- 8,961
- 1,116
- Joined
- May 12, 2008
sillyputty WENT IN
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: this_feature_currently_requires_accessing_site_using_safari
Until new evidence comes along to either support or debunk
the conclusion, it stands.
We have only
recently been able to qualify it and apply measurements to it.
I'm saying that based on the claims for
the existence of a god, the conclusion is not supported. There very well COULD
be a god. But nothing you or anyone else has said supports that logically, or
with any substantial evidence other than them just WANTING it to be true.
Skipping over the proof doesn't make it more true.
Every idea ever
created may have been thought crazy but it started BASED on the idea of what was
already known
Spirituality is for all intents and purposes a flawed concept.Originally Posted by Nyota de la star
Is there is any reason why atheists tend to debate religion and not spirituality? Honest question.
But what you fail to see is that we are not debating. There is not debate. I've been convinced that GOD is real.Originally Posted by sillyputty
That we're debating something doesn't make it true. If that was the case then making women not vote would be the right thing to do, or killing gays....but we're having this conversation...Originally Posted by Supermanblue79
I like you sillyputty.Originally Posted by sillyputty
What you've done here is evade the necessity to support your conclusions.
Thats dishonest.
Try again.
I'm glad you've improved your life and the way you make decisions, but that doesn't mean there is a god.
What you're doing is giving credit to some other entity when in reality YOU are responsible for the improvements you've made in your life.
You say your god wasn't responsible for the lowest points in your life? Then its not god. Heres why.
If god is omnipotent then he can do anything.
if god is omniscient then he can know everything.
If your god isn't responsible for the bad things you've done or making bad situations or creating evil then your god isn't able to do anything. Therefore its not omnipotent.
If your god didn't know how sincere you were when you were at your lowest or doesn't know your thoughts before your pray then its not omniscient.
Therefore its not your god.
You may assert then i never said god could do or know everything...well why do you praise it so much if its less than universal and has limits?
Reconcile this notion.
OK...another lofty claim. Where was god when the average life expectancy was 40 years for men? Where was god when women died in child birth? Where was god when children died of cholera and other diarrhea like diseases? Where was god before we made levees to protect people from flood waters? Where was god when women are raped? Does god pick sides in a football game?
Its one thing to take advantage of science and the improved knowledge we as a society have these days, but its another to lie to yourself and say that god is responsible for all of this as "god" has idly sit around and watch people suffere while others have dedicated their lives through everything from engineers to doctors to improve the status of the experience of life.
Don't undermine the efforts of those whose work you take advantage of. I find that highly disrespectful, if not thing else. If you want someone to pray to, pray to that unpublished researcher slaving in a lab to develop more HPV vaccine.
If GOD doesn't exist, then there's no way that you and I could be having a conversation right now about HIS existence.
But we are having this conversation.
As far as praying to a lab technician working on HPV a vaccine...no thanks....doesn't that make not a BIT of sense to you?
You're asserting a god exists and because we debate it means that its true? How does that even enter your mind as a valid statement?
If you debate with your kid that his imaginary friend exists, does that make it true?
BTW, if you don't give props to that HPV tech, thats fine she'll just keep giving our future daughters a way to prevent getting cervical cancer....something we can effectively reduce to an incidence of ZERO. So much for god.
If GOD doesn't exist, then there's no way that you and I could be having a conversation right now about HIS existence.
Everyone always refers to god as a male...why is that? And what Silly has been asking you religious folk to do (that everyone seems to miss) is prove that god exists.Originally Posted by pookieman
If GOD doesn't exist, then there's no way that you and I could be having a conversation right now about HIS existence.
But we are having this conversation.
As far as praying to a lab technician working on HPV a vaccine...no thanks.
Originally Posted by foreveryoung
Until new evidence comes along to either support or debunk
the conclusion, it stands.
We have only
recently been able to qualify it and apply measurements to it.
I'm saying that based on the claims for
the existence of a god, the conclusion is not supported. There very well COULD
be a god. But nothing you or anyone else has said supports that logically, or
with any substantial evidence other than them just WANTING it to be true.
Skipping over the proof doesn't make it more true.
