- 64,964
- 196,091
- Joined
- Jul 20, 2009
I want know how the judge that have it 48-46 to Edgar scored the rounds.
Official MMA Thread-UFC on FOX 3, 5/5/12 - Anyone asking for stream links = banned.
- Thread in 'Sports & Training' Thread starter Started by monopolyman630,
- Start date
- 1,533
- 10
- Joined
- Aug 13, 2008
Gave the last 4 rounds to Frankie.
- 30,184
- 1,991
- Joined
- Oct 15, 2000
I'm really interested to see the judges scorecards on this one.
I guess you could have given Edgar rounds 2-5, but I wouldn't have.
I guess you could have given Edgar rounds 2-5, but I wouldn't have.
- 9,928
- 572
- Joined
- Jan 30, 2006
Baroni is still the best EVA. Nice ko
- 9,134
- 1,012
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2007
the best eva grabbing the ref's leg
- 1,103
- 12
- Joined
- Nov 13, 2007
Originally Posted by quiickz
Originally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
...a draw...the ufc judges gonna get heat for that decision...thought maynard had it......
No they won't. IMO no one should really be surprised.
...well since edgar showed heart and came back...then that's what the judges saw to make that decision...I think maynard scored more points with the knockdowns...edgar only had take downs n sub att.
- 1,282
- 10
- Joined
- Mar 23, 2010
IMO
Round 1: 10-8 Maynard
Round 2: 10-9 Edgar
Round 3: 10-9 Maynard
Round 4: 10-9 Edgar
Round 5: 10-9 Maynard
48-46 Maynard
Round 1: 10-8 Maynard
Round 2: 10-9 Edgar
Round 3: 10-9 Maynard
Round 4: 10-9 Edgar
Round 5: 10-9 Maynard
48-46 Maynard
- 20,619
- 1,615
- Joined
- Sep 27, 2007
I wasn't that surprised that it was a draw, more disappointed. Maynard def got the 10-8 1st, won the 3rd and the 5th was up in the air, I'd prob give it to Frankie, gun to my head.
I don't know if we see a rematch right away...maybe later in the year
I don't know if we see a rematch right away...maybe later in the year
- 7,925
- 914
- Joined
- Jul 16, 2002
So I guess Edgar vs. Pettis to unify the WEC and UFC LW Belts and then Maynard gets the winner of that.
- 64,964
- 196,091
- Joined
- Jul 20, 2009
That is not how the fights are scored. Round are scored individually, overall performance in the fight is not consideredOriginally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
Originally Posted by quiickz
Originally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
...a draw...the ufc judges gonna get heat for that decision...thought maynard had it......
No they won't. IMO no one should really be surprised.
...well since edgar showed heart and came back...then that's what the judges saw to make that decision...I think maynard scored more points with the knockdowns...edgar only had take downs n sub att.
- 7,925
- 914
- Joined
- Jul 16, 2002
Why did some of you guys give round 5 to Gray? Edgar stuffed all his take downs and I felt Edgar was more aggressive in the stand up for that round.
- 30,184
- 1,991
- Joined
- Oct 15, 2000
Thinking about it, I think 47-47 was the right score.
10-8 Maynard
10-9 Edgar
10-9 Edgar
10-9 Edgar
10-9 Maynard
47-47
But I think both rounds 3 and 5 could have gone either way, so any score ranging from 48-46 either way was a legitimate score imo.
10-8 Maynard
10-9 Edgar
10-9 Edgar
10-9 Edgar
10-9 Maynard
47-47
But I think both rounds 3 and 5 could have gone either way, so any score ranging from 48-46 either way was a legitimate score imo.
- 3,005
- 11
- Joined
- Nov 28, 2008
I had itOriginally Posted by RustyShackleford
That is not how the fights are scored. Round are scored individually, overall performance in the fight is not consideredOriginally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
Originally Posted by quiickz
Originally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
...a draw...the ufc judges gonna get heat for that decision...thought maynard had it......
No they won't. IMO no one should really be surprised.
...well since edgar showed heart and came back...then that's what the judges saw to make that decision...I think maynard scored more points with the knockdowns...edgar only had take downs n sub att.
RD1 Gray 10-8
RD2 Edgar 10-9
RD3 Gray 10-9
RD4 Edgar 10-9
RD5 Edgar 10-9 which is a draw
- 1,103
- 12
- Joined
- Nov 13, 2007
Originally Posted by RustyShackleford
That is not how the fights are scored. Round are scored individually, overall performance in the fight is not consideredOriginally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
Originally Posted by quiickz
Originally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
...a draw...the ufc judges gonna get heat for that decision...thought maynard had it......
No they won't. IMO no one should really be surprised.
...well since edgar showed heart and came back...then that's what the judges saw to make that decision...I think maynard scored more points with the knockdowns...edgar only had take downs n sub att.
...I know how rounds r scored...and fight performance is a factor...especially since the champ came back from a knockdown almost KO...and won some rounds to make it a draw...
- 30,184
- 1,991
- Joined
- Oct 15, 2000
I like this scenario.
- 30,184
- 1,991
- Joined
- Oct 15, 2000
I don't know what you mean by fight performance, but coming back from a KO has nothing to do with it. Everyone round is scored individually. The fact that Edgar survived round one had nothing to do with how the judges scored rounds 2-5.Originally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
Originally Posted by RustyShackleford
That is not how the fights are scored. Round are scored individually, overall performance in the fight is not consideredOriginally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
Originally Posted by quiickz
Originally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
...a draw...the ufc judges gonna get heat for that decision...thought maynard had it......
No they won't. IMO no one should really be surprised.
