I'm a huge Eli supporter and I'll even say he's not HOF worthy... yet. The door has certainly opened though. He continues to have seasons like this and he can stroll on in.
Nobody IN NYC would say Eli is better than Peyton unless they were dumb.
But Peyton has been in a much better offensive system throughout his career so it really isn't fair to compare them.
David Carr is not doing anything with the worst running game in the league, one of the worst defenses in the league, and one of the worst offensive lines in the league.
pls go as well.