Every idea ever
created may have been thought crazy but it started BASED on the idea of what was
already known
Supermanblue79 wrote:
But what you fail to see is that we are not debating. There is not debate. I've been convinced that GOD is real.
You're not talking to my kid. You're conversing with a man that has seen, feels, and touches living proof of GOD in his life
daily.
And you did not say "give props to the lab technician, you said for me to "pray to" the lab technician. Huge difference there.
You're twisting what I've said to justify your own stance out of frustation. And it's me that you called dishonest
in your previous post.
Science is an exciting field, but there's one flaw. They'll all looking for the answers to their own questions,
when I've already found mine.
sillyputty dude you're trying to reason with people that can't be reasoned with..Originally Posted by sillyputty
That we're debating something doesn't make it true. If that was the case then making women not vote would be the right thing to do, or killing gays....but we're having this conversation...Originally Posted by Supermanblue79
I like you sillyputty.Originally Posted by sillyputty
What you've done here is evade the necessity to support your conclusions.
Thats dishonest.
Try again.
I'm glad you've improved your life and the way you make decisions, but that doesn't mean there is a god.
What you're doing is giving credit to some other entity when in reality YOU are responsible for the improvements you've made in your life.
You say your god wasn't responsible for the lowest points in your life? Then its not god. Heres why.
If god is omnipotent then he can do anything.
if god is omniscient then he can know everything.
If your god isn't responsible for the bad things you've done or making bad situations or creating evil then your god isn't able to do anything. Therefore its not omnipotent.
If your god didn't know how sincere you were when you were at your lowest or doesn't know your thoughts before your pray then its not omniscient.
Therefore its not your god.
You may assert then i never said god could do or know everything...well why do you praise it so much if its less than universal and has limits?
Reconcile this notion.
OK...another lofty claim. Where was god when the average life expectancy was 40 years for men? Where was god when women died in child birth? Where was god when children died of cholera and other diarrhea like diseases? Where was god before we made levees to protect people from flood waters? Where was god when women are raped? Does god pick sides in a football game?
Its one thing to take advantage of science and the improved knowledge we as a society have these days, but its another to lie to yourself and say that god is responsible for all of this as "god" has idly sit around and watch people suffere while others have dedicated their lives through everything from engineers to doctors to improve the status of the experience of life.
Don't undermine the efforts of those whose work you take advantage of. I find that highly disrespectful, if not thing else. If you want someone to pray to, pray to that unpublished researcher slaving in a lab to develop more HPV vaccine.
If GOD doesn't exist, then there's no way that you and I could be having a conversation right now about HIS existence.
But we are having this conversation.
As far as praying to a lab technician working on HPV a vaccine...no thanks....doesn't that make not a BIT of sense to you?
You're asserting a god exists and because we debate it means that its true? How does that even enter your mind as a valid statement?
If you debate with your kid that his imaginary friend exists, does that make it true?
BTW, if you don't give props to that HPV tech, thats fine she'll just keep giving our future daughters a way to prevent getting cervical cancer....something we can effectively reduce to an incidence of ZERO. So much for god.
If you noticed the thread title and original post, you will see that it mentions nothing about religion.Originally Posted by Nyota de la star
Is there is any reason why atheists tend to debate religion and not spirituality? Honest question.
Originally Posted by sillyputty
and you better hope that you're worshiping the right God.Originally Posted by iamsaikotic
Originally Posted by sillyputty
I don't even know why I'm even posting here again...
That image you posted there... nobody told you that you have to listen to someone who believes in a higher being. NOBODY! (see I can do it too)
You're the one trying to shake what people believe and have faith in. In retrospect... prove there isn't a God otherwise... I DON'T HAVE TO LISTEN! (or read)
... but then you're going to say I have to prove there is a God... but you can't prove there isn't... but I have to prove it first... but you can't prove it anyway... so
I will gladly live in my ignorant bliss that there is a God. Good luck with the rest of your life buddy and for your sake... you better hope you're right!
Originally Posted by sillyputty
Spirituality is for all intents and purposes a flawed concept.Originally Posted by Nyota de la star
Is there is any reason why atheists tend to debate religion and not spirituality? Honest question.
Its an attempt to suggest some sort of externality to ones physical existence. We are simply animals that think too damn much for own good.
