OFFICIAL NFL Discussion Thread: 2015-16 Season - Congrats to the Denver Broncos and their fans! SB 5

Status
Not open for further replies.
Mike can't hit or block like Hines :pimp:



Tim Brown or Irvin? That's a solid debate there
 
Last edited:
numbah1grimey said:
Jerry Rice is the Robert Parrish of NFL receivers. I would HOPE that after he retired, he would have all the receiving records.

Unfortunately, Michael Irvin and Sterling Sharpe retired prematurely. Both were in the broadcast booth while Jerry Rice was still playing. And he entered the league before them.
Click to expand...

Fun fact of the Day (again): if you only use the first 12 years of Jerry Rice's career, he'd still be the all-time leader in receiving yards (16377) and only two TD's shy of Randy Moss (154).

He doesn't just have "all the records" because of longevity. :D
 
Chester McFloppy said:
Fun fact of the Day (again): if you only use the first 12 years of Jerry Rice's career, he'd still be the all-time leader in receiving yards (16377) and only two TD's shy of Randy Moss (154).

He doesn't just have "all the records" because of longevity. :D
Click to expand...

So.... he'd be the leader in receiving yards, in a pass heavy offense? I woud say this though, Rice played outdoors, Moss and Irvin played on turf. But, Irvin was a beast at University of Miami on grass so, he would be good anywhere.
 
It's not like Rice was physically better then Mike. We aren't comparing Calvin to Welker where you can see the speed, size, jumping ability and undeniable differences. He just played longer and had more targets. If Randy had rings and played every down I'd say he was better then both of them.
 
Who gives a ****. They retired.

Stop with the hypothetical crap in here. It's tired.

Maybe they should have taken better care of their soft serve bodies. Worthless bums.
 
Last edited:
Since longevity is the defining factor, I guess Brett Favre is the greatest QB because he literally was first string for 21 years, as well :lol: :rofl:
 
If you only use the first 12 years of Jerry Rice's career, he'd still be the all-time leader in receiving yards (16377) and only two TD's shy of Randy Moss (154).
 
How is 88 ahead of Tim Brown? Tim was stuck with crappy QBs (no HOFer for him), an inferior RB compared to ES22, worse team overall so obviously no SB. But he still dominated and did on the college level as well. Irvin has the luxury of those incredible Cowboys teams, Timmy had nothing
 
Last edited:
Michael Irvin isn't even top 50 in touchdowns and barely top 25 in receiving yards. Dude is barely better than Santana Moss. Santana Moss won a title at the U, right?
 
Last edited:
dmxfury said:
How is 88 ahead of Tim Brown? Tim was stuck sigh crappy QBs (no HOFer for him), an inferior RB compared to ES22, worse team overall so obviously no SB. But he still dominated and did on the college level as well. Irvin has the luxury of those incredible Cowboys teams, Timmy had nothing
Click to expand...
the list of QBs Tim Brown had :x
 
numbah1grimey said:
Since longevity is the defining factor, I guess Brett Favre is the greatest QB because he literally was first string for 21 years, as well :lol: :rofl:
Click to expand...

I said this yesterday and got no response.

Everyone must have Farve and Emmit as the best All Time. If they don't the Rice argument wouldn't hold weight anymore.
 
If you only use the first 12 years of Jerry Rice's career, he'd still be the all-time leader in receiving yards (16377) and only two TD's shy of Randy Moss (154).
 
dmxfury said:
How is 88 ahead of Tim Brown? Tim was stuck with crappy QBs (no HOFer for him), an inferior RB compared to ES22, worse team overall so obviously no SB. But he still dominated and did on the college level as well. Irvin has the luxury of those incredible Cowboys teams, Timmy had nothing
Click to expand...

Blame Al for putting Marcus Allen on the backburner. Al was even going to bench Tim Brown at one point. Tim Brown was drafted ahead of both Irvin and sharpe in 1988. Blame the Davises
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

The ultimate sneaker enthusiast community.

NikeTalk was created as a way of giving back to both the sneaker enthusiast community and to the greater global community of which we are all a part.

NikeTalk is NOT affiliated with Nike Inc. in any way, shape, or form. All opinions expressed herein do not necessarily reflect those of Nike, Inc.

© 1999-2024 NikeTalk.com

Share this page

Back
Top Bottom