The Official Anime & Manga Thread Vol: 三

[kickvicisous]

Wasn't even aware of this but the Yu Yu Hakusho live action adaption is premiering next month.

Theirs also another live action adaption film for Saint Seiya that premiered on Netflix yesterday i think. Looks extremely weird, wonder what's next

 

[x Buddha Bless x]

There was never supposed to be a happy ending for AoT. That's what made it good IMO. The people that were upset wanted the trio to live happily ever after at the end, which wasn't possible with all the things Eren did. If I remember correctly, the author stated early on that the series was not going to have a happy ending. I'm glad they stuck with it.

It not being a happy ending was not the problem. The reaction I saw was it was not a good ending overall.

 

[groupb]

Akainu had better watch out.

 

[spiderjericho]

It not being a happy ending was not the problem. The reaction I saw was it was not a good ending overall.

Reading online about the discourse, and being reminded of some facts and musing on some of the facts from yesterday. Anime can be nihilistic and depressing.

One of the most depressing I saw was Technolyze. This was 3X worse than that.

 

[nako xl]

Although he was an idiot who felt like he had no choice, picking the nuclear option always felt like an overreaction to me.

It's been a while since I read the manga but as I remember it, he honestly could have let up at several points during his plan.

 

[Beruseruku Desu]

 

[smedroc]

Spoiler: AOT finale....

Eren da seed

 

[Armada]

It's been a while since I read the manga but as I remember it, he honestly could have let up at several points during his plan.

Spoiler

He for sure could've but he stated pretty clearly in the finale fate or not this is what he wanted as well. He wanted to trample the world he wanted to lash out and destroy everything. When he says there was no other choice he didn't mean no other choice to save his friends he meant no other choice to save his friends AND destroy the outside world which he really wanted to do so badly he was willing to jeopardize saving his friends

I had already read the manga but went to a watch party for the finale last night and one of my homies a super Eren defender was going through it last night

Started the finale going "don't worry guys its all Ymir's fault he being controlled by her"

dialogue about Ymir chose to side with Erin not the other way around

"he's really doing it to save the island he didn't want to kill all these people there's no other way"

Eren later admits he kinda did it for himself and did want to kill all these people

Whole night was just some of us going

And my one homie and a couple other still trying to shoot him bail like

Imma miss attack on titan 10 years what a journey the ride was worth it.

 

[spiderjericho]

That story makes no sense lol.

To quote Darknight

Spoiler: AoT Spoiler

Eren went out sad.

Japanese people love these insufferable character endings (Neon Genesis Evangelion, AoT, etc).

 

[2sappy]

That story makes no sense lol.

To quote Darknight

Spoiler: AoT Spoiler

Eren went out sad.

Japanese people love these insufferable character endings (Neon Genesis Evangelion, AoT, etc).

I felt that NGE wrapped up pretty well with the last movie. Shinji got a happy ending at least.

 

[Beruseruku Desu]

danger style

Oda better step it up cause right now Isayama #1 right now.

If Oda wants that spot he better make luffy mid diff Kizaru in round 2

 

[Beruseruku Desu]

 

[danger style]

danger style

Oda better step it up cause right now Isayama #1 right now.

If Oda wants that spot he better make luffy mid diff Kizaru in round 2

 

[smedroc]

It not being a happy ending was not the problem. The reaction I saw was it was not a good ending overall.

Unless you go the happy ending route it's extremely difficult to wrap things up in a satisfying way.

And let's be honest... people are probably more upset that the story has come to an end rather then how it concluded

 

[x Buddha Bless x]

Unless you go the happy ending route it's extremely difficult to wrap things up in a satisfying way.

And let's be honest... people are probably more upset that the story has come to an end rather then how it concluded

Yeah I don’t think that’s true.

You could still have a sad ending or w/e you want to call it and still end things in a satisfying way. This was just the lazy way imo. I don’t know about it being extremely difficult to do either.

And I never rated AoT highly so I know I wasn’t upset that it ended. If anything that’s one thing I’ve noticed with the new anime/manga fans overhype and overrate when they claim it’s the best. They don’t have super long runs and end cuz the creator is ready to move on.

 

[smedroc]

Yeah I don’t think that’s true.

You could still have a sad ending or w/e you want to call it and still end things in a satisfying way. This was just the lazy way imo. I don’t know about it being extremely difficult to do either.

And I never rated AoT highly so I know I wasn’t upset that it ended. If anything that’s one thing I’ve noticed with the new anime/manga fans overhype and overrate when they claim it’s the best. They don’t have super long runs and end cuz the creator is ready to move on.

It's all subjective at the end of the day. That's what makes it difficult. What you deem to be satisfying might suck to the next man and vice versa.

And the length of the run should be dictated by the story. I'd rather a the anime be concise opposed to having to skip through tons of weak *** filler.

 

[IATT]

Spoiler

 

[shogun]

eren been trash since season 1 episode 1.

 

[shogun]

The story got 10x more complex when it introduced ymir, the paths and being to access the past/present/future.

 

[DesD1]

Spoiler

He for sure could've but he stated pretty clearly in the finale fate or not this is what he wanted as well. He wanted to trample the world he wanted to lash out and destroy everything. When he says there was no other choice he didn't mean no other choice to save his friends he meant no other choice to save his friends AND destroy the outside world which he really wanted to do so badly he was willing to jeopardize saving his friends

I had already read the manga but went to a watch party for the finale last night and one of my homies a super Eren defender was going through it last night

Started the finale going "don't worry guys its all Ymir's fault he being controlled by her"

dialogue about Ymir chose to side with Erin not the other way around

"he's really doing it to save the island he didn't want to kill all these people there's no other way"

Eren later admits he kinda did it for himself and did want to kill all these people

Whole night was just some of us going

And my one homie and a couple other still trying to shoot him bail like

Imma miss attack on titan 10 years what a journey the ride was worth it.

Wow 10 years, **** put stuff in perspective, they took their time lol AOT still to 3 for me, ending and all.

 

[ihust1e]

now looking back.. who do yall think was actually the strongest character during Marineford in OP?

danger style

my vote goes to Mihawk

and its not eem close

 

[ihust1e]

ill catch that aot final season part 4 act 7 **** sometime this week

They milked it out too long imo. Ended up reading the manga like 3 years ago

Gotta catch up on JJK, Spy Family and Dr Stone. Think im like 3 weeks behind again smh

 

[smedroc]

Wow 10 years, **** put stuff in perspective, they took their time lol AOT still to 3 for me, ending and all.

I'm gonna be going through the reactions on youtube this week.

I know these guys are gonna be going through it

 

[Beruseruku Desu]

Spoiler: OP1098

Kuma wasn’t a step dad. he was the dad that stepped up

 

[DesD1]

I'm gonna be going through the reactions on youtube this week.

I know these guys are gonna be going through it

Week to be glued to the internet for sure lol