I'm a 8.5 in wingtips and a 8 with the loafers.
Loafers run a little big so half size down is standard. Though I have noticed that the loafers tend to run a little bit more narrow compared to the wingtips.
I've had the same problem too. The only loafer liners that I've bought that hasn't had that problem are these ones:
http://www.jcrew.com/mens_category/accessories/socks/PRDOVR~01397/01397.jsp
But they're way too expensive to buy multiple pairs for. Good thing I bought it during a sale with a...
Good find! Whats the sizing like though? I've tried the ones from J Crew (3 Pack) and often times they're too loose, bunch up easily and slip off sometimes when I'm wearing my loafers.
Finally getting around to posting pics of my 3 Lunargrands
Milkshake Suede Wingtips:
Navy/White Venetian Bit Loafer (Cole Haan x Fragment Design):
Woodbury/Orange Loafer:
By far my favorite shoes to wear esp since you can dress up and dress down. Milkshakes are passable for a workplace...
Also, I guess now is as good a time as any to introduce myself to this thread... Became addicted to the Lunargrands. Have the Milkshake Wingtips, Fragment Design Navy/White Venetian Bit and will be getting the Woodbury Orange Loafer pretty soon.
If I can find the Oxbloods for a good price...
It'll say not applied but if you see the discount amount, it says $10 and it definitely came through on my bill...
Though I did just try on the black/volt and it said it didn't work.