Originally Posted by StillIn729
I said for the right price; say Oakland is willing to give you their 1st rounder because McFadden won't be back me year which is prob top ten; you wouldn't do that?
Desean didn't do much with Maclin the past two years did he? Our Redzone sucked with no big targets and still does
I'm not paying Desean $10 million next year which is the bottom line
This is all hypothetical so don't get so hurt about it
Lmao who's hurt? I'm simply discussing what you brought up, and I find the premise to be kind of ridiculous given circumstance. Andy/Marty's redzone playcalling left a ton to be desired and how is a 5-9, 170 wr going to be a threat in the red Zone anyway? We need to have a better big options than Riley Cooper and Brent Celek. And if you peep the stats Desean was having a great season before he got concussed last yr. and he'll no I'm not trading Shady for a single first roud draft pick. Oak lands not offering a top pick for Desean either. This is like playing fantasy football. Desean is having the best season of his career so far and you want to trade him. Some guys who make around 9million dollars like Desean: Dwayne Bowe, mike Wallace (both make 2-3 mill MORE), Miles Austin, Greg Jennings, victor Cruz, Andre Johnson, Pierre garçon aside from the studs that make more. That's the going rate for an upper level receiver. Who would be our wr tandem? We would win 4 games max with a rookie qb, league avg RB, 2 new wide receivers. It's not like they're old, if shady was 28-29 then yeah I'd consider that but he's 25 with many more yrs ahead of him. What would the point of moving them be? delay our retooling by even more years and Chip gets fed up and wants out bc by yr 3 we still haven't made the playoffs. Then we are back to square 1 with a new coach, new system and all the more worse for it.
Vick doesn't make great decisions in the red zone and chip is still learning clearly. We need the qb of the future, agreed, but surround him with as much talent as possible so he can at least have a shot at being successful. We need to give chip at least this coming offseason to get some more of his guys in here imo.