OFFICIAL 2015 FANTASY FOOTBALL THREAD

[Trey Bantz]

while were on it

Tyrod or Carr ?

Tyrod. Call it East Coast bias, but I'm not sold on Carr.

You clearly haven't watched him play

I haven't. Hence why I called myself out on the East Coast bias. I just think that the Bills are an extremely solid team all around.

 

[whoyouthink]

while were on it

Tyrod or Carr ?

Tyrod. Call it East Coast bias, but I'm not sold on Carr.

You clearly haven't watched him play

I haven't. Hence why I called myself out on the East Coast bias. I just think that the Bills are an extremely solid team all around.

Bills won't have Watkins and Carr is playing with Amari Cooper it shouldn't be a easy decision

 

[Trey Bantz]

while were on it

Tyrod or Carr ?

Tyrod. Call it East Coast bias, but I'm not sold on Carr.

You clearly haven't watched him play

I haven't. Hence why I called myself out on the East Coast bias. I just think that the Bills are an extremely solid team all around.

Bills won't have Watkins and Carr is playing with Amari Cooper it shouldn't be a easy decision

Don't mean to be a ****, but you have an emotional stake in this. Try not to give self-serving advice in this thread.

 

[johnnyredstorm]

I'd start the Carr. Has done solid, has weapons, playing a god awful defense.

 

[whoyouthink]

Then start Tyrod


Bears traded away Allen and their LB in same week but what do I know

 

[flightman]

Tyrod is a top 5 fantasy QB currently and is a dual threat (significantly raises his floor).

There should be no question about starting him over anyone not named Brady, Rodgers, and maybe Cam.

 

[nick.]

am i crazy for considering starting Carr over Carson & Tanny?

 

[Trey Bantz]

am i crazy for considering starting Carr over Carson & Tanny?

Over Carson, maybe. Over Tanny, not at all.

 

[childishlatino]

Is Harvin worth a add with Sammy hurt? 12 team L

 

[macbk]

I'm offering Jordan Cameron, Matt Jones and Cole Beasley for his Karlos Williams and Eifert.

Would you accept?

Trade denied .

 

[goledensilence]

Is Harvin worth a add with Sammy hurt? 12 team L

I'd say yeah since he's the teams #1 WR right now. I can see him getting a nice amount of points against the Giants.

 

[nick.]

am i crazy for considering starting Carr over Carson & Tanny?

Over Carson, maybe. Over Tanny, not at all.

those are the 2 QB's i have rostered, been starting Palmer the past 2 weeks. he has a tough matchup with St. Louis this week tho.

coming off 2 great games & playing a terrible Bears team i'm tempted to #StartTheCarr

Is Harvin worth a add with Sammy hurt? 12 team L

if you need a flex or just some depth, sure

 

[FreshLeeLA]

Then start Tyrod

Bears traded away Allen and their LB in same week but what do I know

You're acting like Tyrod is significantly lower play than Carr.

They're both decent plays this week but I would give the notch to Tyrod because he has been on fire.

I expect L. Murray to have a big game rather than Carr (I'm a Murray owner, haha) 

 

[whoyouthink]

I'm not acting like anything Tyrod has been playing great so far

 

[amarano]

i think Carr is more of a "legit" QB than Taylor.

albeit Taylor is playing VERY well.

i see Taylor crashing down before Carr is a mediocre QB

 

[bballkingsrule1]

Cardinals or Denver Defense??

 

[quise2024]

My David Johnson & Eifert for Steve Smith?

Fair?

I offered Bennett but he countered with Eifert

 

[Trey Bantz]

My David Johnson & Eifert for Steve Smith?

Fair?

I offered Bennett but he countered with Eifert

How badly do you need a WR? Do you have another formidable TE?

 

[Trey Bantz]

Cardinals or Denver Defense??

Cardinals. They've been on fire.

 

[goledensilence]

 
Cardinals or Denver Defense??

Cards

 

[proshares]

Cardinals or Denver Defense??

I think Denver this week at home. They're gonna force Teddy to beat em and I don't think that's gonna work out too well.

i think Carr is more of a "legit" QB than Taylor.

albeit Taylor is playing VERY well.

i see Taylor crashing down before Carr is a mediocre QB

The thing about Taylor is that they came in to the year wanting him to game manage as well as make a few things happen with his legs. But they're letting him throw now and he's been performing really well. The Giants have been very good against the run but very bad against the pass. This all depends on Watkins of course but I don't think it's some egregious statement to say he's a better play than Carr this week. Especially on the road. The Bears are gonna do their best to give Forte tons of touches to slow the game down and keep Carr off the field. All factors you definitely need to consider.

 

[Trey Bantz]

Cardinals or Denver Defense??

I think Denver this week at home. They're gonna force Teddy to beat em and I don't think that's gonna work out too well.

i think Carr is more of a "legit" QB than Taylor.

albeit Taylor is playing VERY well.

i see Taylor crashing down before Carr is a mediocre QB

The thing about Taylor is that they came in to the year wanting him to game manage as well as make a few things happen with his legs. But they're letting him throw now and he's been performing really well. The Giants have been very good against the run but very bad against the pass. This all depends on Watkins of course but I don't think it's some egregious statement to say he's a better play than Carr this week. Especially on the road. The Bears are gonna do their best to give Forte tons of touches to slow the game down and keep Carr off the field. All factors you definitely need to consider.

The only dude saying it's egregious is a Raiders stan.

 

[proshares]

am i crazy for considering starting Carr over Carson & Tanny?

I just wouldn't go in expecting Palmer to replicate what he's been doing. Strong pass rushers throw him off and STL has one of the best.

 

[proshares]

The only dude saying it's egregious is a Raiders stan.

I know, just adding another POV to the equation.

 

[zoomk083]

Is it consensus, that no way brown keeps up his production without big ben?

Maybe a week of practices will help Vick out?