You never give a second thought to the idea that your dog has a spirit and an aura or whatever...or a turtle...or an elephant.
Its always me, me, me, me... spirituality and religion is a narcissistic entity.
wanting to feel some connection to something is just twisting of a concept of some phenomena we don't understand. Advances in neuroscience show us how religious minds work these days. Sociology explains why some communities tend to be more religious than others.
Spirituality is an attempt to connect the mind to some sort of outerworldly concept for which there has never been proof of or evidence suggesting exists.
Things happen all the time we can't explain... I understand that...but asserting an explanation without evidence does not bring us any closer to the truth...even if that "truth" or validity isn't complete.
Originally Posted by NikeAirForce1
If you noticed the thread title and original post, you will see that it mentions nothing about religion.Originally Posted by Nyota de la star
Is there is any reason why atheists tend to debate religion and not spirituality? Honest question.
So far, the only reasons as to why some NTers believe that there is a god is:
I don't understand something, therefore God exists.
I was told believe that God exists, therefore God exists.
I made up God, therefore God exists.
The word God exists, therefore God exists
Science hasn't explained everything yet, therefore God exists.
Science is God, therefore God exists.
I feel something that feels like God, therefore God exists
God is, therefore God exists.
How is any of this compelling to you at all?
Some of you are using science to DISCREDIT SCIENCE!
Originally Posted by Nyota de la star
Originally Posted by sillyputty
Spirituality is for all intents and purposes a flawed concept.Originally Posted by Nyota de la star
Is there is any reason why atheists tend to debate religion and not spirituality? Honest question.
Its an attempt to suggest some sort of externality to ones physical existence. We are simply animals that think too damn much for own good.
You never give a second thought to the idea that your dog has a spirit and an aura or whatever...or a turtle...or an elephant.
Its always me, me, me, me... spirituality and religion is a narcissistic entity.
wanting to feel some connection to something is just twisting of a concept of some phenomena we don't understand. Advances in neuroscience show us how religious minds work these days. Sociology explains why some communities tend to be more religious than others.
Spirituality is an attempt to connect the mind to some sort of outerworldly concept for which there has never been proof of or evidence suggesting exists.
Things happen all the time we can't explain... I understand that...but asserting an explanation without evidence does not bring us any closer to the truth...even if that "truth" or validity isn't complete.Not true imo. And spirituality is far from narcissistic as it has more to do with "metaphysical connections" to other people, things and/or deities ("God").
Anyways, I just wanted to ask because atheists seems to be insistent on debating a man-made instituition (religion) as opposed to spirituality which in essense comes before
the creation of a religion.
Perhaps religion is a lot easier to attack because it is so grounded in humanity and yet claims to have connection to otherworldly forms. Spirituality does not claim to
be tangible at all. It just is.
Just throwing things out there though. Don't mind me.
lolwut. Magic doesn't exist, but we can still sit here and have a conversation about Harry Potter.Originally Posted by Supermanblue79
I like you sillyputty.
If GOD doesn't exist, then there's no way that you and I could be having a conversation right now about HIS existence.
But we are having this conversation.
As far as praying to a lab technician working on HPV a vaccine...no thanks.
Still of no interest to me at the moment.Originally Posted by sillyputty
The Apocrypha contains books NOT in the popular versions of most bibles. These are stories that include when Jesus was a toddler running around and terrorizing his home town and Joseph had to wring his ear and set him straight. These are stories with firebreathing dragons. I'm NOT lying. Read about it. You can find a copy in bookstores.
You should wonder why these books were left out. You should always wonder why other sects don't include parts of your bible? Why is the catholic bible different from the other texts? Why did the catholics change the word "virgin" to the word "young woman" in the re-release of the 2011 bible? Why are they changing the inerrant words of a "universal" book?
You say its not a priority but this is in fact the problem. You should care about what you claim is TRUE or not. I am showing you that you need to investigate these claims. I know more about the underlying tenets of your religion than you do...thats a problem.
You also believe that the world was created in 6 days? Why does god need to rest on the 7th?
Why does god work on a 7 day week? Is it not because jews started the arbitrary concept of working for 6 days then taking a break? Does god respect time-zones? When is the sabbath when its in Japan vs when its in America?