...well since edgar showed heart and came back...then that's what the judges saw to make that decision...I think maynard scored more points with the knockdowns...edgar only had take downs n sub att.
...I know how rounds r scored...and fight performance is a factor...especially since the champ came back from a knockdown almost KO...and won some rounds to make it a draw...
- 64,964
- 196,091
- Joined
- Jul 20, 2009
No it is not, not with the current system. Some judges may do it, but they shouldn't.Originally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
Originally Posted by RustyShackleford
That is not how the fights are scored. Round are scored individually, overall performance in the fight is not consideredOriginally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
Originally Posted by quiickz
Originally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
...a draw...the ufc judges gonna get heat for that decision...thought maynard had it......
No they won't. IMO no one should really be surprised.
...well since edgar showed heart and came back...then that's what the judges saw to make that decision...I think maynard scored more points with the knockdowns...edgar only had take downs n sub att.
...I know how rounds r scored...and fight performance is a factor...especially since the champ came back from a knockdown almost KO...and won some rounds to make it a draw...
And Frankie already got a gift against BJ, judges didn't give BJ the "champion's edge" in that fight. So I don't think anyone should bring up Edgar being the champ, or that making any sort deference, to defend this decision.
A judge thought Frankie won that last 4 rounds, I disagree but I can see someone else seeing it that way, but don't tell me that the gave Frankie the fight because he is the champ, and made a comeback from a bad first round. That wound be BS and I would hope that judge never judges another UFC fight ever.
- 53,457
- 21,038
- Joined
- Nov 24, 2009
Originally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
...a draw...the ufc judges gonna get heat for that decision...thought maynard had it......
they won't get heat for the draw, they got that correct. i figure most scored the fight 47-47. i think people were surprised all 3 scoring cards were different so it means none of the judges agreed. some of the rounds were really close so the result won't be as controversial as really bad decisions like the phan garcia fight or any fight with garcia in it.
- 1,103
- 12
- Joined
- Nov 13, 2007
Originally Posted by 4wrestling
I don't know what you mean by fight performance, but coming back from a KO has nothing to do with it. Everyone round is scored individually. The fact that Edgar survived round one had nothing to do with how the judges scored rounds 2-5.Originally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
Originally Posted by RustyShackleford
That is not how the fights are scored. Round are scored individually, overall performance in the fight is not consideredOriginally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
Originally Posted by quiickz
Originally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
...a draw...the ufc judges gonna get heat for that decision...thought maynard had it......
No they won't. IMO no one should really be surprised.
...well since edgar showed heart and came back...then that's what the judges saw to make that decision...I think maynard scored more points with the knockdowns...edgar only had take downs n sub att.
...I know how rounds r scored...and fight performance is a factor...especially since the champ came back from a knockdown almost KO...and won some rounds to make it a draw...
...we ALL know each round is scored individually...the fact that Edgar (champ) came back(performed>maynard) and won the next few rounds(after being knocked down) to change that win for maynard to a draw=fight performance...
- 53,457
- 21,038
- Joined
- Nov 24, 2009
enough arguing. the best part of tonight was brittney palmer made her debut as a ufc ring girl.
playboy should pay up and have her and arianny fight nude in the octagon covered with oil.
- 1,103
- 12
- Joined
- Nov 13, 2007
^this...IMO...if you score the rounds however u want to...47-47 is the total...yeah I saw that fight and that was terrible...Originally Posted by shogun
Originally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
...a draw...the ufc judges gonna get heat for that decision...thought maynard had it......
they won't get heat for the draw, they got that correct. i figure most scored the fight 47-47. i think people were surprised all 3 scoring cards were different so it means none of the judges agreed. some of the rounds were really close so the result won't be as controversial as really bad decisions like the phan garcia fight or any fight with garcia in it.
- 1,103
- 12
- Joined
- Nov 13, 2007
^this...anyway good fights for being free...Originally Posted by shogun
enough arguing. the best part of tonight was brittney palmer made her debut as a ufc ring girl.playboy should pay up and have her and arianny fight nude in the octagon covered with oil.
- 30,184
- 1,991
- Joined
- Oct 15, 2000
Frankie Edgar will defend against Anthony Pettis next, with Gray Maynard fighting the winner.
Edit:
UPDATE - Frankie Edgar will defend against Gray Maynard next, not Anthony Pettis as announced earlier tonight at the press conference. Dana White just made the call.
Edit:
UPDATE - Frankie Edgar will defend against Gray Maynard next, not Anthony Pettis as announced earlier tonight at the press conference. Dana White just made the call.
- 30,184
- 1,991
- Joined
- Oct 15, 2000
- 64,964
- 196,091
- Joined
- Jul 20, 2009
SMH, all of a sudden you changing your storyOriginally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
Originally Posted by 4wrestling
I don't know what you mean by fight performance, but coming back from a KO has nothing to do with it. Everyone round is scored individually. The fact that Edgar survived round one had nothing to do with how the judges scored rounds 2-5.Originally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
Originally Posted by RustyShackleford
That is not how the fights are scored. Round are scored individually, overall performance in the fight is not consideredOriginally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
Originally Posted by quiickz
Originally Posted by KaDUKUkicks
...a draw...the ufc judges gonna get heat for that decision...thought maynard had it......
No they won't. IMO no one should really be surprised.
...well since edgar showed heart and came back...then that's what the judges saw to make that decision...I think maynard scored more points with the knockdowns...edgar only had take downs n sub att.
...I know how rounds r scored...and fight performance is a factor...especially since the champ came back from a knockdown almost KO...and won some rounds to make it a draw...
...we ALL know each round is scored individually...the fact that Edgar (champ) came back(performed>maynard) and won the next few rounds(after being knocked down) to change that win for maynard to a draw=fight performance...
