Tactics to scare Landlord?

766
687
Joined
Mar 26, 2009
During COVID, I bought a house in a rural area. Fast forward to 2023, I meet a chick who lives in an apartment Downtown 2 miles away from where I work. At first I'm staying over every other night, but as the relationship progresses I start staying weekends too.

Now coinciding with this, a businessman buys the building from the elderly lady who had it for 25 years. During COVID two tenants stopped paying rent so after they were finally evicted she left them vacant. So after businessman takes over, he starts bringing in crews to remodel those apartments up to modern standards. After putting up with non-stop noise, roll-off dumpsters crowding the parking lot, rusty nails in my tires (twice), they finish after 10 months and businessman moves his 20 year old daughter who is attending college nearby.

Both his family and my gfs fam grew up with mutual friends running in the same circles, so at first their landlord-tenant relationship was cordial, but as he started seeing more and more of me I could see him getting suspicious.

So this Sunday we're eating lunch and she gets a text, saying that This Year my costs have been driven up due to inflation, but also utilities with a second person in the apartment. Effective Sept 1st, your new rent will be 1100 per month

Now keep in mind, she has lived there since 2015, rent was originally 650, then in 2019 it was increased to 700 which it has been for the past 5 years. Utilities are inclusive as well.

Adding more complexity to this, the original landlord did verbal leases, so there's no paperwork, when businessman took over he didn't have her sign a lease either. I've always thought that means we have the upper hand and if worst comes to worst a lengthy court battle was a possibility which he would naturally want to avoid, especially since she always pays her rent on time and is an ideal tenant.

But other people are saying causes there's no lease that means she is month to month and he can serve up an eviction notice at any time.

I've been brainstorming strategies to get ahead of this...the utilities thing really bothered me cause being a homeowner I am very conscientous about not wasting anything and have dozens of different things I do to keep them low. Not only that, I work 50-60 hours a week so it's not like I'm lounging around all day in the apartment.

I called up the City to get an estimate of the utilities, and our electric is costing $135 while the daughter is somehow using up $180 despite living alone. But the kicker is, to squash any doubt I wanted to get previous years records to use as a frame of reference but due to privacy they can only supply current charges. So that's back to square one.

Besides that all I got is little stuff, like there not being a fire alarm installed, and with the building being pre-1978 there should've been disclosure forms about the possibility of lead paint.

Have any of y'all been in this situation? My gf is ready to take the L and just pay the 1100, but that's kind of ridiculous for a 1br unit that hasn't been renovated since the 90s...
 
Yea pay or leave. I'd at least see if they could go ahead and renovate your place for that 1100 a month because thats what they're going to charge the new tenant.
 
You're now living there and you're mad they're adjusting the rent accordingly? You weren't part of the original agreement.
 
You're now living there and you're mad they're adjusting the rent accordingly? You weren't part of the original agreement.
Define "living". My belongings only occupy a closet, small shelf and small cabinet. Never had any mail addressed to her spot, I'm still paying my Mortgage/Utilities on my crib in the countryside, I stop by every week to do laundry and sleep there once a month . And Now that my seasonal work is picking up that will likely increase to weekly.

Like I mentioned, working overtime it's impossible for me to drain resources or contribute to wear and tear since a disproportionate aspect of my occupancy is sleeping. And like I said, I'm a wizard at decreasing bills...for example, whenever her light bulbs burn out, I swap them for LEDs, colored bulbs at that. 55w goes down to 5w easy. Swapped out her Giant Fridge (suitable for a Family) with a more modest one that accommodates what little groceries we buy.

She was doing dumb stuff like having both AC units running simultaneously, 24/7 with the excuse that her cats will overheat. I set them up on a timer so they only kick on during the peak hours of the heat.

Plus I got her on my guest pass at the gym, (more time away from the apartment)
is it in rent control?
I'm in Ohio so I don't think that is a thing here.
Reach out to your local tenant resources. It’s usually lawyers and paralegals working for free to get their reps in
Good idea.
 
Back
Top Bottom