I will say this, I have played casually in AM90's and have tripped/fell numerous times, have played in Kobes with no issues except maybe support, I've played in Retro 8's and have had the best games, the straps give that lockdown feel.
These shoes arent enhancing your skills, they just give you a little more confidence as to what you can do on the court...cuts, jumps, running etc.
There are kicks that are holy for small players, and kicks that are holy for big players...different shoes = different results
It wont be that ONE specific shoe works for everyone, which is why the market is so huge