well I'll just name a few of the softer scents I use, that'll allow you to spray a few times without worry.
-Jean Paul Gaultier should be in every man's stash. It's my personal favorite. Women loooove this.
-Armani Attitude is another scent that is very clutch.
-Yves Saint Laurant. I actually prefer the dark, but for you, given that you have polo blue, I say the light is a good choice.
- Givenchy Play Extreme is another one of my personal favorites. Very nice scent, somewhat light so a few sprays definitely wont hurt. Women love it.
- Usher VIP is a solid scent as well.
I have close to 60 bottles of colognes, been wearing it since I was a kid. So I have good experience with alot of different scents, so I can be a good reviewer if you have any questions. We, as men, want women that smell good. Well those women that smell good, would like that reciprocated.