The Invincible Thread

[stillin729]

I'm just trying to figure out why certain people are hellbent on nitpicking this guy's rookie season so much.  Especially considering the trash he's working with, and the fact that he's also working with a rookie head coach.  Every rookie QB isn't going to be Cam Newton out the gate (Hell, most won't, for that matter).  Derek Carr's average pass was 5.46 yards his rookie year.  Now he's a legitimate MVP candidate.

I mean, I get it.  ESPN went crazy with the comparisons three weeks in, and some Eagle fans (none on this board, as far as I know) may have gotten a little extra happy getting T-shirts made and the whole Wentzmania crap, but y'all have been watching football long enough to know how this goes.

An intelligent take

 

[Trey Bantz]

I mean, I get it.  ESPN went crazy with the comparisons three weeks in, and some Eagle fans (none on this board, as far as I know) may have gotten a little extra happy getting T-shirts made and the whole Wentzmania crap, but y'all have been watching football long enough to know how this goes.

Oh no, there were definitely dudes on this board peacocking around and @'ing folks left and right.

Absolutely. I specifically remember the WIR after the Eagles were on BYE. Philly fans invaded the thread just to talk about how good Wentz was, after a goddamn BYE week

 

[HNL HI]

Khaleesi was at her best in season 1 and 2. Missandei stole all her shine

Missanbae 

 

[shatterkneesinc]

Leave the eagles fan alone

They are good people

 

[spacedoodoo]

 

[stillin729]

Wentz is good but y'all made your mind up on him last March so it doesn't matter

 

[Chester McFloppy]

I mean, I get it.  ESPN went crazy with the comparisons three weeks in, and some Eagle fans (none on this board, as far as I know) may have gotten a little extra happy getting T-shirts made and the whole Wentzmania crap, but y'all have been watching football long enough to know how this goes.

Oh no, there were definitely dudes on this board peacocking around and @'ing folks left and right.

Absolutely. I specifically remember the WIR after the Eagles were on BYE. Philly fans invaded the thread just to talk about how good Wentz was, after a goddamn BYE week

http://niketalk.com/t/654090/nfl-week-in-review-week-3-aka-the-carson-wentz-thread

Plus the thread I actually changed the title of because of all the Wentz talk.

But yeah.

 

[EddieDoyers]

[thread="651382"]Dak could be a QB who peaks as a rookie, like RG3 and Vince young.[/thread]
[thread="651382"] [/thread]
[thread="651382"]Wentz could become one of the better QB's in the league further into his career.[/thread]
[thread="651382"] [/thread]
[thread="651382"]y'all are over analyzing both of these QB's too much. [/thread]
[thread="651382"] [/thread]
[thread="651382"] [/thread]
[thread="651382"] [/thread]
[thread="651382"]it's also crazy to compare wentz to alex smith  [/thread]

Vince Young was never good to begin with in his NFL career
But I get what you mean

 

[k3stacks]

Yall stay grouping IATT and stillin with every eagle fan on this board. (No shots at either btw)

 

[shatterkneesinc]

Everyone hopping on the Cowboys hype train this year

its sickening

 

[rook]

Got em'

dudes gotta let my g Dak flourish man.

Got what? Dak is playing with a loaded offense

bruh, hes 9-1. idc

 

[IATT]

You got it. You guys were so annoying about how good he was the first couple weeks that this slander should be expected.

ummm.. actually the points being made earlier in the season still stand..

you had people saying he should be a late round draft pick to UDFA.. it was more making fun of the hot takes before he even took a snap in the league

I know I always qualified my hopes and expectations for him to simply be for him to show the talent and demonstrate that  he belongs and can play on the NFL level

which he is still doing

 

[sb]

View media item 2237287

[QUOTE url="[URL]http://sports.mynorthwest.com/category/podcast_player/?a=10012884&sid=1027&n=The%20Pete%20Carroll%20Show[/URL]"]
 
He’s going to be really good,” Carroll http://sports.mynorthwest.com/categ... … He did a great job. He really did.”[/COLOR

Super Bowl winning coach Pete Carroll seemed to like what he saw, Sunday.  I'll take his word for it.
[/quote]

same coach that didnt give marshawn the ball on the 1 with the superbowl on the line

 

[stillin729]

http://niketalk.com/t/654090/nfl-week-in-review-week-3-aka-the-carson-wentz-thread

Plus the thread I actually changed the title of because of all the Wentz talk.

But yeah.

and that's what fans do

remember when 49ers fans invaded NT a few years ago? I do

 

[shatterkneesinc]

sb

Sorry I stole your favorite emoji

I promise I wont use it anymore

 

[Chester McFloppy]

http://niketalk.com/t/654090/nfl-week-in-review-week-3-aka-the-carson-wentz-thread

Plus the thread I actually changed the title of because of all the Wentz talk.

But yeah.

and that's what fans do

remember when 49ers fans invaded NT a few years ago? I do

Remember when you got caught with your hand in the cookie jar and immediately deflected to another fan base to try and take away from it?

I do. It's OK, it's just a message board. We all make mistakes and say crazy things.

 

[shatterkneesinc]

and that's what fans do

remember when 49ers fans invaded NT a few years ago? I do

 

[stillin729]

Remember when you got caught with your hand in the cookie jar and immediately deflected to another fan base to try and take away from it?

I do. It's OK, it's just a message board. We all make mistakes and say crazy things.

I am not deflecting from anything my stance hasn't changed, you took a subtle shot and I replied to it because you were referring to me indirectly

I am a diehard Philly fan, product of growing up in the city, it is what it is

 

[kdslittlebro]

2016-17 Alex Smith is a bad qb until proven otherwise....

which he's doing on Sunday

 

[CJ616]

Man, do we really have to have this whole conversation again?  Stating that certain people were wrong about Wentz being worth moving up for in the draft  ≠  "OMG WENTZ IS THE GREATEST ROOKIE QB OF ALL TIME, WE'RE GOING TO DA SUPER BOWL"

 

[District of Columbia]

What the he'll does m

Yards per attempt

28th Wentz 6.57
25th Smith 6.88
3rd Prescott 8.35

Not too sure that's the comparison you want to make but that was a good effort from you.


Only Eagles fans seem to think it's shade to compare Wentz to Smith. Not a knock at all if you ask me.

I'm sure Dez Witten and Zeke have nothing to do with that stat [emoji]129300[/emoji] Foh

 

[sb]

sb

Sorry I stole your favorite emoji

I promise I wont use it anymore

View media item 2237302

 

[District of Columbia]

If someone thinks 3200 yards and 16 TDs is good, that's their prerogative.

The chiefs just won what 12 straight regular season games with him right ? In the era of QBs like Jay Cutler and Fitzpatrick Smith isn't a bad QB. He might have a ceiling as to how far he can lead you but wen I think Bad I think of the QBs said above

 

[sb]

must win game this week against the chefs. trev, pls

 

[HNL HI]

 

I mean, I get it.  ESPN went crazy with the comparisons three weeks in, and some Eagle fans (none on this board, as far as I know) may have gotten a little extra happy getting T-shirts made and the whole Wentzmania crap, but y'all have been watching football long enough to know how this goes.

You got it. You guys were so annoying about how good he was the first couple weeks that this slander should be expected.

that's all it looks like to me, the very ones who propped him up need to take some slander. doubt anyone really thinks he's a bust.