- Aug 27, 2013
- 5,919
- 6,874
Yea I heard that’s black owned too, it’s more expensive than ancestry but they also tell you what tribes you more closely match also.
Yea I heard that’s black owned too, it’s more expensive than ancestry but they also tell you what tribes you more closely match also.
tomdiginson
Supporter
- Nov 3, 2011
- 27,283
- 30,548
Not even what I'm referencing, but okay.
- Jan 19, 2017
- 5,516
- 7,971
Tbh, I don't think it's worth paying hundreds of dollars to find out specifics about places I or my immediate have family personally have never set foot in. That's what wikipedia and nat geo is for. I know I'm mainly of West African descent with a small amount of European in there. Paying for something that should be obvious is crazy to me.
- Aug 27, 2013
- 5,919
- 6,874
It’s $79 for ancestry son, it’s not that steep.
Do you know where in West Africa? Do you know how much African you are as opposed to European?
Wouldn’t it be cool to say “oh a majority of me is from Mali, I would like to visit there”
The amount of great things that can come from it is worth the $79
Do you know where in West Africa? Do you know how much African you are as opposed to European?
Wouldn’t it be cool to say “oh a majority of me is from Mali, I would like to visit there”
The amount of great things that can come from it is worth the $79
- Mar 4, 2011
- 10,459
- 8,940
I think these ancestry test are skewed. How many ppl in these rural hard to reach areas have access to these test?
I would think that largely ppl from developed nation's take the test(or remote places hat have come in contact with developed nation's via aid or releif etc.)
If 100mil European samples compare to 1million African samples, you have to question the accuracy of the whole thing.
If billions of ppl all over the world have submitted then the accuracy increases.
Plus it's only comparing to the samples of modern geographic boundaries and those people's location. That's not necessarily the same thing as where your DNA comes from.
It's an average of where your DNA is now. Nevermind war, genocide, displacement, migration.
I would think that largely ppl from developed nation's take the test(or remote places hat have come in contact with developed nation's via aid or releif etc.)
If 100mil European samples compare to 1million African samples, you have to question the accuracy of the whole thing.
If billions of ppl all over the world have submitted then the accuracy increases.
Plus it's only comparing to the samples of modern geographic boundaries and those people's location. That's not necessarily the same thing as where your DNA comes from.
It's an average of where your DNA is now. Nevermind war, genocide, displacement, migration.
Last edited:
- Jan 19, 2017
- 5,516
- 7,971
Maybe it's me but I find it hard to really identify with cultures that I've separated from for hundreds of years. It's like those white bread americans that become irish for one day out of the year for st. paddy's day or two if they're a ufc fan. The last bit of ethinic ties they have are now shallow cash grabs rather than anything authentic. I couldn't take myself seriously if I sent in some dna to one of these sites, found out I was 65% west african, 30% european and 5% random region, and put any more stock into it besides confirming what I already knew.
- Aug 27, 2013
- 5,919
- 6,874
youngogjosh
but it’s gonna tell you where imma europe and Africa? You know those are 2 big *** continents right?
- Aug 27, 2013
- 5,919
- 6,874
Dude my Nigerian (born in America) friend from college took one and it came out to be 97% Nigerian and 3% Ghana/Ivory Coast.
Trust me it’s accurate as hell.
- Mar 4, 2011
- 10,459
- 8,940
- Jan 19, 2017
- 5,516
- 7,971
I get that, I guess my point is, knowing history both inside of a classroom and through the internet. I know the euro genetics in me most likely won't be from say, Romania, they'll most likely be from the British Isles (either GB, Scottland, or Ireland going by my last name) and the African part of my dna will most likely be from West Africa and maybe some from Central Africa. I've been curious before and still am, so I've learned the histories of these places and I feel that that's enough to know how I and my family ended up here. It'd be cool to say my ancestors are specifically from such and such as you said, but I feel like it wouldn't enrich me beyond satisfying a curiosity.
You know those are 2 big *** continents right?
Though, for $79 (I thought it was more expensive) it can't be too bad, certainly, have spent my money on worse.
- Mar 4, 2011
- 10,459
- 8,940
I feel like African Americans are something new now since we were stripped of our past.
Even if your genetics come back and say you 90 percent Ghanaian, you can't go there as an American and try to be Ghanaian. They gone run you for everything. We need economic cultural exchange. I'm not finna go over there and hug and cry with someone cuz we got similar brown tones and nose. It's a nice and novel notion to connect with them like that but not grounded in reality.
Even if your genetics come back and say you 90 percent Ghanaian, you can't go there as an American and try to be Ghanaian. They gone run you for everything. We need economic cultural exchange. I'm not finna go over there and hug and cry with someone cuz we got similar brown tones and nose. It's a nice and novel notion to connect with them like that but not grounded in reality.
