I'm a huge Eli supporter and I'll even say he's not HOF worthy... yet. The door has certainly opened though. He continues to have seasons like this and he can stroll on in.
Nobody IN NYC would say Eli is better than Peyton unless they were dumb.
But Peyton has been in a much better offensive system throughout his career so it really isn't fair to compare them.
David Carr is not doing anything with the worst running game in the league, one of the worst defenses in the league, and one of the worst offensive lines in the league.
pls go as well.
Well, look at career game winning drives and comebacks. The elites at the QB position are all up there. It's all about how you finish. There is no team that consistently blows teams on a regular basis, except for maybe the Packers this year and the Pats in '07. What is consistent is what QB's...
I don't even want to hate on Romo. He's a GREAT Quarterback. But he hasn't had the same success as Eli when it matters the most.
And that's what differentiates them.
And if Tebow keeps winning games in the 4th quarter during the rest of his career, does it in the playoffs, and wins a Superbowl, then there's no way you can say he's not elite.
Eli's mostly been in a running offense. The year he has absolutely no running game, he throws for 5000 yds and has...
What makes you elite is what you do in the 4th quarter. End of story. Who do you want with the ball with 2 minutes left to win the game. Eli is in that category and stats more than prove that point for me.
You're an idiot if you try and disagree.