Nobody's feet are like yours, and if you hoop, nobody who is doing shoe reviews simultaneously has feet like yours and plays just like you do.
You can takeaway whatever you can get from any of these reviewers. And if you're smart, you're on here asking questions of other guys like
bballkid11
,
duke40
,
junjdm
or
Beeb2407
about how shoes work or don't.
And sometimes its about what isn't said. If you know all the hoopers who try out every shoe commented once saying the shoe wasn't good for x, y and z reason and then just stop commenting in the thread, that tells you something too.
But more importantly what I've learned over the years is that each shoe is built for certain players feet, and you should try shoes out because what works for you might not work for other people. Like I don't particularly care about Russ or Sabrina or Giannis necessarily. But the Freak 1s were great for me. The Sabrina 1s have been a mainstay for me. And Russ I actually can't stand, but his sigs and the takedowns work for my feet. So I ball in those.
Love Bron but can't ball in any Brons the way I like. Love KD's game but every pair of KDs I've gotten hurts my one knee. Jordans since the 34 have been somewhat reliable court-wise.
So at the end of the day, you just have to try them for yourself, if you're playing in them.