mr z
Supporter
- 3,062
- 5,336
- Joined
- Aug 10, 2013
Why do you think she technically didn’t meet the criteria for defamation?
Johnny Depp suing Amber Heard for 50 million? Amber Heard counter suing for “100 MILLION DOLLARS”
- 7,707
- 4,546
- Joined
- Jul 31, 2007
Is that Johnny Depp and Sammy Sosa?
calibeebee
Supporter
- 19,160
- 24,190
- Joined
- May 6, 2007
We typing PARAGRAPHS in here? Chill.
- 32,085
- 26,386
- Joined
- Aug 2, 2006
Im not a lawyer, so I really can't say.
I've read compelling arguments both ways.
Opinion | How the Johnny Depp-Amber Heard jury got it wrong — twice
No one should have won. Everyone should have lost.
www.nbcnews.com
the problem is the pro heard arguments i've heard rely on detailed parsing of her original statements.
which is fine in a court of law. but public opinion doesn't operate by those rules.
people think she's a liar, and deserves to be punished.
and you aren't going to changed their mind by saying, well if you look at the requirements needed to classify speech as defamation
and you analyze the original op-ed line by line
well it technically can't be defamation.
even if that's true nobody cares,
it's not going make people who think she's a liar, change their minds.
mr z
Supporter
- 3,062
- 5,336
- Joined
- Aug 10, 2013
Didn’t even finish the article. Clicked off when author tried to say Heard didn’t write the title. It was already established during trial that Heard republished the article and title on twitter. Then tried to say it only meant she “spoke up against sexual violence” and wasn’t accusing anyone of sexual violence. That claim doesn’t work either bc the only time she had ever come out about sexual violence was when she accused Depp of doing so. She also admitted under oath that the article was about Depp.Im not a lawyer, so I really can't say.
I've read compelling arguments both ways.
Opinion | How the Johnny Depp-Amber Heard jury got it wrong — twice
No one should have won. Everyone should have lost.
the problem is the pro heard arguments i've heard rely on detailed parsing of her original statements.
which is fine in a court of law. but public opinion doesn't operate by those rules.
people think she's a liar, and deserves to be punished.
and you aren't going to changed their mind by saying, well if you look at the requirements needed to classify speech as defamation
and you analyze the original op-ed line by line
well it technically can't be defamation.
even if that's true nobody cares,
it's not going make people who think she's a liar, change their minds.
The ONLY person that won on a technicality was Heard. Depp’s legal team couldn’t prove that he had nothing to do with his lawyer’s statements because of attorney/client privilege. They also couldn’t prove that Heard’s friends were in on the hoax. We all know damn well her and her friends tried to frame Depp but it couldn’t be proven so she got a small win on a technicality.
I tried to hear you out, but that article is opinionated and not based on the legal facts. Might as well watch TMZ.
- 32,085
- 26,386
- Joined
- Aug 2, 2006
your are very confident an article you didn't read offers zero reasonable arguments.
you're trying to argue with me about the law
my point is it doesn't matter.
we don't need to play sneaker forum law review.
mr z
Supporter
- 3,062
- 5,336
- Joined
- Aug 10, 2013
The article is trash. As I stated previously, once I saw the terrible arguments for the headline, there was nothing more that needed to be read.
You were the one that originally brought up the law. Stating that there was an argument that legally Her article was not defamation. I really wanted to know why you thought so and you post somebody’s opinion that had the wrong facts from the word go.
RustyShackleford
Supporter
- 63,252
- 189,776
- Joined
- Jul 20, 2009
- 12,929
- 22,632
- Joined
- Feb 23, 2013
- 12,091
- 11,533
- Joined
- Mar 5, 2008
Not gonna lie, her basic white girl look on that interview has me wanting to smash her hard while defecating on her pillow afterwards
The crazy is worth the risk here
The crazy is worth the risk here
- 5,823
- 6,770
- Joined
- Jul 3, 2015
- 53,173
- 20,724
- Joined
- Nov 24, 2009
That meme is actually good.
- 4,022
- 2,247
- Joined
- Jul 22, 2003
- 15,891
- 31,753
- Joined
- Mar 19, 2013
This only gets better! 
- 12,929
- 22,632
- Joined
- Feb 23, 2013
Last edited:
- 28,072
- 52,684
- Joined
- Apr 2, 2007
- 53,351
- 30,826
- Joined
- Jan 20, 2002
Read that the NBC interview did poorly in the ratings and lost out to shows that were on reruns.
Disney about to drop that bag to Johnny
Disney about to drop that bag to Johnny
- 9,134
- 1,012
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2007
Johnny Depp Verdict Thrown Into Chaos As Wrong Juror Seated In Virginia Trial, Amber Heard Says; Wants New Trial
EXCLUSIVE: If there wasn’t enough drama swirling around Johnny Depp’s win over Amber Heard in his multimillion-dollar defamation suit last month, things have turned judicially weird. “Ms. Heard had a right to rely on the basic protection, as prescribed by the Virginia Code, that the jurors in...
It's wild that this could even happen
Her lawyer earning that check
mr z
Supporter
- 3,062
- 5,336
- Joined
- Aug 10, 2013
It can’t.
Johnny Depp Verdict Thrown Into Chaos As Wrong Juror Seated In Virginia Trial, Amber Heard Says; Wants New Trial
EXCLUSIVE: If there wasn’t enough drama swirling around Johnny Depp’s win over Amber Heard in his multimillion-dollar defamation suit last month, things have turned judicially weird. “Ms. Heard had a right to rely on the basic protection, as prescribed by the Virginia Code, that the jurors in...www.yahoo.com
It's wild that this could even happen
Her lawyer earning that check
at Yahoo running this trash article
- 9,654
- 31,021
- Joined
- Mar 24, 2018
All this means is we get to see more CamilleJohnny Depp Verdict Thrown Into Chaos As Wrong Juror Seated In Virginia Trial, Amber Heard Says; Wants New Trial
EXCLUSIVE: If there wasn’t enough drama swirling around Johnny Depp’s win over Amber Heard in his multimillion-dollar defamation suit last month, things have turned judicially weird. “Ms. Heard had a right to rely on the basic protection, as prescribed by the Virginia Code, that the jurors in...
It's wild that this could even happen
Her lawyer earning that check
with her thick sturdy chin lookin ***.
- 87,735
- 50,128
- Joined
- Nov 20, 2007
The Depp impersonator
- 6,127
- 7,086
- Joined
- Sep 3, 2014
They must have been writing the script for this during the trial.
- 8,538
- 17,885
- Joined
- Mar 25, 2021
- 37,945
- 38,057
- Joined
- Feb 5, 2013
a script was def not needed
- 19,637
- 12,643
- Joined
- Feb 11, 2008
