New Orleans Begins Controversial Removal of Confederate Monuments

Discussion in 'General' started by hand2handking, Apr 24, 2017.

  1. hand2handking

    hand2handking

    18,213
    11,816
    Joined
    Jan 11, 2013
    Thoughts? [​IMG]  
     
    Last edited: Apr 24, 2017
  2. jjs07

    jjs07

    20,332
    13,981
    Joined
    Jul 18, 2012
    We'll be seeing more of this...I know in the DC area, there is chatter about possibly re-naming some of the High Schools (JEB Stuart, Washington-Lee, etc.) and some of the roads/highways named after folks in the confederacy. Going to be interesting to see where this goes.
     
  3. langfor5

    langfor5

    4,307
    1,565
    Joined
    Nov 25, 2006
    As a former history major this does bother me a bit. America's history is flawed; just like its leaders. More and more I see society trying to become as 'PC' as possible. We can't change or undo our history, both good and bad. The best thing we can do is to learn and educate and not repeat the mistakes that we made. If we are going to remove all Confederate monuments are we going to remove Jefferson and Washington monuments? Are we going to remove any mentions of Andrew Jackson? What about statues for Sherman and Sheridan and the role they played in nearly exterminating Native Americans? My overall point is - if we start removing Confederacy monuments because they are offensive then we might as well not talk about our history overall because many of our so called 'founding fathers' had flaws 10x worse than any Confederate farmers.
     
  4. wavycrocket

    wavycrocket

    31,050
    55,442
    Joined
    Aug 11, 2012
    They are part of our history and should be remembered.

    That doesn't mean they should be "honored" though.
     
  5. John Wick

    John Wick formerly jayzonmytoes

    5,956
    1,710
    Joined
    Oct 6, 2006
    But does this also mean we will be renaming buildings as well? For example the J Edgar Hoover building.
     
    Last edited: Apr 24, 2017
  6. jthagreat

    jthagreat

    18,918
    1,167
    Joined
    Dec 29, 2004
    Good, racist traitors should not be honored.
     
    moe fab likes this.
  7. langfor5

    langfor5

    4,307
    1,565
    Joined
    Nov 25, 2006
    So do we take down the Jefferson Memorial? What about the Andrew Jackson memorial? George Washington? The list goes on and on...
     
    Last edited: Apr 24, 2017
  8. superblytrife

    superblytrife

    16,064
    9,388
    Joined
    Mar 21, 2002
    @langfor5 I don't think it's about the flaws of the confederate farmers.

    It's about the fact they were fighting to uphold the institution of slavery. Nobody fighting to uphold that should be honored with a monument. Period. Same goes for anyone else tied to any atrocity.

    We can talk about history all day--doesn't bother me one bit. In fact, I think we need to discuss it more and confront it head on. Hell, we've got certain states trying to take slavery out of the history books in school because it makes white people look bad. But being honored for being an ******* for all the world to see? Why do we need that? We don't.
     
  9. xcellz

    xcellz

    1,354
    727
    Joined
    Apr 26, 2013
    my exact thoughts..... history is very flawed we are honoring folks who did great things but also were slave owners.

    cant believe i was force fed all that crap in school
     
  10. deuce king

    deuce king

    15,490
    4,264
    Joined
    Jul 8, 2005
    Sounds like a plan to me. We gotta start somewhere.
     
  11. NotoriousLEEdope

    NotoriousLEEdope formerly dapimpjuice4ya

    700
    91
    Joined
    Oct 17, 2002
    I see where you're coming from but these aren't people who should be honored. I don't care how much history their despicable acts represent. Are there monuments honoring anyone who supported or represented any of the disgusting sentiments that led to the Holocaust?
     
    xcellz likes this.
  12. langfor5

    langfor5

    4,307
    1,565
    Joined
    Nov 25, 2006
    America has to be real careful how they pick and choose what leaders we want to 'honor.' A good portion of our so called founding fathers owned slaves, thought of blacks as 'inferior, less educated and overall second class citizens' and then later helped to nearly exterminate all Native Americans.

    Not all Confederates believed in slavery just like all Northerners weren't fighting because they believed that all blacks should be free and that it was there moral duty to protect that.

    I am all for NOT honoring individuals who supported slavery but this is a topic that needs to addressed and discussed - not swept under a rug. This was a disgusting time period. But you ask Native Americans how they feel about Columbus, Andrew Jackson and any of the other generals and policy leaders who helped exterminate and remove Native peoples from their homelands you will get the same response with less action. Nobody is clamoring to remove Andrew Jackson statues who was a slave OWNER and chased fugitive slaves in SE Florida....he personally removed 46k Indigenous peoples to open up lands for white settlement and slavery...

    My point is...if we are going to be removing monuments that honor those that believed in uncomfortable or racist ideals we better be CONSISTENT.
     
    Last edited: Apr 24, 2017
  13. kingkoopa

    kingkoopa

    16,552
    12,206
    Joined
    Aug 14, 2012
    History is wrote by the winners.
     
