Originally Posted by
General Johnson
Originally Posted by SuperAntigen
[color= rgb(255, 0, 0)]Soo not to derail this thread or anything but I have a question regarding the term "Uncle Tom".[/color]
[color= rgb(255, 0, 0)]Why do people (within NT and outside of it) always use that term in an insulting manner? [/color]
[color= rgb(255, 0, 0)]I ask because I actually just read Stowe's "Uncle Tom's Cabin" for the first time last year and as far as I'm concerned, and to be honest, Uncle Tom was an inspiring character who embodied all that that good and virtuous in an age when, as a black man, he had every right to be wicked and vengeful towards his oppressors.[/color]
[color= rgb(255, 0, 0)]...[/color]
What made Stowe, a free white woman, an expert on the subject she wrote about?
It was fiction from a free white woman's perspective and I hate that people cite it as if it was some sort of accurate account of the times.
You can't possibly be serious with the first sentence in your reply--can you?
I ask because what you seem to be suggesting, with that first sentence, is that--one can only provide commentary on some state of being only if one has physically experienced said state of being.
That said, I suppose I can't write about the evil that rape is because, well, I have never been raped. Neither can I comment on the evil that American slavery was because, well, I myself was never an American slave. And I certainly can't write and/or comment on the concept of white privilege because, well, I am neither white nor privileged...right?
This is what you're suggesting/implying?
Furthermore, what does it matter who wrote it--racially speaking? Stowes' fiction along with Douglas' Narrative, (and some other papers/books I'm sure I have forgotten/yet to read), depicted for a very ignorant sector of the country, like nothing before had done during those times, just how cruel and inhumane slavery was. Lincoln himself stated that this "fiction" served as a key catalyst for the Civil War and yet, you want to write it off because it was written from the perspective of a "free white woman" who couldn't have possibly been an expert on the subject. Comon son...
Ohh and as far as I'm concerned, it was very accurate account of the times. After all, many of the injustices and evils Stowes noted as being experienced by blacks, could very much be found in the Douglas' Narrative-- a compilation of factual experiences by a black man who escaped from the slave south.
...