Raider fans like you kill me bro. Hue had the same players Allen had minus Dmac and a QB with no training camp and he won more games then Allen. Plus do you remember he didnt pick Breshnahan whose defense let teams score on us at an all time high. Hue was handicapped not just with his roster. Mark my words we will dread the day we hired Allen. He picked his coaches like no other Raider coach has had a chance to and fired them all after 1 year. Raiders deserve coaches will Swag like Chucky and Madden who did it their way with ego...not wimps like Allen.
Same players?
Lets start there. We lost Wimbley. Not the greatest, but he was our best pass rusher. We lost Routt. Again, not the greatest, but judging by LAST year, he was our best CB. Seymour got another year older, and another year slower. Jason Campbell is a pro. He had the SAME playbook the year prior. It wasnt that big of deal of no training camp as far as thats concerned. He also had a healthy DMC the first 7 weeks in a scheme that fit him. You see what happened when we had to rely on Michael Bush? He was GASSED by week 13.
And lets not count all the injuries that plagued this team last year as well on defense. We almost had to get Darrell Green out of retirement to help us out in the secondary.
Defensive scheme? I agree with you here. Al' s man/man zero blitz philosophy simply didn't work anymore. But then you question why the hate on Al Davis? This is one of the reasons why. He failed to adapt to the new way of the NFL. He thought his scheme would eventually work. It didn't. Don't think that was all Breshnehan. That was classic Al Davis Defense from top to bottom. Breshnehan was just the fall guy.
I loved Al Davis, and for what he did for the league and the sport. He was a revolutionary. Unfortunately, father time caught up and the last 10 years his whole thought process has been atrocious. Outside of Nnam, and MAYBE DMC, we haven't had a successful 1st round draft pick. Thats ONE PLAYER in 10 years that has been drafted in the 1st by this org that is still on the team. (not counting McLame) Thats a terrible track record. Don't get me wrong, I still think Al had an eye for talent getting some studs towards the later rounds, but his 1st round successes were terrible and their cap numbers KILLED our books.
On to contracts. Al overpaid EVERYONE. Thats fine and all when you're winning, but when you're not, and those players aren't performing, again, it kills your cap and franchise. Javon Walker, DeAngelo Hall, Routt, Wimbley, Tommy Kelly, Randy Moss, Seymour, Gibril Wilson, Jamarcus Russell, etc etc etc. Those are FRANCHISE KILLER moves.
Hell the computers in the facility were over 10 years old. The whole place was a mess and it all stemmed from Al.
Reggie has had a year and a half now to fix decades of issues and people want his head? Its ridiculous. I'm a realist. This franchise is long overdue for this overhaul.
And no Dennis Allen didn't fire all of his coaches. He fired stupid Knapp and his lame O line staff. Knapp refused to adjust his playbook to fit our needs. Was it a bad hire? sure, should have never been in the ZBS in the first place, but I'm willing to see if he can redeem himself. Our special teams was a hold over and was terrible. I'm glad that guy is gone. Everyone else is pretty much the same.