- 11,153
- 17,222
Here we go Braves!
2024 MLB Thread; RIP Willie Mays & Pete Rose. Dodgers win #8!
- Thread in 'Sports & Training' Thread starter Started by CP1708,
- Start date
- 28,099
- 9,226
Hard disagree about Story. I get that there is a Coors factor but thats the reality. His offense has dwarfed Correa and quite frankly so has his defense.Nah, as I said, Lindor was great coming up, but I have regressed on him due to his last two seasons, which probably isn't fair, but he's been dreadful with RISP, and runners on the past 2 years and in this year's playoffs. I feel like that has to account for something, which is really my big knock on him. As a Tribe fan, have you not felt the same way?
I don't think it's farfetched to have him in the best SS convo, but I personally have him as 3 with Story/Torres/Xander just right behind. But still a tier below Tatis/Correa at this stage.
Yeah talent wise I do feel like having him #1 is kind of inarguable. I would have to disagree on Lindor and Story. Lindor is better defensively but him not coming through as an important bat the past two years has lowered him in my rankings. Story has the Coors factor going for him and he's still not as good offensively and slightly better defensively. FWIW, Carlos had a superb year defensively. I think he had the best dWAR for a SS IIRC. I agree on Tatis, but his sample size is limited, and Carlos has proven himself time and time again in the playoffs that it's hard to argue against. It may be unfair to hold others because they haven't had similar opportunities, but I still think he needs to get credit, and to me, that's what separates them.
Also, Playoff Peyton Kershaw
Also I forgot about Trea Turner. He has injury history too but he is absolutely in the mix. Its a very similar comp actually. I would actually lean Turner as of now but this is real close too.
I guess it just comes down to Tatis, Lindor and Story for me as definitively being better IMO.....and then a jumbled up mess of Baez, Turner, Correa, Xander, and Gleyber in that next tier.
- 47,251
- 96,796
As much as i csnt stand htown, lindor is not better than carlos korea
Had bi bim bap yesterday for lunchOrdering KBBQ tonight if Rays win
- 12,389
- 2,910
Let’s ******* goooooo!!!
- 11,529
- 7,439
Dodgers looking like they don’t want to play anymore?
What happened to all the California teams? They fizzled out in the post season
What happened to all the California teams? They fizzled out in the post season
- 1,232
- 315
Let’s Gooooooo! 
- 47,251
- 96,796
My dog Freddie gonna get him an NLCS MVP
- 3,699
- 25,084
What a difference a day makes!
- 11,930
- 15,885
I'll have to double check but I'm pretty sure after park factors, Correa is better offensively. I feel like judging by your rankings, you might be putting too much emphasis on raw stats and fantasy.
Hard disagree about Story. I get that there is a Coors factor but thats the reality. His offense has dwarfed Correa and quite frankly so has his defense.
Also I forgot about Trea Turner. He has injury history too but he is absolutely in the mix. Its a very similar comp actually. I would actually lean Turner as of now but this is real close too.
I guess it just comes down to Tatis, Lindor and Story for me as definitively being better IMO.....and then a jumbled up mess of Baez, Turner, Correa, Xander, and Gleyber in that next tier.
- 11,930
- 15,885
Peyton Kershaw getting outpitched by a rookie in a must-win game as a near 3:1 favorite
Somewhere, Manny is laughing at home at Graterol
Somewhere, Manny is laughing at home at Graterol
- 28,099
- 9,226
For the record, that rolling smiley was about Kershaw, not your post.
- 35,049
- 47,155
- 28,043
- 10,466
Braves were like +190 on ML. Hopefully someone in this thread ate.
- 47,251
- 96,796
He shouldve pitched last game, he couldve gave up 8 runs and still been blessss
- 11,930
- 15,885
- 17,194
- 24,001
Go Rays!
- 11,930
- 15,885
I'm getting some Texas BBQ instead of KBBQ for lunch, thanks for the suggestion earlierGo Rays!
. Too much pressure for Kershaw at home
- 11,153
- 17,222
- 23,371
- 26,393
You know it chief
Fade Kershaw day
This inning has been going on forever.
The Lakers chip is semi keeping me warm at night but this **** is embarrassing for LA every damn year
T0INE
formerly toine2983
- 67,159
- 73,569
Dodgers blew their load last night.
- 12,389
- 2,910
74 pitches and you take Wilson out?
- 47,251
- 96,796
Braves gonna slap whoever makes it out the AL
- 11,930
- 15,885
Damn we almost had Will Smith on Will Smith crime
TBF, that 6th inning was long as hell and he had to sit for a long time. Arm gets cold74 pitches and you take Wilson out?
Nah, hitting is better in the AL. That pitching definitely isn't surviving vs the Astros if we somehow came back and won. Maybe the Rays tho, but I'm pretty sure I would still favor them
- 54,228
- 31,746
- 47,251
- 96,796
Will smith 