- Aug 27, 2013
- 5,919
- 6,874
Ain’t nobody saying you should go there and hug and cry with anyone.
It’s about have a clearer understanding of who you really are.
As you said we have been stripped of knowing who we are.
It’s just a starting point
It’s about have a clearer understanding of who you really are.
As you said we have been stripped of knowing who we are.
It’s just a starting point
- Mar 4, 2011
- 10,459
- 8,940
https://www.businessinsider.com/dna-testing-delete-your-data-23andme-ancestry-2018-7
SCIENCE
DNA-testing company 23andMe has signed a $300 million deal with a drug giant. Here's how to delete your data if that freaks you out.
- Erin Brodwin
- Jul 25, 2018, 5:27 PM ET
Hollis Johnson
- Popular DNA-testing companies like Ancestry and 23andMe can - and frequently do - sell your data to drugmakers.
- On Wednesday, the pharmaceutical giant GlaxoSmithKline announced it was acquiring a $300 million stake in 23andMe, making that connection much more explicit.
- If that new has you wondering about how your own genetic material is being used, here's a guide to deleting your DNA sample and data from 23andMe, Ancestry, and Helix.
atlsfinest
Supporter
- Feb 8, 2009
- 18,926
- 26,385
- Oct 2, 2011
- 27,294
- 15,002
Yeah, nah I’m good off that.
I’m African American. I’m good off that alone.
I don’t need to know where my great great great great ancestors came from bad enough to sell my dna. I don’t even know them people like that.
I know my family as far back as I can remember and I know further from what they’ve told me. I don’t need some website to tell me what country they came from, that still won’t create a bond between me and a stranger from 200+ years ago
- May 23, 2005
- 63,607
- 50,745
so u got ur friend cloned
type of friend are u
- Oct 13, 2001
- 176,377
- 164,856
I think the POINT is we are lost, in terms of knowing where we came from.
Maybe finding out your roots can put you closer to those "cultures that you been separated from for hundreds of years."
That is how I view it.
We are the only fools that don't have anywhere to call home
- May 23, 2005
- 63,607
- 50,745
why are we fools though????
- Oct 13, 2001
- 176,377
- 164,856
The word fool is just a placeholder. You are searching for something that isn't there.
- Oct 2, 2011
- 27,294
- 15,002
- Jan 19, 2017
- 5,516
- 7,971
I don't feel lost, my home is right where I was born. As for culture, AA's already have that, in fact, I feel ours is more widespread than our forebears.
- Oct 13, 2001
- 176,377
- 164,856
Hmm, ok.
- May 23, 2005
- 63,607
- 50,745
no i legit was asking
ur searching for something that isnt there
- Oct 13, 2001
- 176,377
- 164,856
Nah, they didn't fight to make this our home.
They fought to attempt to get equality in a place in which we aren't welcomed.
Neither of which has happened yet.
This is not our home. We are just here.
- Apr 27, 2002
- 5,506
- 5,800
i don't think people quite understand that nuance, these types tests have limited utility in telling people where they are ancestrally are actually from but where people that share some genetic similarity are currently, and only a somewhat of a utility in identifying groups of peoples/tribes due to the bias of the representative samples (i.e. these test could be missing large swathes of identifiers because they don't have large samples across many populations). in some ways, i think it is kinda arbitrary to even decide to in effect stop the clock at particular point of time and say a certain point of time is where it stops given that we are in most cases more genetically similar than different; it is culture that divides and/or brings folks together and the point that african americans are "something new," or their own entity is one that both sides of the equation (african americans & africans) understand implicitly because of the difference/similarities in culture...
we are still basically in the preliminary stages of this being consumer/widely available, part of the original aim(s) of this knowledge/tech was more toward disease awarness/prevention & healthcare (to which point, it makes the accuracy of these tests very important & is why many of these tests put caveats on, downplay or have gotten away from completely those aspects; because the fact is these test can be WILDLY inaccurate or at the very least incomplete) than ancestry, and in that respect it may one day prove very useful for healthcare (again ominous implications aside).
not saying this info can't or won't do these things but what clearer understanding did you gather from the results? how was it a starting point for you? there is no denying that black folk (specifically in americas/western hemisphere, but it definitely could/should be argued more broadly for the whole black diaspora) have had been stripped on their history (and arguably some of the present & future too) but i'm not sure, even if there was a such a test that could tell people with 100% certainty the tribe of peoples they are descended from, this type of knowledge could illuminate something (other than maybe some potential health concerns) or create a connection to a people/place
#homeiswhereyoumakeit? how do you define 'lost?' and why attribute that to a whole people??