  14. NotoriousLEEdope

    NotoriousLEEdope formerly dapimpjuice4ya

    700
    91
    Joined
    Oct 17, 2002
    Maybe they should because I would definitely support that as well. I'm from New Orleans so I've followed the fight to remove these monuments since it began. The company who was originally contracted to do the removal had to back out because those in opposition of removal torched the owner's Lamborghini. There's a reason this removal was done under the cover of darkness. Workers had to work in all black with their faces for their protection. It's sad that that kind of evil still exists in this country. That's the kind of ignorance this movement is fighting. Im well aware of why the civil war was fought and also well aware that not all parties who fought that war did so as some crusade against or for slavery. I'm for removing all monuments honoring people who fought and stood for the oppression of any group of people, not just mine.
     
  15. wavycrocket

    wavycrocket

    31,050
    55,442
    Joined
    Aug 11, 2012
    @langfor5 Native Americans are fighting to remove the honoring of Jackson and Columbus though....
     
  16. langfor5

    langfor5

    4,307
    1,565
    Joined
    Nov 25, 2006
    Great post. You are certainly more informed about the ongoing events in regards to this matter. This was the first time I had heard about this happening in New Orleans and I support it. No one needs to glorify or honor slavery and I hope that by removing these monuments it helps to encourage and spark discussions about this particular time period and how it can NEVER be repeated.

    @WavyCrockett Native peoples have been fighting for years to abolish Columbus Day but yet it is still being recognized as a Federal Holiday. I hope they do remove Jackson memorials every where. That man was a racist bigot but you and I both know that they will never remove Jackson's statue in DC. His actions at the Battle of New Orleans and defeat of the British will super secede any of the slaves that he owned or his involvement in the killing and removal of the Cherokee people.
     
  17. flyeed

    flyeed

    9,185
    6,320
    Joined
    Sep 11, 2013
    It's clear that those who are fighting for the preservation of the monuments are doing so in the name of upholding our history, good and bad. These folks are certainly not losing their **** sending death threats because they're rustled about racist monuments being taken down that celebrate a government which fought a war to overthrow the United States.

    On the real though, the whole where do you stop argument is non-sense. Progress can start at any point when society is ready for it. The celebration of these people is highly offensive to blacks, any minorities, and any true patriot of the United States.

    Instead of asking where does it stop how about asking where do we start?
     
    tay1 likes this.
  18. handullz

    handullz

    4,069
    2,156
    Joined
    Oct 31, 2009
    The Confederacy was a bunch of treasonous morons.

    You can't claim Murica on one side and then claim Confederacy on the other.

    Dudes just trying to hold on to the good ol' days when you had a perpetual underclass of slaves and could literally rule over people.

    Good riddance, yo.
     
  19. ninjahood

    ninjahood

    65,795
    20,250
    Joined
    Aug 2, 2004
    scrubbing history is dumb, and what you're doing is giving supporters of da rebel flag for innocuous reasons (yes they do exist) martyrdom​ status.

    besides, seen da State flag of their next door neighbors? heh.
     
  20. RustyShackleford

    RustyShackleford

    38,032
    67,108
    Joined
    Jul 21, 2009
    And lets be honest here regarding the Civil War, keeping statues up is what whitewashes it.

    Saying it was just about states rights, ignoring it was the states' right to enslave black people, whitewashes it.

    Claiming Lincoln was some benevolent savior of black people whitewashes it.

    Not calling out seceding like the South did the biggest act of treason ever committed against America whitewashes it.

    Ignoring how Reconstruction was botched (especially after Lincoln's death, great way to honor the man :rolleyes) and how much that ****** up black people to this day, and America as a whole, whitewashes it

    To this day there are a large number of people in the white community, the South, and political right that have been on some strong "PC" steez regarding the Civil War. So please spare me the "PC" talk when the monuments to these traitors and racist get taken down.
     
    Last edited: Apr 25, 2017
    AZwildcats, SuperQ, red mpls and 3 others like this.
  21. tay1

    tay1

    34,433
    21,918
    Joined
    Aug 6, 2012
    Good. Take the racists off the money too. I wanna see ODB on currency.
     
    Last edited: Apr 24, 2017
  22. tay1

    tay1

    34,433
    21,918
    Joined
    Aug 6, 2012
    [​IMG]  how are you a former history major?

    They're still in history books. They're not being erased from history. Why would you want to honor a man on the side of slavery? That's baffling to me and it speaks volumes on people who'd want to be against this.
     
    Last edited: Apr 24, 2017
  23. RustyShackleford

    RustyShackleford

    38,032
    67,108
    Joined
    Jul 21, 2009
    Playing devil's advocate for people that support the confederacy.

    I would say I'm shocked, then I realize who is posting this. :rolleyes
     
  24. ninjahood

    ninjahood

    65,795
    20,250
    Joined
    Aug 2, 2004
    imagine if da current Egyptian government felt compelled to destroy da Pyramids over da transgressions of black jews during passover during da current climate...where do you draw da line? you don't open that Pandora's box.

    judging historical monuments on da current whims of political/moral winds is dumb.

    btw, get disrespectful in here at your peril.
     
  25. RustyShackleford

    RustyShackleford

    38,032
    67,108
    Joined
    Jul 21, 2009
    What an asinine example