Who's had a better track record with women: DiCaprio or Jeter?

[morningstar7777]

Leo wins with Bar Refaeli alone, and did we forget Gisselle?

 

[Shanegerous]

gotta go with Derek

 

[mastamind033]

Leo and his list is just going to be get more impressive. Jeter is settling down while Leo switches it up constantly and still has my whole generation's females still in love with his Titanic character.

 

[limonyfresh]

Jeter by a slim margin (Alba, Lima, Kelly). Leo bagged a slew of supermodels though (Bar, Gisele ect).

 

[mastamind89]

Jeter takes it

 

[CP1708]

Better argument, Jeter or Justin? 

Justin had PRIME Britney  I'm talkin 21-22 year old Britney. 

Biel
Scarlett
Cameron  (deduct points off this if you wish)
Potentially Mila (

)
and a few others I am forgetting. 

I think Jeter still wins, but Justin is closer than Leo is imo. 

 

[chicagokid23]

nah Jeter got this on the strength of Kelly, Lima, Biel, and Alba heading his list

Leo got Lively, Gisele, Bar, and Amber Valetta

gotta go DJ

 

[doublejs07]

Originally Posted by CP1708


Better argument, Jeter or Justin? 

Justin had PRIME Britney  I'm talkin 21-22 year old Britney. 

Biel
Scarlett
Cameron  (deduct points off this if you wish)
Potentially Mila (

)
and a few others I am forgetting. 

I think Jeter still wins, but Justin is closer than Leo is imo. 

Didn't Timberlake get to Beyonce too? 

*Also Janet Jackson (i believe)

 

[CP1708]

DoubleJs07 wrote:

---

CP1708 wrote:

---

Better argument, Jeter or Justin? 

Justin had PRIME Britney  I'm talkin 21-22 year old Britney. 

Biel
Scarlett
Cameron  (deduct points off this if you wish)
Potentially Mila (

)
and a few others I am forgetting. 

I think Jeter still wins, but Justin is closer than Leo is imo. 

Didn't Timberlake get to Beyonce too? 

*Also Janet Jackson (i believe)



Janet was a definite, not sure on Beyonce tho.  But I know there is more, my wife reads all that crap and she swears he has a better list than Jeter (I don't agree, but it's easily a solid A- list.) 
  

 

[mrmac9]

Jeter easy but all y'all shleep on Bow Wow (waits for the hate)

 

[wawaweewa]

Another man crush thread.

 

[jd214]

Jeter, Easy.

 

[bdavis5]

jeter no doubt.

 

[jkomorowski09]

there is just something about blake lively shes too fine

 

[proper english]

Jeter got at my top 5.

 

[baller23217]

you left gabi union off jeter's list too

 

[User 37837]

Justin bagged janet, beyonce and scarlett??

 

[mr kuter]

We need supporting evidence for the Beyonce claim. I never heard this.

 

[fenixconnexion.]

Jeter's life > dicaprio's

 

[gllahone84]

Leo is a hip hop dude and he doesn't seem to be settling down.

Plus his list has more of a variety.

 

[hella handsome]

This is like comparing Birdman to Jay-Z only with women

I'd say Leo. We don't know what lowkey chicks he's pulled

 

[malcala622]

Originally Posted by Noskey

Originally Posted by bkmac

Jaric
Adriana Lima

Winner.

FIXED

 

[justdunks]

^ Word. I go with Leo simply for the fact that he doesn't have an athlete body and is pulling A+ chicks.

 

[dt43]

Originally Posted by JustDunks

^ Word. I go with Leo simply for the fact that he doesn't have an athlete body and is pulling A+ chicks.

in that case, i'll go with Jeter because he wasnt in arguably the most popular movie of all time and is still pulling A+++ chicks..
also OP, your Jeter list is incomplete:

http://coedmagazine.com/2009/10/29/derek-jeters-slew-of-sloppy-seconds/

 

[beh235]

The Captain hands down, and I'm not even a Yankee fan. I'm a Mets fan and it's impossible to hate this man because of this lol. I had this discussion several times. Jeter can walk into a room with other famous dudes, have him show who their girlfriend is, and there is a good chance Jeter tagged it before dude sniffed her out. Must be a good feeling to say "oh that's your hot gf? Dude, I had her 5 years ago"

. That's G right there.