they're so poor they sure do spend a lot of money on lottery tickets and going to the casino. So somethin about that is right or somethin is being kept from me
     
  13. ham city

    ham city Banned

    10,150
    202
    Joined
    Oct 19, 2009
    Trust me my man, it's not that simple. Some of you need to widen your perspective, put yourself in other peoples shoes.
     
  14. e3lal

    e3lal

    3,254
    14
    Joined
    Jul 26, 2006
    [​IMG]@ thinking the market is for the 99%.  They sadly get used.  Just because the overall market looks to be back to comparable pre-08 levels does not mean that everyone recovered their losses.  Money gets shifted from sector to sector.
     
  15. crcballer55

    crcballer55

    3,939
    1,179
    Joined
    Nov 17, 2001
    More info? For me, it was as easy as opening an online brokerage account, importing some information, clicking some buttons and BAM, I was invested.
     
  16. flaming hot cheetos

    flaming hot cheetos

    1,982
    12
    Joined
    Apr 29, 2008
    Annnnnnnd you wonder how those idiots are/stay poor [​IMG]
     
  17. patrick bateman

    patrick bateman

    5,165
    621
    Joined
    Sep 2, 2010
    It's not hard to use your gambling money to put in a long term investment cache. Stop creating so many excuses for the "poorest" households.. Hell, I consider myself poor and I have a brokerage account. [​IMG] Yeah it may take a few years to familiarize yourself with how the market works and where to put your money... but spare me. Stop gambling and think long term.
     
  18. sushi and grits

    sushi and grits

    1,824
    84
    Joined
    May 29, 2008
    Lotto really is basically throwing your money in a trash can.

    People have this thing with "short-cuts" and don't have enough faith in building something with patience.
     
  19. shatterkneesinc

    shatterkneesinc Banned

    22,535
    2,383
    Joined
    Nov 26, 2005
    you can invest 1g but you have to pay commission, so just like that ur already in the red. economies of scale always goes against the poorer folks and more favorable to the wealthier who buys securities at a bulk

    the market is not like a swear jar where u just put money in

    also there is a substantial difference between paying 1g straight up and whatever chump change they spend on the lottery weekly

    and it is simple to have access to the financial markets...if they know how to that is, information is not always available for everybody

    you think if people were financial savvy they would be spending that much on the lottery...if those numbers are even real which i doubt 
     
  20. monstar1

    monstar1

    2,365
    18
    Joined
    Sep 2, 2011
    Not everyone is educated or wants to educate themselves.

    Lets face it.  Some people look for the easy dollar.  The majority of those people are poor.  If you already have money you won't think about gambling on regular basis with dreams of winning.  Most rich people gamble for the thrill.  Poor people gamble for the prize.

      
     
  21. patrick bateman

    patrick bateman

    5,165
    621
    Joined
    Sep 2, 2010
    ^ Yeah I've come to realize some people just don't want to learn or don't care to learn. Oh well. [​IMG]
     
  22. ruxxx

    ruxxx

    14,446
    239
    Joined
    Feb 5, 2009

    It really is.
     
  23. regis

    regis

    419
    16
    Joined
    Feb 2, 2012
    While you seem to know what youre talking about, you really do lack perspective.
    Education and financial status usually go hand in hand. It was easy for you cause you have an education.
     
  24. shiznut123

    shiznut123

    1,012
    228
    Joined
    Jun 1, 2003
    UTVol, good point, some mutual funds do offer pretty good returns over the long term, but you have to consider transaction costs, expenses, front-load, back-load, taxes, and inflation. Also a lot of these funds that show up in today's databases are also subject to survivorship bias. Only the funds that survive are listed, subjecting the average returns of these funds to an upward bias. 
    But yeah, mutual funds def should be considered for your average joe's portfolio. 
     
  25. crcballer55

    crcballer55

    3,939
    1,179
    Joined
    Nov 17, 2001
    Commissions on many funds aren't that substantial. No load funds with online brokerages require about a $10 upfront fee with no load paid until you sell the fund. That's a pretty good tradeoff to me. Plus, it doesn't really matter how much you make/lose in the first day/week/month. If you stick with it for the long run you'll more often than not come out in the black. This last decade was the first time in HISTORY that the American stock market has had a net loss over a 10 year history. Unless something drastic like the housing market happens again, I don't foresee that happening any time soon since there are very few other arenas that could take down the economy like housing.

    Most "poor" people should also have the same access to most of the information that many middle class people have as long as they have internet access. Morning Star, Yahoo Finance, & Fool.com are all great sources for free information. Like Patrick Bateman said, it's often an issue of people not wanting to learn or change their bad habits. Rather, it's easier to complain and blame a person's struggles on someone else.