You're only focused on the "reward" you get for being a christian rather than actually being a christian. You pick and choose from your book that you don't even know the history of and don't care to know only because you want to focus on the parts that make you feel good and skip over the other inconsistencies.
I've read the bible. Twice. Once straight. Another according to a reading schedule.
All this poetic nonsense aside (i'm sorry but thats just what it is to me, not that its an objective assessment), if god does all this, what do YOU do? What are YOU responsible for? If you trust god so much why do you work? Why do you struggle? Why not just pray for everything to happen? Why not pray for a million bucks? Or a Benz? Or a model wife?
Wanting to believe in something doesn't make it TRUE homie.
Spirituality at its finest. And this what they just don't get. It so simple, though.Originally Posted by Retro23J
Still of no interest to me at the moment.Originally Posted by sillyputty
The Apocrypha contains books NOT in the popular versions of most bibles. These are stories that include when Jesus was a toddler running around and terrorizing his home town and Joseph had to wring his ear and set him straight. These are stories with firebreathing dragons. I'm NOT lying. Read about it. You can find a copy in bookstores.
You should wonder why these books were left out. You should always wonder why other sects don't include parts of your bible? Why is the catholic bible different from the other texts? Why did the catholics change the word "virgin" to the word "young woman" in the re-release of the 2011 bible? Why are they changing the inerrant words of a "universal" book?
You say its not a priority but this is in fact the problem. You should care about what you claim is TRUE or not. I am showing you that you need to investigate these claims. I know more about the underlying tenets of your religion than you do...thats a problem.
You also believe that the world was created in 6 days? Why does god need to rest on the 7th?
Why does god work on a 7 day week? Is it not because jews started the arbitrary concept of working for 6 days then taking a break? Does god respect time-zones? When is the sabbath when its in Japan vs when its in America?
You're only focused on the "reward" you get for being a christian rather than actually being a christian. You pick and choose from your book that you don't even know the history of and don't care to know only because you want to focus on the parts that make you feel good and skip over the other inconsistencies.
I've read the bible. Twice. Once straight. Another according to a reading schedule.
All this poetic nonsense aside (i'm sorry but thats just what it is to me, not that its an objective assessment), if god does all this, what do YOU do? What are YOU responsible for? If you trust god so much why do you work? Why do you struggle? Why not just pray for everything to happen? Why not pray for a million bucks? Or a Benz? Or a model wife?
Wanting to believe in something doesn't make it TRUE homie.
There is no problem. I'm not questioning what I already believe in. What's important to me is getting to know God on a more personal level. You knowing more about underlying tenets means nothing to me.
Your trolling me with this one. I already said I believe the bible is true. As far as why God does what He does, there's not a man on earth that can explain to you the complexities of God. You said yourself you've read the bible twice. "without controversy great is the mystery of godliness" applies right here.
Only focused on the reward lol. My reward is being in the presence of my creator for eternity and there is a process in order to be able to do that. Having read the bible you know this so you must also know that the focus is to be holy and acceptable in the sight of the Lord.
All condescension aside your asking things that you already know answers to and there isn't much that I've had a problem with you saying in all of your posts.
You appear to be telling me here that I'm only wanting to believe in what I said I believe in......no?
Originally Posted by il prescelto
srs question, why doesnt God help me out when I ask him for help? like, when im doing math hw?....for being all-powerful/omniscent/etc., he sure acts like a little $%#@
oh, and BasedGod > God
/thread
So then, how does one know whether god is providing answers or not? If I'm in a tough situation and I pray to god about it, when the situation is resolved, how does one know whether it was god that helped resolve the issue or whether it was something else? Is it always god? Did he just create us to be so incompetent that we can't possibly ever accomplish anything on our own and without his help?Originally Posted by Steinbeckballa
Originally Posted by il prescelto
srs question, why doesnt God help me out when I ask him for help? like, when im doing math hw?....for being all-powerful/omniscent/etc., he sure acts like a little $%#@
oh, and BasedGod > God
/thread
He's not not going to just write the answers down for you. There are resources that he placed for you to learn and study the math material. It's up to you to put in the work.