Actually, no.
Phil's only "knock" was he was always "given" elite talent to coach with. At that point, with only 9 rings (

) he could do the one thing he never got a chance to go thru, a complete rebuild.
The 05 Lakers on up was a rebuild, we tore everything down after Shaq except one thing, an elite player the entire time.

Sort of cheating in a regard. But all that 08 team was was kids before the Pau deal and Fish comin back. LO was the only mid level player, age, talent guy after Kobe.
Bynum, Farmar, Turiaf, Sasha, Critt, Ariza were all little kids before they flipped Critt and brought Pau in. Suddenly they had 2 vet guys, with a role Fisher, and a gel guy in LO. Boom.
Add the year of experience of going to the Finals after playing together only from Feb 1 on, they were ready to go in 2009. They "rebuilt" in just 3-4 years, but with Kobe in hand.
Phil would have had a shot at a true full on rebuild if things go the way they do in my head. To me, LO gets flipped, Prince, gone, Rip, see ya, Vlad, Fish, Kwame, all sold/cut/traded whatever. 25 and under only for the LA Lakers leading up to 2010 in which case we try to land 1-2 pieces with our young guys to make it work. Coulda been Melo, Bosh, Amare, Joe Johnson, anybody and of course the big name guys from that class.
Who knows, maybe our pick in 09 is top 5, etc. Coulda been real interesting, and Phil would have enjoyed that, imo.